A wave of touching photos showing great moments in time is fascinating amateur historians online. The problem? They are not real — and might be clouding our view of the past.
Widely shared on social media, the atmospheric black-and-white shots — a mother and her child starving in the Great Depression; an exhausted soldier in the Vietnam war — might look at first like historic documents.
However, they were created by artificial intelligence (AI), and researchers fear they are muddying the waters of real history.
Photo: Reuters
“AI has caused a tsunami of fake history, especially images,” said Jo Hedwig Teamwise, a Dutch historian who debunks false claims online. “In some cases, they even make an AI version of a real old photo. It is really weird, especially when the original is very famous,” Teeuwisse said.
One photo shared on Facebook shows a pair of fresh-faced young men posing in front of an antique biplane: purportedly Orville and Wilbur Wright at the time of their first powered flight.
However, those are not the Wright Brothers.
Real archive shots from the time show mustachioed Orville and his taller brother Wilbur in flat caps, looking nothing like the blond pair in the sepia-hued AI image.
Among the images created using Midjourney, a popular AI online image generator, is a series of fake reproductions portraying the moment when the suspected assassin of former US president John F. Kennedy, Lee Harvey Oswald, was shot dead by Jack Ruby in 1963.
Other images on Midjourney purport to show the explosion of the atom bomb over Hiroshima, Japan, in 1945, the invasion of Prague by Soviet-allied troops in 1968 and even a vision of the Roman Colosseum in ancient times.
“They often focus on events from too long ago to have been photographed or on moments that are poorly documented,” said Marina Amaral, an artist who specializes in adding color to black and white photographs.
“This creates a risk of false visuals being accepted as fact, which could, over time, distort our understanding of history and weaken public trust in visual evidence as a reliable source for learning about the past,” Amaral said.
For now, Amaral and Teeuwissen believe they can still tell fake historical images from real ones just by looking at them.
AI-generated photos often have tell-tale glitches: too many fingers on a hand, missing details — such as the lack of a propeller on the Wright brothers’ plane — or, on the other hand, compositions that are too perfect.
“AI-generated pictures can recreate the look, but they miss the human element, the intent, the reason behind the photographer’s choices,” Amaral said. “They may be visually convincing, but they’re ultimately hollow.”
For Teeuwissen, “real photos are made by real people and there’s usually something that’s out of focus, or someone looks silly by accident, the makeup looks bad, et cetera.”
However, she judges it is “only a matter of time” before the quality of the AI image makes fakes hard to detect with the naked eye — a “dangerous” prospect, she said, which would amplify disinformation.
It is usually a serene two-and-a-half-hour ride on Japan’s famously efficient bullet train, but on Saturday, the journey quickly descended into a zombie apocalypse, with passengers screaming in terror. Organizers of the adrenaline-filled trip, less than two weeks before Halloween, touted it as the world’s first haunted house experience on a running Shinkansen. On board one chartered car of the Shinkansen, about 40 thrill-seekers were ready to brave an encounter with the living dead between Tokyo and the western metropolis of Osaka. The eerie experience was inspired by the hit 2016 South Korean action-horror movie Train to Busan, in which a father and
The space rock that slammed into Earth 66 million years ago at the end of the Cretaceous Period caused a global calamity that doomed the dinosaurs and many other life forms, but that was far from the largest meteorite to strike our planet. One up to 200 times bigger landed 3.26 billion years ago, triggering worldwide destruction at an even greater scale, but as new research shows, that disaster actually might have been beneficial for the early evolution of life by serving as “a giant fertilizer bomb” for the bacteria and other single-celled organisms called archaea that held dominion at the
NEW RECRUITS: A video released by Ukrainian officials allegedly shows dozens of North Koreans lining up to collect military fatigues from Russian servicemen Russian aerial strikes wounded more than a dozen and knocked out electricity for tens of thousands of Ukrainians overnight in attacks on residential areas as temperatures dropped toward freezing, Kyiv said yesterday. Ukraine also said it had targeted a crucial Russian explosives factory, about 750km from the border, in an overnight drone attack, while Moscow said it had shot down 110 drones, the largest attempted aerial barrage by Kyiv in more than two weeks. At least 17 people were wounded in an attack on Kryvyi Rig, Ukraine, including a first responder, the Ukrainian State Emergency Service said. “At night, the enemy attacked Kryvyi
PROPAGANDA: The leaflets attacked the South Korean president and first lady with phrases such as: ‘It’s fortunate that President Yoon and his wife have no children’ North Korean propaganda leaflets apparently carried by balloons were found scattered on the streets of the South Korean capital, Seoul, yesterday, including some making personal attacks on the country’s president and first lady. The leaflets attacking South Korean President Yoon Suk-yeol and first lady Kim Keon-hee found in the capital appear to be the first instance of the North Korean government directly sending anti-South propaganda material across the border. They included graphic messages accusing the Yoon government of failures that had left his people living in despair, and describing the first couple as immoral and mentally unstable. The leaflets included photographs of the