Yen Ching-chang (顏慶章): The GATT [General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade, the predecessor to the WTO] was signed on Oct. 30, 1947. In its many drafts, it clearly stated that governments entering under the name “separate customs territory” essentially lack national sovereignty, so when Taiwan applied to enter the GATT on Jan. 1, 1990, it used the name “the Separate Customs Territory of Taiwan, Penghu, Kinmen and Matsu.”
Looked at another way, Taiwan had no way to compete with China due to international circumstances at the time, forcing the nation to minimize itself by applying not under its official title, but as a so-called “autonomous entity.”
This undeniably minimized our sovereignty, making us suffer within the global trade system ever since.
Photo: Hu Chih-kai, Taipei Times
This became most obvious in 1992, when a working group was formed to approve our application, followed by a series of bilateral trade negotiations. During a review meeting, the [GATT] chairman specifically mentioned that Taiwan’s representative throughout its time as an observer and then a full member should be “along the same lines” as that of Hong Kong and Macau. Not only that, but the titles used by Taiwan’s representatives could not have diplomatic connotations.
So this entire process essentially showed that, because of the name on our application, we do not have sovereignty and therefore all follow-up meetings and negotiations would continue to trample on our national dignity.
NEW WORLD AGREEMENTS
When we joined the WTO [in 2002], the attitude in Geneva [Switzerland] toward Taiwan was completely different than the global attitude today.
Because we had used the “separate customs territory” name, we were forced to call our delegations “economic and trade offices” in a similar convention to Hong Kong and Macau. All told, apart from the few small countries with which we had diplomatic relations, most nations tried to avoid the subject like the plague. The situation now is totally different.
When [former US] president Barack Obama was forming the TPP [Trans-Pacific Partnership], he repeatedly invited Taiwan to join, even going so far as to say that the point [of the trade bloc] was to counter China’s growing influence in the Indo-Pacific region.
Former Japanese prime minister Shinzo Abe also brought it up in his address to the US Congress, saying clearly that we must seek free and democratic economic cooperation in the Asia-Pacific, and in so doing, we must exclude members who bring intimidation. At the time, most people worldwide called the TPP the ‘anyone but China club.’
JOINING JAPAN’S CPTPP
As part of his “America First” policy, [former US] president Donald Trump withdrew from the TPP after his election, but maintained a strong presence in the region through trade and politics that deeply intimidated China.
Since the US withdrew, Abe led the 11 other members in completing the pact in 2018, making Japan leader of the new CPTPP. Then over the past few years, Japan has expressed strong support for Taiwan, although there are admittedly a few details that have upset Japan, such as the Fukushima food safety issue. [After the 2011 Fukushima Dai-ichi nuclear power plant disaster, Taiwan banned food from five Japanese prefectures.]
Truthfully speaking, Taiwan-Japan relations are very good in some areas. Since Taiwanese donated more money to Japan after the [2011] tsunami and power plant disaster than any other country, Japan is grateful and has shown its sincerity through policy.
This year happens to be Japan’s turn to lead the CPTPP, but its term will be over in less than two months. It is a shame because, if Taiwan had acted a little bit sooner, it could have worked with Japan. Instead we have wasted all that time from the establishment of the CPTPP in 2018 until now.
NAMES MATTER
Our application to join the CPTPP follows the naming convention from our 1990 GATT application. What is important to remember is that this “separate customs territory” name comes from the GATT charter. We cannot ignore that it is used for an unsovereign entity. If Taiwan is forced to resign itself to this title, there is nothing we can do.
As I said, in 1990 we applied under the “separate customs territory” name, then two years later in September and October 1992, the director-general accepted our application. In that meeting, the chairman further declared that the representative would be “hereinafter referred to as Chinese Taipei,” thereby also giving us that title in the GATT.
The way we translate it as Zhonghua Taibei (中華台北) sounds horrible, but it saves face. If it were translated directly from English would Taiwanese accept this name? This happened back in 1992; would Taiwanese today be willing to make such a concession?
POWERFUL FRIENDS
Today, Taiwan’s international situation has improved a lot. The US offers support in many areas, and it has only become more firm and apparent since [US President Joe] Biden took office.
We will of course not talk about countries that do not have a geopolitical relationship with the CPTPP, but among those that do, Japan is the biggest. There is also Australia, which has already stated that it wants to align with Japan and Canada. Canada has in the past not expressed a clear stance on Taiwan, but because of the Huawei [Technologies] situation, it has come to realize how China pressures its neighbors, including Canada.
So the CPTPP of course requires a consensus among its 11 members, the same as the WTO. In that consensus, we can imagine that if only one country opposes — no matter how big or small — Taiwan cannot join. However, we should also have confidence, since it also only takes one country to oppose China’s entry.
ALREADY ‘TAIWAN’
As for changing our name, I think it could be discussed in future negotiations.
Alternatively, another major member such as Japan could do what they did during the Tokyo Olympics and directly say “Taiwan” instead of “Chinese Taipei.” This is actually already happening internationally.
For instance, in all government documents and statements since breaking ties in 1979, the US has called us Taiwan; it has never used “Chinese Taipei.” It is the same with Australia — none of the countries with more economic weight in the CPTPP will call us the “Separate Customs Territory of Taiwan, Penghu, Kinmen and Matsu,” so we should not minimize ourselves, either.
I will not say it is impossible to change the name on our application. If it is possible, we could work with some big countries such as Japan, Canada and Australia to reach a consensus with the other members.
ONE CHOICE
Then of course there is only one choice of name. The Republic of China is definitely not feasible, because there are a lot of arenas where using this name is impossible.
Diplomacy is an extension of domestic affairs, but our domestic conversation around this issue is frankly confusing.
If we insist on using the Republic of China, it is too similar to the People’s Republic of China in English and therefore untenable internationally.
As we cannot accept “Taiwan, Penghu, Kinmen and Matsu,” the best middle ground is “Taiwan.”
However, there are still some Taiwanese who refuse to use this name, making it impossible to speak with any consistency at home, and adding a great deal of difficulty when trying to say what country you are from or which government you represent while abroad.
FIRST, CONSENSUS
I want to encourage all Taiwanese to think about this: Ever since we withdrew from the UN in 1971, we have been called the Republic of China, but now this term has no room for survival on the international stage.
How should we consider eliciting national pride with the consensus of all people? Most crucially, we must first have pride in this land before we can become great; we cannot wait to become great before we identify as a nation.
We must do this now, because if we do not change, over the next 50 years where will we find ourselves?
Reporting by Ou Hsiang-yi, Liu Yan-chen and Hu Chih-kai
Translated by Kayleigh Madjar
POSITIVE DEVELOPMENT: Japan and the US are expected to hold in-depth discussions on Taiwan-related issues during the meeting next month, Japanese sources said The holding of a Japan-US leaders’ meeting ahead of US President Donald Trump’s visit to China is positive news for Taiwan, former Japan-Taiwan Exchange Association representative Hiroyasu Izumi said yesterday. After the Liberal Democratic Party’s landslide victory in Japan’s House of Representatives election, Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi is scheduled to visit the US next month, where she is to meet with Trump ahead of the US president’s planned visit to China from March 31 to April 2 for a meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平). Japan and the US are expected to hold in-depth discussions on Taiwan-related issues during the
‘LIKE-MINDED PARTNER’: Tako van Popta said it would be inappropriate to delay signing the deal with Taiwan because of China, adding he would promote the issue Canadian senators have stressed Taiwan’s importance for international trade and expressed enthusiasm for ensuring the Taiwan-Canada trade cooperation framework agreement is implemented this year. Representative to Canada Harry Tseng (曾厚仁) in an interview with the Central News Agency (CNA) said he was increasingly uneasy about Ottawa’s delays in signing the agreement, especially as Ottawa has warmed toward Beijing. There are “no negotiations left. Not only [is it] initialed, we have three versions of the text ready: English, French and Mandarin,” Tseng said. “That tells you how close we are to the final signature.” Tseng said that he hoped Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney
President William Lai (賴清德) yesterday bestowed one of Taiwan’s highest honors on Saint Vincent and the Grenadines (SVG) Ambassador Andrea Clare Bowman in recognition of her contributions to bilateral ties. “By conferring the Order of Brilliant Star with Grand Cordon on Ambassador Bowman today, I want to sincerely thank her, on behalf of the Taiwanese people, for her outstanding contribution to deepening diplomatic ties between Taiwan and SVG,” Lai said at a ceremony held at the Presidential Office in Taipei. He noted that Bowman became SVG’s first ambassador to Taiwan in 2019 and
A man walks past elementary school artworks at the Taipei Lantern Festival in Ximen District yesterday, the first day of the event. The festival is to run from 5pm to 10pm through March 15.
RSS