Legal academics have called on the Constitutional Court to exercise restraint when reviewing a case about the constitutionality of amendments to government oversight laws passed by the Legislature at the end of May.
At a discussion on Friday co-hosted by the Republic of China Constitutional Law Society, attorney and Soochow University law professor Nigel Li (李念祖) said the legislature should be allowed sufficient latitude in crafting legislation.
A judicial ruling shackling the legislative body’s operations risks undermining the democratic system, Li said.
Photo: CNA
He was referring to the case brought by the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) caucus, the Cabinet, President William Lai (賴清德) and the Control Yuan in a bid to reject oversight laws that took effect on June 26.
The Constitutional Court has already issued an injunction that halted enforcement of some of the revisions, including those that would have given legislators much broader investigative powers.
The amendments to the Act Governing the Legislative Yuan’s Power (立法院職權行使法) and the Criminal Code were pushed through by opposition Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) and Taiwan People’s Party lawmakers, who together form a majority in the legislature.
The DPP-affiliated petitioners maintained that the deliberation that led up to the laws’ passage were unconstitutional, arguing that there was a lack of substantive discussions and that ruling party lawmakers were deprived of opportunities to express their views.
The petitioners also sought to challenge the constitutionality of many of the adopted measures, including those expanding the legislature’s investigative powers and requiring the president to address the legislature periodically and answer questions.
However, Li cited the court’s previous rulings, saying the court had in the past shown great respect for the “principle of legislative autonomy” provided that the legislative process did not contain “manifest and gross procedural flaws.”
The Constitutional Court, when trying to arbitrate constitutional disputes between top government agencies, as in the oversight law case, should refrain from assuming a “too active” role, he said.
Instead, the Constitutional Court should adopt a “minimalist” approach, he said, suggesting that the court render a ruling limited to the specific issues of the case and avoid setting broad precedents.
Political science professor Su Tzu-chiao (蘇子喬) and law professor Yang Chih-chieh (楊智傑) expressed similar views, saying the court should refrain from excessive intervention in the ongoing disputes between the opposition-led legislature and the petitioning agencies.
Su, also from Soochow University, said the new measures requiring the president’s presence at the legislature to deliver an annual state of the nation address and then answer questions would not undermine the constitutional system.
Rather, they would provide an opportunity to “clarify” the confusion in the division of responsibilities between the president and the premier, he said.
However, Lai has maintained that according to the Constitution, the president is not accountable to the Legislative Yuan and that the head of state can volunteer, but has no obligation, to address the legislature.
Friday’s discussion was cohosted by the National Policy Foundation — a think tank affiliated with the KMT — and the Taiwan Administrative Law Association.
An undersea cable to Penghu County has been severed, the Ministry of Digital Affairs said today, with a Chinese-funded ship suspected of being responsible. It comes just a month after a Chinese ship was suspected of severing an undersea cable north of Keelung Harbor. The National Communications and Cyber Security Center received a report at 3:03am today from Chunghwa Telecom that the No. 3 cable from Taiwan to Penghu was severed 14.7km off the coast of Tainan, the Ministry of Digital Affairs said. The Coast Guard Administration (CGA) upon receiving a report from Chunghwa Telecom began to monitor the Togolese-flagged Hong Tai (宏泰)
A cat named Mikan (蜜柑) has brought in revenue of more than NT$10 million (US$305,390) for the Kaohsiung MRT last year. Mikan, born on April 4, 2020, was a stray cat before being adopted by personnel of Kaohsiung MRT’s Ciaotou Sugar Refinery Station. Mikan was named after a Japanese term for mandarin orange due to his color and because he looks like an orange when curled up. He was named “station master” of Ciaotou Sugar Refinery Station in September 2020, and has since become famous. With Kaohsiung MRT’s branding, along with the release of a set of cultural and creative products, station master Mikan
RISING TOURISM: A survey showed that tourist visits increased by 35 percent last year, while newly created attractions contributed almost half of the growth Changhua County’s Lukang Old Street (鹿港老街) and its surrounding historical area clinched first place among Taiwan’s most successful tourist attractions last year, while no location in eastern Taiwan achieved a spot in the top 20 list, the Tourism Administration said. The listing was created by the Tourism Administration’s Forward-looking Tourism Policy Research office. Last year, the Lukang Old Street and its surrounding area had 17.3 million visitors, more than the 16 million visitors for the Wenhua Road Night Market (文化路夜市) in Chiayi City and 14.5 million visitors at Tainan’s Anping (安平) historical area, it said. The Taipei 101 skyscraper and its environs —
Taiwan on Friday said a New Zealand hamburger restaurant has apologized for a racist remark to a Taiwanese customer after reports that it had first apologized to China sparked outrage in Taiwan. An image posted on Threads by a Taiwanese who ate at Fergburger in Queenstown showed that their receipt dated Sunday last week included the words “Ching Chang,” a racial slur. The Chinese Consulate-General in Christchurch in a statement on Thursday said it had received and accepted an apology from the restaurant over the incident. The comment triggered an online furor among Taiwanese who saw it as an insult to the
RSS