The Ministry of Environment on Wednesday unveiled a carbon fee charging method that diverges significantly from what was widely expected and is less stringent on big emitters, attracting immediate criticism from environmental groups.
Climate Change Administration (CCA) Director-General Tsai Ling-yi (蔡玲儀) met with representatives from civil environmental groups at an event held by the CCA in Taipei on Wednesday.
At the meeting, Tsai said the carbon fee to be paid next year by big emitters would be their total emissions minus 25,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent (tCO2e), multiplied by the carbon fee rate (Carbon fee = (emissions - 25,000) x fee rate)).
Photo: Chen Chia-yi, Taipei Times
This came as a surprise to many of those in attendance as it had been expected that the carbon fee formula would be the fee rate multiplied by the whole amount of the carbon dioxide equivalent emitted for big emitters (Carbon fee = emissions x fee rate).
The CCA on Friday last week released the tentative outline of Taiwan’s future carbon pricing structure to be reviewed by stakeholders ahead of the publication of an official draft.
The tentative outline showed the carbon fee formula as total emissions multiplied by the carbon fee rate.
Big emitters were defined as companies whose direct and indirect annual emissions exceed 25,000 tonnes, the tentative outline shows. They were to pay carbon fees starting in 2025 based on their emissions measured this year.
An estimated 512 companies in the electricity, iron and steel, oil refining, cement, semiconductors, thin-film transistor LCD industries and all companies with direct fossil fuel emissions exceeding the 25,000-tonne threshold were to be subject to fees, the CCA said.
Wednesday’s newly publicized information amounts to granting big emitters “free allowances,” wholly at odds with what had been expected before Wednesday.
Tsai explained that the newly proposed formula is to prevent emitters from trying to avoid paying carbon fees entirely by reducing emissions to just below the 25,000 threshold.
There would have been a big difference between an emitter with 24,900 tonnes and one with 25,000 tonnes, which would have increased the incentive for companies to circumvent the regulations, Tsai said.
Based on Wednesday’s formula, carbon fees would exert insufficient pressure on companies to decarbonize, an Environmental Rights Foundation representative said.
For example, a 26,000-tonne emitter will now only have to pay NT$300,000 (US$9,672.43) if the carbon fee rate is set at NT$300 per tonne, much lower than the previously expected NT$7.8 million, the representative said.
The Society of Wilderness representative said if decarbonization is the country’s top priority, it is doubtful the current plan would make much of a contribution to ensuring firms work toward that goal.
The director-general said that of the estimated 512 big emitters, those responsible for most of the country’s emissions emit several million tonnes per year, and to them, the emission of “25,000 tonnes is like single digits.”
On the other hand, many small companies have total emissions per year of 25,000, 30,000 or 40,000 tonnes, mostly from electricity use, she added.
Such small businesses would be incentivized to use electricity more efficiently or use renewable energy if their annual emissions are only slightly above the fee threshold, Tsai said.
The CCA released the tentative outline as a pre-draft of an official draft of the regulations on Friday last week as this would allow for “wider communication with society and create a more solid consensus,” CCA Deputy Director-General Huang Wei-ming (黃偉鳴) said.
The meeting on Wednesday was the first roundtable discussion intended to facilitate wider communication.
In March last year, Chang Tzi-chin (張子敬), then-head of the Environmental Protection Administration (EPA), which was upgraded to the ministry in August last year, said about 289 big emitters collectively emitted 233.873 million tCO2e in 2021, accounting for about 82 percent of the country’s emissions.
The electricity utility companies accounted for most emissions at about 54.3 percent of the 233.873 million tCO2e, Chang said.
A report publicized by the Risk Society and Policy Research Center in June and based on information provided by the EPA, found that the top 30 enterprise-emitters, excluding electricity suppliers, emitted a total of 132.292 million tCO2e (including indirect emissions from electricity use) in 2021.
This included 10 from the petrochemical industry (49.06 percent), seven from the electronic components manufacturing sector (14.91 percent, five from the semiconductor industry and two LCD firms), five iron and steel companies (25.99 percent), four papermaking enterprises (2.8 percent), two cement firms (6.11 percent), one textile company and one glass enterprise.
Taipei and New Taipei City government officials are aiming to have the first phase of the Wanhua-Jungho-Shulin Mass Rapid Transit (MRT) line completed and opened by 2027, following the arrival of the first train set yesterday. The 22km-long Light Green Line would connect four densely populated districts in Taipei and New Taipei City: Wanhua (萬華), Jhonghe (中和), Tucheng (土城) and Shulin (樹林). The first phase of the project would connect Wanhua and Jhonghe districts, with Chiang Kai-shek Memorial Hall and Chukuang (莒光) being the terminal stations. The two municipalities jointly hosted a ceremony for the first train to be used
MILITARY AID: Taiwan has received a first batch of US long-range tactical missiles ahead of schedule, with a second shipment expected to be delivered by 2026 The US’ early delivery of long-range tactical ballistic missiles to Taiwan last month carries political and strategic significance, a military source said yesterday. According to the Ministry of National Defense’s budget report, the batch of military hardware from the US, including 11 sets of M142 High Mobility Artillery Rocket Systems (HIMARS) and 64 MGM-140 Army Tactical Missile Systems, had been scheduled to be delivered to Taiwan between the end of this year and the beginning of next year. However, the first batch arrived last month, earlier than scheduled, with the second batch —18 sets of HIMARS, 20 MGM-140 missiles and 864 M30
Representative to the US Alexander Yui delivered a letter from the government to US president-elect Donald Trump during a meeting with a former Trump administration official, CNN reported yesterday. Yui on Thursday met with former US national security adviser Robert O’Brien over a private lunch in Salt Lake City, Utah, with US Representative Chris Stewart, the Web site of the US cable news channel reported, citing three sources familiar with the matter. “During that lunch the letter was passed along, and then shared with Trump, two of the sources said,” CNN said. O’Brien declined to comment on the lunch, as did the Taipei
A woman who allegedly attacked a high-school student with a utility knife, injuring his face, on a Taipei metro train late on Friday has been transferred to prosecutors, police said yesterday. The incident occurred near MRT Xinpu Station at about 10:17pm on a Bannan Line train headed toward Dingpu, New Taipei City police said. Before police arrived at the station to arrest the suspect, a woman surnamed Wang (王) who is in her early 40s, she had already been subdued by four male passengers, one of whom was an off-duty Taipei police officer, police said. The student, 17, who sustained a cut about
RSS