A New Taipei City high school rescinded a top art prize for a student after Internet sleuths discovered that an image generation tool was used to create the award-winning entry.
Fu Hsin Trade and Arts School, a private school with a renowned commercial art program, held a teacher-student art show on March 25 and April 2 to celebrate the 67th anniversary of its founding.
The top award in the digital art category went to the creation by a student, surnamed Lin (林), titled: Danao Longgong (大鬧龍宮), a work that aroused suspicion from other contestants and Internet users that it might have been generated by artificial intelligence (AI).
Photo: Screen grab from Facebook page
The competition’s rules do not allow the use of image generators.
On Wednesday, a YouTuber known as Boss Kuma published a video on his channel discussing the ethics of AI art, in which he criticized the competition’s judges for failing to spot AI content.
The Monkey King character depicted in the piece had deformed hands and feet, anatomically incorrect thigh muscles, and weird textures in its hair and bandages, which are common signs of AI art, he said.
“This is not just an AI-generated picture but one that has not even been touched up. I do not know what the creator of this submission went to three years of art school for. So pathetic,” he said.
In a Facebook post on Sunday last week, Fu Hsin Trade and Arts School said that following an explanation by Lin and repeated examinations by teachers with a professional specializing in the subject, Lin admitted to misapplying AI.
“The student and his parents have apologized and the awards will be changed according to the scores of the submissions,” it said.
Reports that the whistle-blower has received a major demerit is incorrect, the school added.
New Taipei City Department of Education said that it would emphasize the need for experts on the judging panel of art competitions.
New guidelines and tools for detecting AI art should be used for art shows and competitions, it added.
Schools are additionally reminded of the importance of teacher-student communication and using positive reinforcement instead of punitive discipline, the department said.
Tunghai University College of Fine Arts and Creative Design director Hsu Ho-chieh (許和捷) said that educators in the field of commercial art and design should acknowledge the rise of AI and change the skills they teach students to use accordingly.
Solid training in basic skills, and an eye for aesthetics and innovation are as important as ever, since AI art generators cannot be used effectively if the creator is unable to see and correct mistakes, he said.
Copyright must be understood and respected, as AI use poses significant risks of infringement, he added.
Educational institutions should be careful in writing competition guidelines on tools and media to ensure students understand the assignment, National Taichung University of Education professor Lu Shih-yun (盧詩韻) said.
Schools should do a better job of integrating AI art as a tool in the creative process and re-evaluate their definition of art to include the utilization of new technology, she said, adding that the use of image generation tools should be accepted as an art form.
The point is not to prevent students from using AI to make art but to teach them how to use it correctly, National Chiayi University Department of Visual Art chair Hsieh Chih-chang (謝其昌) said.
Creators can and should make use of AI so long as the work they created is unique and distinctly theirs, he added.
The US-Japan joint statement released on Friday not mentioning the “one China” policy might be a sign that US President Donald Trump intends to decouple US-China relations from Taiwan, a Taiwanese academic said. Following Trump’s meeting with Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba on Friday, the US and Japan issued a joint statement where they reaffirmed the importance of peace and stability in the Taiwan Strait and support for Taiwan’s meaningful participation in international organizations. Trump has not personally brought up the “one China” policy in more than a year, National Taiwan University Department of Political Science Associate Professor Chen Shih-min (陳世民)
‘NEVER!’ Taiwan FactCheck Center said it had only received donations from the Open Society Foundations, which supports nonprofits that promote democratic values Taiwan FactCheck Center (TFC) has never received any donation from the US Agency for International Development (USAID), a cofounder of the organization wrote on his Facebook page on Sunday. The Taipei-based organization was established in 2018 by Taiwan Media Watch Foundation and the Association of Quality Journalism to monitor and verify news and information accuracy. It was officially registered as a foundation in 2021. National Chung Cheng University communications professor Lo Shih-hung (羅世宏), a cofounder and chairman of TFC, was responding to online rumors that the TFC receives funding from the US government’s humanitarian assistance agency via the Open Society Foundations (OSF),
ANNUAL LIGHT SHOW: The lanterns are exhibited near Taoyuan’s high-speed rail station and around the Taoyuan Sports Park Station of the airport MRT line More than 400 lanterns are to be on display at the annual Taiwan Lantern Festival, which officially starts in Taoyuan today. The city is hosting the festival for the second time — the first time was in 2016. The Tourism Administration held a rehearsal of the festival last night. Chunghwa Telecom donated the main lantern of the festival to the Taoyuan City Government. The lanterns are exhibited in two main areas: near the high-speed rail (HSR) station in Taoyuan, which is at the A18 station of the Taoyuan Airport MRT, and around the Taoyuan Sports Park Station of the MRT
An alleged US government plan to encourage Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC) to form a joint venture with Intel to boost US chipmaking would place the Taiwanese foundry giant in a more disadvantageous position than proposed tariffs on imported chips, a semiconductor expert said yesterday. If TSMC forms a joint venture with its US rival, it faces the risk of technology outflow, said Liu Pei-chen (劉佩真), a researcher at the Taiwan Industry Economics Database of the Taiwan Institute of Economic Research. A report by international financial services firm Baird said that Asia semiconductor supply chain talks suggest that the US government would
RSS