Efforts by local prosecutors to bring charges of criminal negligence against the pilots of Singapore Airlines flight SQ006 may strain Taiwan's diplomatic and economic ties with the international community.
Aviation experts say it goes against international practice to hold responsible the three pilots of the doomed flight, in which 82 people lost their lives. International pilots' associations have also raised concerns over inquiries into whether the pilots should be held criminally liable.
TAIPEI TIMES FILE PHOTO
Still, the Ministry of Justice says prosecutors have the right to probe the cause of the Oct. 31 crash alongside the Aviation Safety Council, which is interested in preventing future accidents.
TAIPEI TIMES FILE PHOTO
The ministry arrived at that conclusion recently after consulting the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the Ministry of Transportation and Communications.
Investigation should be left to the experts
But officials from the Aviation Safety Council and National Transportation Safety Board of the US say it is better to leave the questions to the aviation experts. Throughout the world, they say, uncovering the cause of plane accidents is best done by aviation professionals.
"Unless there is a potential crime -- such as the implantation of a bomb -- prosecutors won't interfere in the investigation conducted by professionals," said Ron Schleed, a former senior investigator at the US National Transportation Safety Board.
But local prosecutors say they are examining whether charges of criminal negligence should be brought in the SQ006 case.
Pilots of the ill-fated 747-400 attempted to take off from a CKS airport runway partially closed for repairs, barrelling into construction equipment.
The plane broke into three pieces and exploded.
"Our criminal law suggests that we should be there when death is involved in a case," the prosecutors said.
A question of jurisdiction
Ministry of Justice officials also argue that Taiwan has jurisdiction over how the investigation into the plane crash proceeds, not anyone else.
That closely echoes statements from Taoyuan prosecutors, who said Taiwan's "criminal law should be applied to the case since the accident happened here in a sovereign state. It is humiliating to the nation and inimical to its sovereignty not to handle this case in accordance with our law."
Meanwhile, the three pilots of the flight -- Malaysian captain Foong Chee Kong, and Singaporean co-pilots Latiff Cyrano and Ng Kheng Leng -- have been barred by prosecutors from leaving the country, arousing complaints from several pilots' associations.
Prevention, not prosecution
In any case, many aviation safety experts have warned that threatening to bring criminal charges against the pilots would hinder the flow of information about the crash.
That would make it difficult to prevent future air traffic accidents, they say, and it undermines the goal of carrying out investigations in the first place.
"It is very unfortunate," Schleed said, after learning that the Ministry of Justice planned to allow prosecutors' probes to go forward.
While the ministry says the inquiry is to determine whether "criminal liability" should be assigned to the pilots, Schleed said the case is a matter of human error and the pilots had no criminal intent.
Furthermore, Schleed said, introducing the threat of criminal charges would pose a threat to the safety of the world's aviation system.
"The threat of criminal charges will lead aviation crews to cover up their minor errors during their flight operations," he said. "Then, as its consequence, air safety will not be improved, which may even cause significant accidents afterwards."
Lu Peng-jeu (陸鵬舉), chairman of the department of Aeronautics and Astronautics at National Cheng Kung University (成功大學), agrees. Lu said that some past aviation accidents in Taiwan were caused by the reoccurrence of mistakes that pilots had concealed.
If pilots don't report their mistakes, other pilots don't have a chance to learn from them.
Lu said many countries prefer to focus on improving aviation safety rather than punishing pilots for professional negligence. Lu said that an emphasis on flight safety allows a greater number of lives to be saved.
Robert Vandel, executive vice president of the US-based Flight Safety Foundation, said that aviation accident rates have declined tremendously over the years by "utilizing what we have learned from accident investigations."
But if the threat of criminal charges is introduced, pilots and other aviation personnel may not be forthcoming about factors contributing to a crash.
"Taiwan is a benefactor of this system and the island should not inhibit in any fashion the work of the independent accident investigation team," Vandell wrote in a letter to the Ministry of Justice and the Ministry of Transportation and Communications.
Aviation safety specialists say that many other countries besides Taiwan have faced the issue of balancing the law with the need to improve safety.
Yong Kay (
"Canada, Australia and New Zealand have passed laws to prevent investigation reports by professionals from being used in judicial proceedings," Yong said.
New Zealand passed its law last year. John Britton, of that nation's Transport Accident Investigation Commission, said the law has already brought about its desired effect.
"There are no more reports of airline crews turning cockpit voice recorders off, and it is easier to persuade people to talk frankly with investigators," Britton said.
Lu also notes that the US had developed "a confidential reporting system," whereby pilots are allowed to report their mistakes without fearing repercussions.
"They once recalled the system because of the prosecutors' objections, too," Lu said. "But they put the system back in place, as they realized that the threat of criminal charges and penalties against pilots never really addressed the issue of improving aviation safety."
In addition, groups such as the International Civil Aviation Organization have asked their members to review their laws to determine whether the threat of criminal liability is blocking the collection of information that could prevent future accidents.
Still, the Ministry of Justice says there are no specific international regulations sparing pilots from criminal liability.
Judgement vs. the rule book
Local prosecutors argue that, in probing the accident, they are merely doing what the law requires them to do.
But Brian Kennedy, a former US prosecutor and frequent contributor to the Taipei Times, said that "any prosecutors' office anywhere in the world has some latitude of prosecutorial discretion."
Yong also said that prosecutors should exercise some discretion. Yong said that the purpose of pursuing criminal charges is to prevent future crimes. But as is the case with many aviation accidents, unintentional human error is often the cause.
Kennedy said that prosecutors should use reasonable individual judgement instead of merely sticking to the rule book.
Kennedy also suggested that an "inter-agency rivalry" may exist between the Ministry of Justice and aviation experts. That may be why the ministry has refused to give up its right to conduct an investigation or file charges against the pilots.
"They want to be seen as having done something, as being in the lead, as not surrendering to any other agencies, such as the Aviation Safety Council," Kennedy said.
"In fact, the judicial system should not worry too much about decriminalizing pilots' error in the air accident. Pilots in general, compared to other transportation operators, are well trained and closely monitored. They're less likely to commit an intentional crime," Kennedy said.
"To make a general policy of not filing criminal charges against pilots is crucial, otherwise there's a greater chance for us to risk future aviation safety compared to miss punishing a seriously guilty pilot," he said.
Kennedy also criticized the Ministry of Justice for appealing to Taiwan's sense of nationalism in defending its right to probe the plane crash. He said the legal and aviation safety issues involved in the case have little to do with national sovereignty, a popular issue in Taiwan.
Taiwan may be subject to boycotts by pilots
Yong and many others have warned that if prosecutors insist on bringing charges, Taiwan may suffer from a boycott from pilots, hurting Taiwan's economic and diplomatic ties with the rest of the world.
The International Federation of Airline Pilots' Association, which represents more than 100,000 pilots from nearly 100 countries worldwide, has warned of such as boycott.
The federation, along with the Malaysia Airlines Pilots' Association, have asked that the three pilots be allowed to go home, saying keeping them here in Taiwan will do little to help the investigation.
The CIA has a message for Chinese government officials worried about their place in Chinese President Xi Jinping’s (習近平) government: Come work with us. The agency released two Mandarin-language videos on social media on Thursday inviting disgruntled officials to contact the CIA. The recruitment videos posted on YouTube and X racked up more than 5 million views combined in their first day. The outreach comes as CIA Director John Ratcliffe has vowed to boost the agency’s use of intelligence from human sources and its focus on China, which has recently targeted US officials with its own espionage operations. The videos are “aimed at
STEADFAST FRIEND: The bills encourage increased Taiwan-US engagement and address China’s distortion of UN Resolution 2758 to isolate Taiwan internationally The Presidential Office yesterday thanked the US House of Representatives for unanimously passing two Taiwan-related bills highlighting its solid support for Taiwan’s democracy and global participation, and for deepening bilateral relations. One of the bills, the Taiwan Assurance Implementation Act, requires the US Department of State to periodically review its guidelines for engagement with Taiwan, and report to the US Congress on the guidelines and plans to lift self-imposed limitations on US-Taiwan engagement. The other bill is the Taiwan International Solidarity Act, which clarifies that UN Resolution 2758 does not address the issue of the representation of Taiwan or its people in
US Indo-Pacific Commander Admiral Samuel Paparo on Friday expressed concern over the rate at which China is diversifying its military exercises, the Financial Times (FT) reported on Saturday. “The rates of change on the depth and breadth of their exercises is the one non-linear effect that I’ve seen in the last year that wakes me up at night or keeps me up at night,” Paparo was quoted by FT as saying while attending the annual Sedona Forum at the McCain Institute in Arizona. Paparo also expressed concern over the speed with which China was expanding its military. While the US
SHIFT: Taiwan’s better-than-expected first-quarter GDP and signs of weakness in the US have driven global capital back to emerging markets, the central bank head said The central bank yesterday blamed market speculation for the steep rise in the local currency, and urged exporters and financial institutions to stay calm and stop panic sell-offs to avoid hurting their own profitability. The nation’s top monetary policymaker said that it would step in, if necessary, to maintain order and stability in the foreign exchange market. The remarks came as the NT dollar yesterday closed up NT$0.919 to NT$30.145 against the US dollar in Taipei trading, after rising as high as NT$29.59 in intraday trading. The local currency has surged 5.85 percent against the greenback over the past two sessions, central
RSS