The New Taipei District Court has upheld its rejection of a request for state compensation from the parents of a two-year-old boy who died from complications related to COVID-19 following an 81-minute wait for an ambulance in April last year, the lawyer of the plaintiff said on Saturday.
The lawyer, Wang Miao-hua (王妙華), said the court has determined that the previous ruling made in July was in accordance with legal provisions, and that the appeal from En En’s (恩恩) parents was “neither justifiable nor legal.”
Wang did not specify the date of the final ruling, but mentioned that the parents received the court document on Oct. 30.
Photo: Chen Wei-tzu, Taipei Times
Since the case was handled in a small claims trial, it would not reach a higher court, Wang said on behalf of En En’s family, adding that the father, surnamed Lin (林), was disappointed at the outcome.
Lin’s purpose in bringing the case to court was to seek the truth, and having exhausted all legal avenues now, he respected the ruling but hoped the tragedy would not be repeated, Wang said.
In the first ruling, the court rejected the claim on the grounds that Lin had not provided medical data to establish a causal relationship between his son’s death and government officials’ handling of the ambulance request.
For a claim of state compensation to be established, the case has to involve government officials infringing the freedom and rights of the people through intentional or negligent actions or failure to carry out their duties, the court said.
Lin argued in his appeal that the family is entitled to state compensation since it could adequately prove the harm suffered based on “rule of thumb and social norms.”
In this case, the severe pain they endured had constituted a substantial loss, Lin said, adding that the court failed to take that into consideration in the first ruling.
The court decided that Lin’s points did not stand up and dismissed the appeal without oral argument.
Lin’s son was the first child in Taiwan to die from COVID-19, on April 19 last year. He developed severe COVID-19 symptoms and fell into a coma at home in Jhonghe District (中和) on April 14, just as COVID-19 cases in the country were beginning to surge.
According to the results of an investigation into the case by the now-disbanded Central Epidemic Command Center (CECC), which were released on July 5 last year, En En’s mother first called the city’s fire department to request an ambulance for her son at 5:59pm on April 14.
The city government dispatched an ambulance at 7:06 pm and it arrived at En En’s home and the hospital at 7:20pm and 7:27pm respectively, the report stated.
According to the phone records between agencies, New Taipei City Fire Department was not able to contact the Department of Health, which served at the time as the city’s ambulance dispatch center, to arrange an ambulance until 6:25pm.
The phone records were leaked to the media in June last year, following Lin’s failed requests the previous month for access to them, prompting the CECC to investigate the case.
The hospital said at that time that the boy died of brain stem encephalitis resulting from septicemia that was triggered by the COVID-19 infection, attributing the cause of his death to the rapid deterioration of his condition after he developed severe symptoms.
However, medical authorities have never determined whether a faster response to the ambulance request might have saved the child’s life.
In November last year, Lin filed a compensation lawsuit against the city government, and the city’s fire and health departments, after his demand for a symbolic NT$1 in compensation from each of the three agencies was rejected by the government in September of the same year.
SCENARIOS: A potential conflict with Beijing would not be similar to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, and China would target energy and food supplies, a researcher said China is likely to continue using economic and cyberoperations against Taiwan to force it to capitulate without resorting to a military attack, Fox News reported yesterday, citing the outcome of a tabletop exercise. Washington-based think tank the Foundation for Defense of Democracies (FDD) earlier this month held a tabletop exercise in Taipei focusing on Beijing’s use of economic and cybercoercion against Taiwan. The FDD mentioned an “anaconda strategy,” in which Beijing would likely use cyberwarfare and disinformation campaigns followed by a blockade or other measures to strangulate Taiwan, rather than attempting an invasion, the report said. A large-scale cyberattack would be
HSINCHU CASES: Five people among 35 who were reported being sick were still in hospital after eating at a vendor in a market in Jhubei, the local health agency said Thirty-five people have sought medical treatment for acute symptoms after allegedly eating banh mi (Vietnamese sandwiches) from a vendor in Jhubei City (竹北), the Hsinchu County Public Health Bureau said yesterday. The bureau said that since Saturday, it has received several reports of suspected food poisoning from hospitals. The vendor has been ordered to temporarily suspend its business, it said, adding that tests were being conducted to determine whether the people had food poisoning, with results expected in about two weeks. A preliminary investigation showed that the people who sought treatment had recently eaten banh mi at a vendor at a retail market
GOOD MODEL: Speaking at his book launch, Law said that Taiwan is the most democratic Chinese-speaking country, which is why Hong Kongers relocated here China has suffocated Hong Kong’s civil society and its next target could be Taiwan, Nathan Law (羅冠聰), cofounder of the disbanded pro-democracy Hong Kong political party Demosisto, said in Taipei yesterday. Law made the remarks at a launch in Taipei for his book When the Wind Blows — the Struggles for Freedom of Hong Kong (時代推著我們前行:羅冠聰的香港備忘錄). Law has been living in the UK since he fled Hong Kong in 2020, and the book is about his fighting for the cause of freedom in the area. He was granted political asylum in 2021. “Fleeing is a long and distressing process, but it also
IMITATING OTHERS? Tsai Ing-wen’s office said the former president rents a commercial unit for her personal office and had never used election funds to purchase real estate Taiwan People’s Party (TPP) Chairman Ko Wen-je (柯文哲) yesterday confirmed that he used about NT$43 million (US$1.35 million) from his presidential election subsidy to purchase an office unit near the Legislative Yuan in May. Ko made the remarks after Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) Taipei City Councilor Lin Yen-feng (林延鳳) earlier in the day told a news conference that she received a tip-off that the TPP chairman had purchased a 48.76 ping (161.2m2) office unit at Jinan Building (濟南大樓), a commercial building in Taipei’s Zhongzheng District (中正). Lin said that Ko purchased the unit on May 10, paying about NT$43 million in cash,