A Changhua man has been fined NT$12,000 in a civil suit for calling a woman an “idiot.”
The man, surnamed Chen (陳), last year was involved in a quarrel with a woman surnamed Liu (劉) over right of way in a parking lot at a hypermarket in Taichung, the Changhua District Court said in its ruling on Friday.
Chen called Liu an “idiot” after she refused to move her car for him, the court said.
Photo: Taipei Times
He was fined NT$3,000 in a criminal case of public insult.
Liu pressed a claim for civil compensation, saying that Chen’s name-calling resulted in anxiety and depression, the ruling said.
She was frightened to drive or go out and was diagnosed with depression at Yuanlin Christian Hospital, the court said, adding that she was on sick leave for six months due to the condition.
Her monthly wage was NT$60,000, it said.
She sought NT$590,680, with NT$330,000 for loss of salary, NT$250,000 in solatium, NT$6,500 for medical expenses and more than NT$4,100 for transportation to the hospital, the ruling said.
Chen offered NT$50,000 in compensation in exchange for immunity from criminal complaint, but Liu rejected the offer, it said.
The civil compensation claim did not meet the principle of proportionality, he told the court.
The word “idiot” would not cause a target of the insult to have depression, while such serious mental problems from a one-off incident seems questionable, the ruling said.
Given that the two parties did not know each other prior to the incident, the defendant would not have known the plaintiff had a mental disease, it said.
As the plaintiff could not prove that her depression was a result of a one-off incident of being called an “idiot,” her claim for compensation for medical expenses, transportation and salary loss was groundless, it said, adding that NT$12,000 in solatium was proper.
READY: The CGA said it closely monitored China’s maritime exercise, deployed vessels to shadow the Chinese ships one-on-one and set up emergency response centers Chinese navy and coast guard ships have returned to China, signaling the end of a massive maritime exercise, authorities said yesterday. The Coast Guard Administration (CGA) released images it said showed Chinese vessels sailing north in rough seas past Taiwan on Thursday, on their way to China. “All the Chinese coast guard went back to China yesterday, so although they have not officially made any announcement, we consider it over,” CGA Deputy Director-General Hsieh Ching-chin (謝慶欽) said. Beijing has not confirmed the drills and the Chinese Ministry of National Defense did not say whether the maneuvers had taken place when asked at a
People can take the Taipei MRT free of charge if they access it at Nanjing Sanmin Station or Taipei Arena Station on the Green Line between 12am and 6am on Jan. 1, the Taipei Department of Transportation said on Friday, outlining its plans to ease crowding during New Year’s events in the capital. More than 200,000 people are expected to attend New Year’s Eve events in Taipei, with singer A-mei (張惠妹) performing at the Taipei Dome and the city government’s New Year’s Eve party at Taipei City Hall Plaza, the department said. As people have tended to use the MRT’s Blue or
PUBLIC TRANSPORT: As some roads would be fully or partially closed, people are advised to take the MRT, with services expanded to accommodate more riders This year’s Taipei Marathon, which has obtained its first gold label certification from World Athletics, is to be held from 5am to 1pm tomorrow and would have 28,000 participants. The race is to start from the Taipei City Plaza and would go through major roads throughout the city, with traffic control implemented from 6am to 2pm, officials said. The Taipei Mass Rapid Transit (MRT) system and New Taipei City MRT Circle line would start operating at 5am on the day of the race, they said. The race would cover Renai Road, Xinyi Road, Hangzhou S Road, Aiguo east and west roads,
Taiwanese professional baseball should update sports stadiums and boost engagement to enhance fans’ experience, Chinese Professional Baseball League (CPBL) commissioner Tsai Chi-chang (蔡其昌) told the Liberty Times (sister paper of the Taipei Times) in an interview on Friday. The league has urged Farglory Group and the Taipei City Government to improve the Taipei Dome’s outdated equipment, including relatively rudimentary television and sound systems, and poor technology, he said. The Tokyo Dome has markedly better television and sound systems, despite being 30 years old, because its managers continually upgraded its equipment, Tsai said. In contrast, the Taipei Dome lacked even a room for referees
RSS