The High Court earlier this month overturned a ruling ordering a man to pay NT$4,000 to a woman he called “ugly,” saying that the insult would not harm the plaintiff, as the man is not an authority on aesthetics.
The incident occurred at a Taipei department store in June 2021 during an argument between two clerks at neighboring shops.
A merchant surnamed Cheng (鄭) later sued the other merchant, surnamed Lee (李), for calling her an “ugly woman,” citing Article 309 of the Criminal Code, which prohibits public insult.
Photo: Yang Kuo-wen, Taipei Times
In the first ruling, the Taipei District Court ordered Lee to pay Cheng NT$4,000, as his comment “disrespected [Cheng’s] reputation and interests.”
Lee appealed to the High Court, which on Feb. 8 overturned the earlier ruling.
Calling someone ugly is an expression of personal aesthetic opinion and cannot be judged according to a standard, the court said.
It further cited the psychological concepts of “aesthetic fluency” and the “pleasure-interest model of aesthetic liking” to explain how the brain consciously processes aesthetics.
As Lee does not possess any expertise in aesthetic criticism, nor has any social capital in the field, the court ruled that his comment “only reflects the functioning of his individual mind and does not have authoritative social credibility.”
As such, it would not persuade or incite others, and therefore would not harm Cheng’s reputation, it said.
The court also said that from the content of their argument, it is impossible to determine whether Lee intentionally delivered an insult, even though the phrase angered Cheng.
The case has generated significant interest in the legal community as to whether calling someone ugly or actions such as giving someone the middle finger constitute a crime.
Similar cases cross the court docket regularly. The Taipei District Prosecutors’ Office said it receives about a dozen per month.
Some have photographic evidence showing the defendant pointing and looking at the plaintiff, while others are difficult to prove the insult was directed at a particular person.
The public insult clause in the Criminal Code stipulates a punishment of “short-term imprisonment” or a fine of up to NT$9,000.
The insult must also be public to be considered a crime, which in legal terms means a place where someone other than the person or people being accused can bear witness, attorney Ting Yu-jen (丁昱仁) said.
For instance, if someone shows someone else the middle finger on a street, it would be considered public because a third party could come by at any time, even if there were no witnesses to the incident itself, Ting said.
An insult is determined by whether there was the subjective intent to belittle another person, he said.
The law is intended to protect the “right of fame,” or the right to human dignity and reputation, Ting said.
It is expressed through the respect that people deserve in the process of social interaction, meaning that giving the middle finger is the same as cursing and would constitute a crime, he added.
WANG RELEASED: A police investigation showed that an organized crime group allegedly taught their clients how to pretend to be sick during medical exams Actor Darren Wang (王大陸) and 11 others were released on bail yesterday, after being questioned for allegedly dodging compulsory military service or forging documents to help others avoid serving. Wang, 33, was catapulted into stardom for his role in the coming-of-age film Our Times (我的少女時代). Lately, he has been focusing on developing his entertainment career in China. The New Taipei District Prosecutors’ Office last month began investigating an organized crime group that is allegedly helping men dodge compulsory military service using falsified documents. Police in New Taipei City Yonghe Precinct at the end of last month arrested the main suspect,
LITTORAL REGIMENTS: The US Marine Corps is transitioning to an ‘island hopping’ strategy to counterattack Beijing’s area denial strategy The US Marine Corps (USMC) has introduced new anti-drone systems to bolster air defense in the Pacific island chain amid growing Chinese military influence in the region, The Telegraph reported on Sunday. The new Marine Air Defense Integrated System (MADIS) Mk 1 is being developed to counter “the growing menace of unmanned aerial systems,” it cited the Marine Corps as saying. China has constructed a powerful defense mechanism in the Pacific Ocean west of the first island chain by deploying weapons such as rockets, submarines and anti-ship missiles — which is part of its anti-access/area denial (A2/AD) strategy against adversaries — the
Eleven people, including actor Darren Wang (王大陸), were taken into custody today for questioning regarding the evasion of compulsory military service and document forgery, the New Taipei District Prosecutors’ Office said. Eight of the people, including Wang, are suspected of evading military service, while three are suspected of forging medical documents to assist them, the report said. They are all being questioned by police and would later be transferred to the prosecutors’ office for further investigation. Three men surnamed Lee (李), Chang (張) and Lin (林) are suspected of improperly assisting conscripts in changing their military classification from “stand-by
Former Taiwan People’s Party chairman Ko Wen-je (柯文哲) may apply to visit home following the death of his father this morning, the Taipei Detention Center said. Ko’s father, Ko Cheng-fa (柯承發), passed away at 8:40am today at the Hsinchu branch of National Taiwan University Hospital. He was 94 years old. The center said Ko Wen-je was welcome to apply, but declined to say whether it had already received an application. The center also provides psychological counseling to people in detention as needed, it added, also declining to comment on Ko Wen-je’s mental state. Ko Wen-je is being held in detention as he awaits trial
RSS