The Constitutional Court yesterday ruled that insulting public officials is punishable under the Constitution, while defaming a public office is not.
The court sent a case about criticism of an official back to the Taiwan High Court for a retrial based on the interpretation.
The defendant, Yang Hui-ju (楊蕙如), in 2022 was found guilty of contravening Article 140 of the Criminal Code after Yang allegedly paid people to post criticism online of the Taiwan Economic and Cultural Office’s Osaka branch over its handling of evacuations of Taiwanese from Japan following a 2018 typhoon.
Photo: Wen Yu-te, Taipei Times
Su Chii-cherng (蘇啟誠), who was director-general of the office at the time, committed suicide in his residence shortly after the criticism began.
Article 140 stipulates a prison sentence of up to one year or a fine of up to NT$100,000 for “insult[ing] a public official during the discharge of his legal duties or publicly mak[ing] insults about his discharge of such legal duties.”
The office was accused by members of the public of failing to offer aid to Taiwanese when Kansai International Airport flooded when Typhoon Jebi hit Japan in 2018.
Yang sought a constitutional interpretation, saying that Article 140 contravenes constitutionally guaranteed free speech.
At a discussion at the Constitutional Court last year, a Ministry of Justice representative said that insulting public officials was not a crime unique to Taiwan and that those working on behalf of the country should be protected.
The Constitutional Court said that Article 140 has two parts, one referring to “slandering or defaming a public official” and one to “slandering or defaming a public office.”
Regarding the former part, if defamation is immediate and intended to obstruct an official, it should be punished, which would not contravene Article 11 of the Constitution, it said.
Article 11 says: “The people shall have freedom of speech, teaching, writing and publication.”
However, people are entitled to question, criticize or comment on the decisions of an office, as this is a part of democracy and civic oversight, it said.
Even if a member of the public were to simply curse the office or direct vulgar language at it as a means of venting their frustration, it would still be within their free-speech rights, it said.
It is difficult to imagine public defamation of an office having any immediate or noticeable effect on public officials carrying out their jobs, so criminalization under Article 140 would contravene the Constitution, it added.
Additional reporting by CNA
SEND A MESSAGE: Sinking the amphibious assault ship, the lead warship of its class, is meant to show China the US Navy is capable of sinking their ships, an analyst said The US and allied navies plan to sink a 40,000-tonne ship at the latest Rim of the Pacific (RIMPAC) exercise to simulate defeating a Chinese amphibious assault on Taiwan. This year’s RIMPAC — the 29th iteration of the world’s largest naval exercise — involves the US, 28 partners, more than 25,000 personnel, 40 warships, three submarines and more than 150 aircraft operating in and around Hawaii from yesterday to Aug. 1, the US Navy said in a press release. The major components of the event include multidomain warfare exercises in multiship surface engagements, anti-submarine warfare and multi-axis defense of a carrier strike
Passengers aboard Korean Airlines Flight KE189 arrived in Taichung safely yesterday after a scare the previous day encountering uncontrolled decompression, which injured 13 passengers. Flight KE189 departed from Incheon at 4:45pm on Saturday bound for Taichung with 125 passengers on board. The flight was above Jeju Island when a fault in the pressurization system occurred 50 minutes after takeoff. Online flight tracker Flightradar24’s data show that the plane dropped more than 8,000 meters within 15 minutes, before it returned and landed back at Incheon Airport at 19:38pm. Thirteen passengers on board had a headache or earache due to the incident and were hospitalized. A different
China might seek to isolate Taiwan and weaken its economy through a “quarantine,” which would make it difficult for the US to respond and force Taipei to negotiate on unification, CNN reported on Saturday. Chinese President Xi Jinping’s (習近平) “increasingly bellicose actions” toward Taiwan have heightened concerns that Beijing would use its military against Taiwan, it said, citing a report by think tank the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS). However, China might choose to initiate a quarantine, rather than a military invasion of Taiwan, to avoid US involvement, it said. “A quarantine [is] a law enforcement-led operation to control
A new message broadcast on the Taipei MRT’s Wenhu (Brown) Line urging passengers to yield their seats to those in need, not necessarily elderly people, would be extended to other MRT lines and public transportation in the capital, Taipei Mayor Chiang Wan-an (蔣萬安) said yesterday. Chiang was responding to reporters’ questions on the sidelines of a news conference at Taipei City Hall promoting healthy walking. Several disputes over priority seats on public transportation have recently been reported, sparking debate about who qualifies to sit in them, as most of the cases involved elderly people asking young people to give up their