The Taipei District Prosecutors’ Office yesterday filed to appeal the acquittal of former Chinese national Ho Jianghua (何建華), accused of setting up a spying network for China.
Ho was indicted in 2020, allegedly receiving funding and working on espionage activities for China, but was acquitted by the Taipei District Court in its first ruling in February.
The district court’s acquittal on the basis of “freedom of speech” was flawed, prosecutor Lin Ta (林達) wrote in the appeal, adding that it did not assess the clear danger she posed to national security and did not take her actions into account.
Photo: Screen grab from Facebook
Those actions include holding meetings in Beijing, receiving more than NT$400,000 in funding from the Chinese United Front Work Department, evidence of engaging in espionage, collecting personal information and subverting Taiwan’s democratic system.
The acquittal did not examine her efforts to develop a network for the Chinese government and the judge detached this portion presented in the indictment, Lin said.
In doing so, the court judge nullified the application of Article 2 of the amended National Security Act (國家安全法), which prohibits the “funding, hosting ... directing or developing an organization” for a hostile foreign state, he added.
Photo: Taipei Times
An investigation showed that Ho had established an organization for Chinese women and spouses living in Taiwan, drafted its charter and working programs, and led members in a visit to Beijing where they reported to Chinese officials and agreed to become a Chinese government-affiliated organization, Lin said.
The appeal said that Ho headed the organization, set up channels for funding from Beijing and initiated plans to execute several programs, one of which was to “identify personal details of Chinese nationals living in Taiwan” and “track their activities.”
Ho was supported financially by Beijing for these efforts and it helped fund events in Taiwan that aimed to entice Chinese nationals to attend, including Chinese spouses who have become Taiwan citizens, it said.
“Through these efforts and events planning, Ho would contact and recruit Chinese nationals in Taiwan to become members and work for her, further developing her organization. One of their programs was to collect personal details and sensitive information, and to report on those who are supporting Taiwanese independence,” Lin said.
Ho also instructed members to attend rallies and support certain parties and candidates during election campaigns, she said.
“Overall, from the evidence and observation of these activities, it can be deemed that [Ho] has contravened Article 7 of the National Security Act’s ‘intends to endanger national security or social stability’ on behalf of China,” he said.
“Based on an objective assessment, Ho had initiated, funded and arranged her organization in a way that leads to ‘clear and immediate danger’ to undermine Taiwan’s national security and social stability ... therefore, the district court’s ruling is flawed,” Lin said.
“Through the appeal, we can also use this case to start a legal discourse on the boundaries between national security and freedom of speech, and to clarify the requirements of ‘developing an organization’ on behalf of a hostile foreign state,” he said.
It is important to differentiate it from “freedom of speech,” a basic right protected under the Constitution, he said.
The justice system should have an accurate understanding of its fundamental principle and should not be used to protect every unlawful action, he added.
“In Taiwan, our citizens have freedom of speech, by which a person can, in political discourse, advocate for ‘unification with China.’ However, the person’s intent and actions must not amount to ‘colluding with China or other hostile states, in conspiring to destroy our nation’s political system as a democratic republic,’” he said.
“The courts must refrain from abusing the concept of ‘freedom of speech’ to grant an acquittal,” Lin said.
A decision to describe a Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs statement on Singapore’s Taiwan policy as “erroneous” was made because the city-state has its own “one China policy” and has not followed Beijing’s “one China principle,” Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs Tien Chung-kwang (田中光) said yesterday. It has been a longstanding practice for the People’s Republic of China (PRC) to speak on other countries’ behalf concerning Taiwan, Tien said. The latest example was a statement issued by the PRC after a meeting between Singaporean Prime Minister Lawrence Wong (黃循財) and Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) on the sidelines of the APEC summit
Taiwan’s passport ranked 34th in the world, with access to 141 visa-free destinations, according to the latest update to the Henley Passport Index released today. The index put together by Henley & Partners ranks 199 passports globally based on the number of destinations holders can access without a visa out of 227, and is updated monthly. The 141 visa-free destinations for Taiwanese passport holders are a slight decrease from last year, when holders had access to 145 destinations. Botswana and Columbia are among the countries that have recently ended visa-free status for Taiwanese after “bowing to pressure from the Chinese government,” the Ministry
HEALTHCARE: Following a 2022 Constitutional Court ruling, Taiwanese traveling overseas for six months would no longer be able to suspend their insurance Measures allowing people to suspend National Health Insurance (NHI) services if they plan to leave the country for six months would be abolished starting Dec. 23, NHIA Director-General Shih Chung-liang (石崇良) said yesterday. The decision followed the Constitutional Court’s ruling in 2022 that the regulation was unconstitutional and that it would invalidate the regulation automatically unless the NHIA amended it to conform with the Constitution. The agency would amend the regulations to remove the articles and sections that allow the suspension of NHI services, and also introduce provisional clauses for those who suspended their NHI services before Dec. 23, Shih said. According to
‘GRAY ZONE’ TACTICS: China continues to build up its military capacity while regularly deploying jets and warships around Taiwan, with the latest balloon spotted on Sunday The US is drawing up contingency plans for military deployments in Japan and the Philippines in case of a Taiwan emergency, Japan’s Kyodo news agency reported. They would be incorporated in a first joint operation plan to be formulated in December, Kyodo reported late on Sunday, citing sources familiar with Japan-US relations. A US Marine Corps regiment that possesses High Mobility Artillery Rocket Systems — a light multiple rocket launcher — would be deployed along the Nansei Island chain stretching from Kyushu to Yonaguni near Taiwan, Kyodo said. According to US military guidelines for dispatching marines in small formations to several locations,