The Supreme Administrative Court last week rejected an appeal in a case from 2018, in which a man surnamed Wu (吳) had a wristwatch valued at NT$4.5 million (US$146,513) confiscated by customs officers for failing to declare the watch when entering the country.
Wu, a Taiwanese citizen who was living in Malaysia, had been asked by a friend surnamed Ling (凌) — a Malaysian citizen — to bring the Richard Mille watch with him for repairs when Wu visited Taiwan. Customs Administration officials confiscated the watch, saying Wu had not declared it, and that all items exceeding NT$20,000 in value must be declared.
Wu argued that, according to Article 52 of the Customs Act (關稅法), items imported for repair or refurbishment are exempt from customs duties.
Photo: Yang Kuo-wen, Taipei Times
However, the Supreme Administrative Court said that Wu had not submitted paperwork registering the watch as an item being imported for repair, or paid the required deposit for items listed under the article.
The watch had originally been purchased by Ling in June 2018 at the Richard Mille store at the Mandarin Oriental hotel in Taipei. Ling applied for a tax exemption on the watch when he returned to Malaysia in September, court documents said.
After noticing that the watch was not keeping accurate time, Ling contacted the Richard Mille store using Line, and was told the watch appeared to be broken, but he could bring it in for repairs.
Ling then asked Wu, who was returning to Taiwan for a visit in October, to take the watch with him to Taiwan so it could be repaired.
Wu had the watch in his suitcase when he was stopped at the airport’s “nothing to declare” line, and customs officers confiscated the watch according to Article 39 of the Customs Anti-smuggling Act (海關緝私條例).
Wu questioned the confiscation of the watch, arguing that it was clearly a used item.
However, he was told that even used, the watch had a market value of more than NT$3.3 million, and that it would have to be either declared or registered as an item for repair.
Wu filed an administrative lawsuit, and submitted records of the conversations between himself and Ling, and between Ling and the Richard Mille store, as well as the purchase receipt and repair order.
The Supreme Administrative Court argued that signage throughout the airport makes it clear that all items valued over NT$20,000 must be declared when entering the country, and upheld the earlier ruling by the Taipei High Administrative Court that the item would remain confiscated.
Civil society groups yesterday protested outside the Legislative Yuan, decrying Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) efforts to pass three major bills that they said would seriously harm Taiwan’s democracy, and called to oust KMT caucus whip Fu Kun-chi (傅?萁). It was the second night of the three-day “Bluebird wintertime action” protests in Taipei, with organizers announcing that 8,000 people attended. Organized by Taiwan Citizen Front, the Economic Democracy Union (EDU) and a coalition of civil groups, about 6,000 people began a demonstration in front of KMT party headquarters in Taipei on Wednesday, organizers said. For the third day, the organizers asked people to assemble
POOR IMPLEMENTATION: Teachers welcomed the suspension, saying that the scheme disrupted school schedules, quality of learning and the milk market A policy to offer free milk to all school-age children nationwide is to be suspended next year due to multiple problems arising from implementation of the policy, the Executive Yuan announced yesterday. The policy was designed to increase the calcium intake of school-age children in Taiwan by drinking milk, as more than 80 percent drink less than 240ml per day. The recommended amount is 480ml. It was also implemented to help Taiwanese dairy farmers counter competition from fresh milk produced in New Zealand, which is to be imported to Taiwan tariff-free next year when the Agreement Between New Zealand and
A woman who allegedly spiked the food and drinks of an Australian man with rat poison, leaving him in intensive care, has been charged with attempted murder, the Taipei District Prosecutors’ Office said yesterday. The woman, identified by her surname Yang (楊), is accused of repeatedly poisoning Alex Shorey over the course of several months last year to prevent the Australian man from leaving Taiwan, prosecutors said in a statement. Shorey was evacuated back to Australia on May 3 last year after being admitted to intensive care in Taiwan. According to prosecutors, Yang put bromadiolone, a rodenticide that prevents blood from
A Japanese space rocket carrying a Taiwanese satellite blasted off yesterday, but was later seen spiraling downward in the distance as the company said the launch attempt had failed. It was the second attempt by the Japanese start-up Space One to become the country’s first private firm to put a satellite into orbit, after its first try in March ended in a mid-air explosion. This time, its solid-fuel Kairos rocket had been carrying five satellites, including one from the Taiwan Space Agency and others designed by Japanese students and corporate ventures. Spectators gathered near the company’s coastal Spaceport Kii launch pad in Japan’s
RSS