After former US president Donald Trump said that Taiwan should devote 10 percent of its GDP to the defense budget, lawmakers, political commentators and military experts said that he was imposing a difficult demand on Taiwan and no states focused on maintaining a strong military would have the capability to do it.
Radio talk show host Huang Wei-han (黃暐瀚) on Facebook yesterday said that Saudi Arabia has the highest national defense budget at 6.6 percent of GDP, with Israel coming in second at 5.2 percent.
The US dedicates 2.5 percent of its GDP to military expenditure, he said
Photo: AFP
Taiwan would have to spend NT$2.6 trillion (US$81.7 billion) per year on the defense budget to meet Trump’s demand, even though it only has a total annual budget of NT$3 trillion, he added.
Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) Legislator Lee Yen-hsiu (李彥秀) said that Trump’s comments showed that he and his staffers’ understanding of Taiwan’s finances is far removed from reality.
Cross-strait relations are regressing, but the state has limited resources to distribute, she said.
Taiwan is not averse to spending money for its protection, but when the money has been spent, and the promised arms packages are repeatedly delayed, the public begins to question such expenses, she said.
Taiwan should prepare for the possible outbreak of war and seek alternative solutions to ensure that war is avoided, she added.
KMT Legislator Wang Hung-wei (王鴻薇) criticized the government for its meekness and silence, saying that while Taiwan would continue to work with the US, it should not allow such misguided notions to become mainstream as it would negatively impact the nation.
Taiwan People’s Party (TPP) Legislator Lin Yi-chun (林憶君) said Trump’s comments were just exaggerated talk geared toward boosting support for his presidential bid.
She said that Taiwan has limited resources and cautioned against hiking defense spending, as such a policy would not be to the benefit of the public.
Taiwan must consider how to rely on its own military forces to deter foreign aggression, Lin said.
The TPP’s stance on cross-strait issues is that Tawain should be prepared, capable and would not shy away from war, but it should not be actively bellicose.
Association of Strategic Foresight researcher Chieh Chung (揭仲) on Tuesday said that Trump’s unrealistic 10 percent defense spending demonstrated his unfamiliarity with the nation’s finances.
Chieh said that Taiwan’s GDP for next year is estimated at NT$26 trillion, 10 percent of which would comprise 84 percent of the nation’s expected annual expenditure of NT$3.13 trillion.
The increase would be six times the budgeted defense spending for next year, currently set at NT$476 billion, and would leave the government in deficit after paying the wages of civil servants, he said.
Chieh said that the defense budget has been boosted due to the Sea-Air Combat Power Improvement Plan Purchase Special Regulation (海空戰力提升計畫採購特別條例) and the Special Act on the Procurement of Updated Fighter Jets (新式戰機採購特別條例).
If Trump wins the US presidential election on Nov. 5, President William Lai’s (賴清德) administration would have to consider increasing military spending without undermining the overall budget, Chieh said.
Kuma Academy chief executive officer Ho Cheng-hui (何澄輝) on Tuesday said that Trump’s comments likely originate from Elbridge Colby, a senior defense official in his administration.
Colby expressed similar sentiments in an op-ed titled “Taiwan must get serious on defense,” in the Taipei Times on May 11.
“Given the massive disparity in military power in the Taiwan Strait, spending 5 percent of its GDP on defense should be the floor for Taiwan. Indeed, if its security and autonomy are at stake, why not spend 10 percent?” he wrote.
Ho said there is a consensus that Taiwan should increase its defense spending, but it should be a planned and incremental increase rather than a sudden spike that would jeopardize other government spending.
Additional reporting by Lin Che-yuan
Tropical depression TD22, which was over waters south of the Ryukyu Islands, is likely to develop into a tropical storm by this morning and pose a significant threat to Taiwan next week, the Central Weather Administration (CWA) said yesterday. The depression is likely to strengthen into a tropical storm named Krathon as it moves south and then veers north toward waters off Taiwan’s eastern coast, CWA forecaster Hsu Chung-yi (徐仲毅) said. Given the favorable environmental conditions for its development, TD22’s intensity would reach at least typhoon levels, Hsu said. As of 2pm yesterday, the tropical depression was about 610km east-southeast of Taiwan proper’s
RESTRICTIONS: All food items imported from the five prefectures must be accompanied by radiation and origin certificates, and undergo batch-by-batch inspection The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) on Wednesday announced that almost all produce from five Japanese prefectures affected by the 2011 Fukushima Dai-ichi nuclear power plant disaster would now be allowed into Taiwan. The five are Fukushima, Gunma, Chiba, Ibaraki and Tochigi. The only items that would still be blocked from being imported into the nation are those that are still banned from being circulated in Japan, the FDA added. With the removal of the ban, items including mushrooms, the meat of wild birds and other wild animals, and koshiabura” (foraged vegetables) would now be permitted to enter Taiwan, along with the other
A new tropical storm is expected to form by early tomorrow morning, potentially developing into a medium-strength typhoon that is to affect Taiwan through Wednesday next week, the Central Weather Administration said today. There are currently two tropical systems circulating to the east of Taiwan, agency forecaster Hsu Chung-yi (徐仲毅) said. The one currently north of Guam developed into Tropical Storm Gebi this afternoon and is expected to veer toward Japan without affecting Taiwan, Hsu said. Another tropical depression is 600km from the east coast and is likely to develp into the named storm Krathon either late tonight or early tomorrow, he said. This
Typhoon Krathon, a military airshow and rehearsals for Double Ten National Day celebrations might disrupt flights at Taiwan Taoyuan International Airport in the first 10 days of next month, the airport’s operator said yesterday. Taoyuan International Airport Corp said in a statement that it has established a response center after the Central Weather Administration issued a sea warning for Krathon, and urged passengers to remain alert to the possibility of disruptions caused by the storm in the coming days. Flight schedules might also change while the air force conducts rehearsals and holds a final airshow for Double Ten National Day, it added. Although