The Kaohsiung branch of the High Court on Tuesday commuted a local man’s death sentence to life imprisonment after a fourth retrial.
Liu Chih-ming (劉志明) robbed and killed a woman, surnamed Chen (陳), near Haluo Market (哈囉市場) in Kaohsiung’s Zuoying District (左營) on Dec. 3, 2014, the court said.
Liu had been riding a scooter to visit his former girlfriend, hoping to reconcile, court documents from previous trials showed.
Photo: Pao Chien-hsin, Taipei Times
He was carrying a hammer and planned to threaten her if she refused, the documents said.
However, he could not find his girlfriend, they said.
Later, he saw a woman who had just finished grocery shopping at the market and was getting into her car, they said.
He attacked the woman, surnamed Chen (陳), with the hammer, planning to steal the vehicle to continue his search, but a lock on the controls prevented him from driving it, they said.
Liu struck Chen on the head 13 times, they said.
Unable to take the vehicle, he raped the woman and took NT$2,000 from her purse, the documents said.
Police found the body of Chen, a retired teacher, in the vehicle, they said.
Liu was sentenced to death in all four previous verdicts.
However, after the Supreme Court sent the case back to the Kaohsiung court four times upon appeals, it ruled that Chen was a random target of Liu.
As Liu did not deliberately target her, his crime does not fit the category of “most serious crimes” according to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, the Kaohsiung court said, adding that the death penalty can only be implemented under such circumstances.
There was a lack of evidence — his confession to having taken the money notwithstanding — to show that Liu stole NT$2,000 from Chen, it said.
Moreover, it is difficult to be certain that he intended to kill Chen, the previous verdicts said.
The results of psychological assessments and pre-sentence investigations showed that Liu could be rehabilitated, so his sentence was commuted to life in prison and disenfranchisement for life, it said.
The ruling can be appealed.
A 10-year sentence for rape was established in previous rulings.
Chen’s husband, surnamed Chang (張), yesterday said that he would do everything in his power to fight for justice for his wife.
Liu cut the hammer shorter to make it easier to carry, indicating that he did plan to kill someone, Chang said.
Liu ascertained that his wife was alone, followed her and waited for her to get in the vehicle before acting, Chang said.
“Does that not count as planning” to kill her? he asked.
Chang asked why the Kaohsiung court said there was a lack of evidence that Liu stole from his wife.
It asked the family to produce evidence of the exact amount stolen, even though Liu himself admitted to stealing about NT$2,000 during the investigation, Chang said.
Moreover, a Kaohsiung Veterans General Hospital report said that there is a high possibility Liu could commit sexual offenses again in 15 years, while Kaohsiung Municipal Kai-Syuan Psychiatric Hospital said that he does not have mental health problems, all of which the court ignored, Chang said.
Liu has three lawyers from the Legal Aid Foundation, while Chang initially only had one from the Association for Victim Support, he said.
Even after hiring a second lawyer, he still has less representation than Liu, he said.
In countries where the death penalty has been abolished, there is often the option of life imprisonment without parole to ensure that perpetrators cannot re-enter society, but in Taiwan, a life sentence comes with the possibility of parole, which not only fails to provide closure for victims and their families, but adds to their fear, he said.
Taiwan is not ready to abolish the death penalty, Chang said.
Foreign tourists who purchase a seven-day Taiwan Pass are to get a second one free of charge as part of a government bid to boost tourism, the Tourism Administration said yesterday. A pair of Taiwan Passes is priced at NT$5,000 (US$156.44), an agency staff member said, adding that the passes can be used separately. The pass can be used in many of Taiwan’s major cities and to travel to several tourist resorts. It expires seven days after it is first used. The pass is a three-in-one package covering the high-speed rail system, mass rapid transport (MRT) services and the Taiwan Tourist Shuttle services,
Drinking a lot of water or milk would not help a person who has ingested terbufos, a toxic chemical that has been identified as the likely cause of three deaths, a health expert said yesterday. An 83-year-old woman surnamed Tseng (曾) and two others died this week after eating millet dumplings with snails that Tseng had made. Tseng died on Tuesday and others ate the leftovers when they went to her home to mourn her death that evening. Twelve people became ill after eating the dumplings following Tseng’s death. Their symptoms included vomiting and convulsions. Six were hospitalized, with two of them
DIVA-READY: The city’s deadline for the repairs is one day before pop star Jody Chiang is to perform at the Taipei Dome for the city’s Double Ten National Day celebrations The Taipei City Government has asked Farglory Group (遠雄集團) to repair serious water leaks in the Taipei Dome before Friday next week, Taipei Mayor Chiang Wan-an (蔣萬安) said yesterday, following complaints that many areas at the stadium were leaking during two baseball games over the weekend. The dome on Saturday and Sunday hosted two games in tribute to CTBC Brothers’ star Chou Szu-chi (周思齊) ahead of his retirement from the CPBL. The games each attracted about 40,000 people, filling the stadium to capacity. However, amid heavy rain, many people reported water leaking on some seats, at the entrance and exit areas, and the
BIG collection: The herbarium holds more than 560,000 specimens, from the Japanese colonial period to the present, including the Wulai azalea, which is now extinct in the wild The largest collection of plant specimens in Taiwan, the Taipei Botanical Garden’s herbarium, is celebrating its 100th anniversary with an exhibition that opened on Friday. The herbarium provides critical historical documents for botanists and is the first of its kind in Taiwan, Taiwan Forestry Research Institute director Tseng Yen-hsueh (曾彥學) said. It is housed in a two-story red brick building, which opened during 1924. At the time, it stored 30,000 plant specimens from almost 6,000 species, including Taiwanese plant samples collected by Tomitaro Makino, the “father of Japanese botany,” Tseng said. The herbarium collection has grown in the century since its