A pro-China network of fake and impostor accounts found a global audience on YouTube, Facebook and Twitter to mock the US response to the COVID-19 pandemic as well as a deadly riot in Washington that left five dead, research published on Thursday found.
Messages posted by the network, which also praised China, reached the social media feeds of government officials, including some in China and Venezuela who retweeted posts from the fake accounts to millions of their followers.
The international reach marked new territory for a pro-China social media network that has been operating for years, said Ben Nimmo, head of investigations at Graphika, the social media analysis firm that monitored the activity.
“For the very first time, it started to get a little bit of audience interaction,” Nimmo said.
The network’s messaging aligns closely with posts and comments made by Chinese government officials.
However, it is unclear who is behind the fake accounts, which posted more than 1,400 videos in English, Mandarin and Cantonese, Nimmo said.
One of the Twitter accounts, which had a following of about 2,000 users mostly from Latin America, also tweeted the messaging in Spanish.
The posts appear to target social media users outside of the US, gaining traction in Taiwan, Hong Kong and Venezuela — where Chinese and US interests have increasingly come into conflict.
“The overall message is: America is doing very badly. China is doing very well,” Nimmo said. “Who do you want to be like?”
The network used photos of Chinese celebrities on the accounts and, in one case, hijacked the verified Twitter account of a Latin American soap opera show to post messages, the Graphika report showed.
The accounts seized on the Jan. 6 insurrection in Washington as the US Congress met to certify the US election results at the US Capitol.
One video described the US as a “failed state” and another said that it was “running naked in front of the world” in the wake of the Capitol siege.
Three videos described the riot as a “beautiful sight to behold,” mimicking the language used in Chinese state media reports on the riot, the report found.
Relations between Washington and Beijing worsened under former US president Donald Trump, who launched an aggressive diplomatic and economic offensive against China.
That tension has played out on social media, where Chinese officials in the past few years aired pointed criticisms of Trump.
Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs spokesman Zhao Lijian (趙立堅) has been one of the most vocal critics of the US on social media, spreading a conspiracy theory on Twitter last year that COVID-19 began in the US, despite evidence that the virus originated in the Chinese city of Wuhan.
However, even after Trump’s exit from office on Jan. 20, the network has continued to push anti-US posts.
Some of the accounts have now pivoted to attacking the Democratic Party by accusing leaders of having a “one-party mentality” in videos posted to YouTube, the report found.
Other fake accounts have questioned the safety of US-approved COVID-19 vaccines, despite studies on tens of thousands of people that found no serious side effects.
“The safety of the ... vaccine was in doubt, but it was quickly approved,” one of the pro-China videos posted on Jan. 21 claimed in a headline.
Other posts praised China’s response to the pandemic, while criticizing the US’ ability to contain the virus.
“There’s this cherry-picking of narratives and events that make the US look really bad,” Nimmo said.
Last month, YouTube said that it in December last year removed more than 3,000 YouTube channels that were identified as part of Graphika’s investigation into influence campaigns linked to China.
The attempted assassination of former US president Donald Trump by a shooter at a rally in Pennsylvania has confirmed the worst fears of public figures warning that an escalation in incendiary political rhetoric on all sides could lead to bloodshed. US lawmakers and analysts have been voicing concern since the Jan. 6, 2021, US Capitol riot that increasingly bellicose campaign language was becoming a worrying contusion on the US body politic ahead of November’s presidential election. The danger was vividly illustrated in 2022, when then-US House of Representatives speaker Nancy Pelosi’s husband was attacked with a hammer by a far-right conspiracy theorist
A high-ranking North Korean diplomat stationed in Cuba defected to South Korea in November last year — just months before Seoul and Havana established diplomatic ties, the South Korean National Intelligence Service said yesterday. North Korean diplomat Ri Il-kyu had been responsible for political affairs at Pyongyang’s embassy in Cuba since 2019, tasked specifically “with obstructing the establishment of diplomatic relations between South Korea and Cuba,” South Korea’s Chosun Daily reported. Ri defected to South Korea with his wife and children in early November, making him the highest-ranking North Korean diplomat known to have defected since then-North Korean deputy ambassador to the
HIGH TENSIONS: Local media reported that police had fired into the air to try to disperse an angry crowd at the garbage dump, while investigators called for calm and cooperation A total of eight bodies, all female, have been recovered so far from a garbage dump near Nairobi, Kenya’s acting police chief said yesterday, after authorities a day earlier confirmed they had found more bags filled with dismembered female body parts, the latest macabre discovery that has horrified and angered the country. Detectives have been scouring the site in the Mukuru area of Nairobi since the mutilated corpses of at least six women were found on Friday in sacks floating in a sea of garbage. On Saturday, the Kenyan Directorate of Criminal Investigations (DCI) said that five bags had been retrieved from
A World War I veteran is the first person identified from graves filled with more than 100 victims of the 1921 Tulsa Race Massacre that devastated the city’s black community, the mayor said on Friday. Using DNA from descendants of his brothers, the remains of C.L. Daniel from Georgia were identified by Intermountain Forensics, said Tulsa Mayor G.T. Bynum and officials from the lab. The man was in his 20s when he was killed. “This is one family who gets to give a member of their family that they lost a proper burial, after not knowing where they were for over a century,”