A Google software engineer was suspended after going public with his claims of encountering “sentient” artificial intelligence on the company’s servers — spurring a debate about how and whether AI can achieve consciousness. Researchers say it’s an unfortunate distraction from more pressing issues in the industry.
The engineer, Blake Lemoine, said he believed that Google’s AI chatbot was capable of expressing human emotion, and that the company would need to address the resulting ethical ramifications. Google put him on leave for sharing confidential information and said his concerns had no basis in fact — a view widely held in the AI community. What’s more important, researchers say, is addressing issues like whether AI can engender real-world harm and prejudice, whether actual humans are exploited in the training of AI, and how the major technology companies act as gatekeepers of the development of the tech.
Lemoine’s stance may also make it easier for tech companies to abdicate responsibility for AI-driven decisions, said Emily Bender, a professor of computational linguistics at the University of Washington. “Lots of effort has been put into this sideshow,” she said. “The problem is, the more this technology gets sold as artificial intelligence — let alone something sentient — the more people are willing to go along with AI systems” that can cause real-world harm.
Photo: Pixabay 照片:Pixabay
Bender pointed to examples in job hiring and grading students, which can carry embedded prejudice depending on what data sets were used to train the AI. If the focus is on the system’s apparent sentience, Bender said, it creates a distance from the AI creators’ direct responsibility for any flaws or biases in the programs.
The debate over sentience in robots has been carried out alongside science fiction portrayal in popular culture, in stories and movies with AI romantic partners or AI villains. So the debate had an easy path to the mainstream. “Instead of discussing the harms of these companies,” such as sexism, racism and centralization of power created by these AI systems, everyone “spent the whole weekend discussing sentience,” Timnit Gebru, formerly co-lead of Google’s ethical AI group, said on Twitter. “Derailing mission accomplished.”
Putting an emphasis on AI sentience would have given Google the leeway to blame the issue on the intelligent AI making such a decision, Bender said. “The company could say, ‘Oh, the software made a mistake,’” she said. “Well no, your company created that software. You are accountable for that mistake. And the discourse about sentience muddies that in bad ways.”
Photo: Pixabay 照片:Pixabay
The earliest chatbots of the 1960s and ’70s, including ELIZA and PARRY, generated headlines for their ability to be conversational with humans. In more recent years, the GPT-3 language model from OpenAI, the lab founded by Tesla CEO Elon Musk and others, has demonstrated even more cutting-edge abilities, including the ability to read and write. But from a scientific perspective, there is no evidence that human intelligence or consciousness are embedded in these systems, said Bart Selman, a professor of computer science at Cornell University who studies artificial intelligence.
(Bloomberg)
谷歌一名軟體工程師因聲稱在公司伺服器上遇到「有感情」的人工智慧而遭停職──這引起了熱議,爭論人工智慧如何及是否能夠有意識。研究人員表示,很不幸這分散了對人工智慧中更迫切問題的注意力。
工程師布萊克‧勒莫因表示,他相信谷歌的人工智慧聊天機器人能夠表達人類的情感,谷歌公司需要解決由此產生的道德後果。谷歌令其休假,理由是他分享了機密資訊,並表示他的擔憂其實並無根據──此為人工智慧業界之普遍觀點。研究人員表示,更重要的是解決人工智慧是否會在現實世界中造成傷害與偏見、訓練人工智慧時是否有真人被剝削,以及大型科技公司如何作為技術發展的守門人等問題。
華盛頓大學電腦語言學教授艾蜜莉‧班德表示,勒莫因的立場也可能讓科技公司對人工智慧所做的決策更容易卸責。她說:「這個枝節問題花了大家很多力氣」。「問題是,這項技術被當做人工智慧出售得越多──更不用說是有感情的東西──就有越多人願意接受(這可對現實世界造成傷害的)人工智慧系統」。
班德以徵才及學生評分為例,說明這可能帶有嵌入的偏見,端看用於訓練人工智慧的資料集為何。班德說,如果把焦點集中在系統有明顯的感知力,它就會讓人工智慧創建者與程式中任何缺陷或偏見所需負的直接責任脫鉤。
關於機器人感知能力的爭論,與流行文化中的科幻小說、故事及電影對AI情人或AI惡棍的描繪並行。因而論辨很容易成為主流 ,「而沒有討論這些公司的危害」,例如這些人工智慧系統所造成的性別歧視、種族主義和權力集中,每個人「整個週末都在討論感知」,前谷歌人工智慧倫理小組聯合負責人蒂姆尼特‧蓋布魯在推特上說道,「轉移注意力的任務完成」。
班德說,將重點放在 AI 感知上會讓谷歌有迴旋餘地,將問題歸咎於智慧AI做出此決定。「公司可能會說,『喔,是軟體出錯了』」,她說。「嗯,不對,你的公司創建了那個軟體。你要為這個錯誤負責。但關於感知的討論很糟糕地讓這一點模糊掉了」。
一九六○年代和七○年代最早的聊天機器人,包括ELIZA和PARRY,因其與人類對話的能力而成為頭條新聞。近年來,特斯拉執行長伊隆‧馬斯克等人創立的實驗室OpenAI的GPT-3語言模型展示了更先進的能力,包括讀寫能力。但從科學的角度來看,並沒有證據顯示人類的智能或意識嵌入在這些系統中,康乃爾大學研究人工智慧電腦科學教授巴特‧塞爾曼說。
(台北時報林俐凱編譯)
The Perseids meteor shower is expected to peak on Monday next week, with the up to 100 meteors per hour, with the number expected to reach more than 30 one or two days before and after, which will surely be a treat for stargazers. The Perseids are named after the Greek hero Perseus, as the meteor shower appears to come from the eponymous constellation. According to myth, Perseus slew the gorgon Medusa by cutting off her snake-covered head while viewing her reflection in his shield. While the meteors are active from mid-July, the best time to see them is next Monday with the
A: Japanese pop diva Hikaru Utada is visiting Taiwan, as well as Aespa. B: Yeah, she will hold two concerts at the Taipei Arena over the weekend. A: When she released her 1999 debut album “First Love,” it became Japan’s best-selling album ever. B: Her No. 1 hit “First Love” from that album even topped the chart again in 2022 as the theme song of a TV drama. A: After a wait of 25 years, Taiwanese fans can finally see “Hikki” for the first time. A: 除了Aespa,日本歌后宇多田光終於要來台開唱啦。 B: 對啊,本週末將在台北小巨蛋連唱兩天。 A: 她在1999年推出首張專輯《First Love》,甚至還成為日本史上最暢銷專輯。 B: 而當年的同名冠軍歌曲《First Love》,2022年搭配日劇播出在台再度奪冠。 A: 台灣歌迷等了25年,終於等到她來台開演唱會啦! (By Eddy Chang, Taipei Times/台北時報張聖恩)
Roast duck is a dish that reflects Taiwan’s diverse culinary style, shaped by its rich immigrant background. Originally brought to Taiwan by Chinese immigrants, roast duck has become an essential delicacy in Taiwanese cuisine. Restaurants specializing in roast duck are often packed at meal times. However, since these restaurants have only a limited number of roast ducks each day, reservations are necessary to ensure availability. Preparing a delicious roast duck is no easy feat, as it is a time-consuming process requiring half a day to cook to ensure the perfect taste. 台灣的移民背景造就豐富的飲食文化,烤鴨就是其中之一。烤鴨傳入台灣是由外省人引進的,隨著時間的紮根,成為了台灣不可或缺的美食。用餐時間的烤鴨店總是高朋滿座,但因每天限量供應,想吃還要提早訂,因為製作美味的烤鴨至少得花上半天,才能色香味俱全。 immigrant (n.) 移民 reservation (n.)
A: K-pop SM Entertainment’s four-member girl group Aespa is set to stage three shows in Taiwan starting Friday. B: Great, where will they be performing? A: At Taoyuan’s National Taiwan Sports University Stadium, commonly known as the Linkou Stadium. B: I hear that Aespa has even been voted by netizens as one of the top 10 girl groups. A: Yeah, other top groups include Blackpink, (G)I-DLE, NewJeans and Twice. A: 南韓SM娛樂旗下的4人女團Aespa,週五起將在台灣一連嗨唱3場! B: 太棒了,在哪唱? A: 在桃園的國立體育大學綜合體育館,就是俗稱的「林口體育館」。 B: 聽說Aespa還被網友選為10大女團? A: 對啊,前幾名的女團還有:Blackpink、(G)I-DLE、NewJeans、Twice。 (By Eddy Chang, Taipei Times/台北時報張聖恩)