The Cabinet yesterday said it would request a new vote on Constitutional Court reforms that lawmakers passed on Dec. 20, signaling further deadlock between the central government and the opposition-controlled legislature.
President William Lai (賴清德) yesterday approved the request to send the changes to the Constitutional Court Procedure Act (憲法訴訟法) back to the legislature, Presidential Office spokesperson Karen Kuo (郭雅慧) said yesterday.
As the bill is highly controversial, the government hopes the ruling party and the opposition could re-examine the bill and reach a consensus through rational communication and negotiations under the constitutional mechanism, she said.
Photo: Chung Li-hua, Taipei Times
Earlier yesterday, Cabinet spokesperson Michelle Lee (李慧芝) cited Premier Cho Jung-tai (卓榮泰) as saying that the amendments would allow the legislature to override the judiciary, setting an “unreasonable threshold” that would disrupt the operations of the court.
That could affect the public’s right to seek remedies or to resolve constitutional disputes, endangering the constitutional order, Cho added.
Also, amendments to Article 4 of the act would not help to ensure the stable operation of the Constitutional Court, as it does not set a legal time limit for the legislature to approve the nomination of grand justices by the president, Cho said.
A constitutional interpretation would be sought if the legislature votes down the motion to reconsider the bill, Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) caucus chief executive Rosalia Wu (吳思瑤) said.
The political impasse over the issue, created by a combination of court vacancies and reforms sought by the legislature, is likely to continue.
The legislation would require at least 10 justices on the court — which normally has 15 members — to hear a case, and at least nine justices to back any unconstitutional ruling. Current rules do not specify a minimum number of justices required to hear a case. Instead, they simply mandate the presence of at least two-thirds of all sitting justices, with a ruling determined by a simple majority vote.
While the government has asked the legislature to hold a new vote on the bill, it is unlikely to yield a different result.
The opposition-backed bill creates problems, as the eight-year terms of seven of the Constitutional Court’s 15 judges ended on Oct. 31 last year.
With only eight justices left, the court does not have the number required by the bill to hear cases.
Lai put forward seven nominees to fill the vacancies, but all of them were rejected by the legislature on Tuesday last week, with opposition parties claiming they were too partisan.
Lai has not yet sought another vote on the nominees or named new candidates.
Minister Without Portfolio Lin Ming-hsin (林明昕) also signaled support for a court challenge at a news briefing yesterday, saying that the reforms would contravene the constitutionally enshrined separation and balance of powers between the five branches of government.
Taking that road risks setting off a potential crisis, as the Constitutional Court would be asked to rule on legislation directly relating to its own powers, with only eight judges available to hear them.
However, under Article 43 of the act, the court can issue a preliminary injunction against a law with a quorum of two-thirds of incumbent justices and a majority voting in support of the injunction.
Alternatively, the government could hold negotiations with the legislature to select seven Constitutional Court nominees who are acceptable to both sides.
If it did so, the government could still seek an injunction and constitutional interpretation for the reforms after the new justices are seated.
Meanwhile, Lee said the Cabinet had not received any official notice of two other sets of controversial amendments to the Public Officials Election and Recall Act (公職人員選舉罷免法) and the Act Governing the Allocation of Government Revenues and Expenditures (財政收支劃分法) that were also approved by opposition lawmakers last month.
Those amendments would tighten requirements for petitions to recall elected officials and reallocate more funding from the central government to local governments.
Lee said if the amendments are sent to the Executive Yuan on the last working day before the Lunar New Year, the Executive Yuan would have until Feb. 2 to request that the legislature reconsider the bills.
If the Executive Yuan is to make a request during the Lunar New Year, the legislature would have to handle it within 15 days, she said, adding that the motion would be considered passed otherwise.
If the lawmakers vote down the motion, the Executive Yuan would discuss further actions, Lin said.
The president would have 10 days to promulgate the law, which would not come into effect immediately after the legislature votes down the motion, Lin added.
STILL COMMITTED: The US opposes any forced change to the ‘status quo’ in the Strait, but also does not seek conflict, US Secretary of State Marco Rubio said US President Donald Trump’s administration released US$5.3 billion in previously frozen foreign aid, including US$870 million in security exemptions for programs in Taiwan, a list of exemptions reviewed by Reuters showed. Trump ordered a 90-day pause on foreign aid shortly after taking office on Jan. 20, halting funding for everything from programs that fight starvation and deadly diseases to providing shelters for millions of displaced people across the globe. US Secretary of State Marco Rubio, who has said that all foreign assistance must align with Trump’s “America First” priorities, issued waivers late last month on military aid to Israel and Egypt, the
‘UNITED FRONT’ FRONTS: Barring contact with Huaqiao and Jinan universities is needed to stop China targeting Taiwanese students, the education minister said Taiwan has blacklisted two Chinese universities from conducting academic exchange programs in the nation after reports that the institutes are arms of Beijing’s United Front Work Department, Minister of Education Cheng Ying-yao (鄭英耀) said in an exclusive interview with the Chinese-language Liberty Times (the Taipei Times’ sister paper) published yesterday. China’s Huaqiao University in Xiamen and Quanzhou, as well as Jinan University in Guangzhou, which have 600 and 1,500 Taiwanese on their rolls respectively, are under direct control of the Chinese government’s political warfare branch, Cheng said, citing reports by national security officials. A comprehensive ban on Taiwanese institutions collaborating or
France’s nuclear-powered aircraft carrier and accompanying warships were in the Philippines yesterday after holding combat drills with Philippine forces in the disputed South China Sea in a show of firepower that would likely antagonize China. The Charles de Gaulle on Friday docked at Subic Bay, a former US naval base northwest of Manila, for a break after more than two months of deployment in the Indo-Pacific region. The French carrier engaged with security allies for contingency readiness and to promote regional security, including with Philippine forces, navy ships and fighter jets. They held anti-submarine warfare drills and aerial combat training on Friday in
COMBAT READINESS: The military is reviewing weaponry, personnel resources, and mobilization and recovery forces to adjust defense strategies, the defense minister said The military has released a photograph of Minister of National Defense Wellington Koo (顧立雄) appearing to sit beside a US general during the annual Han Kuang military exercises on Friday last week in a historic first. In the photo, Koo, who was presiding over the drills with high-level officers, appears to be sitting next to US Marine Corps Major General Jay Bargeron, the director of strategic planning and policy of the US Indo-Pacific Command, although only Bargeron’s name tag is visible in the seat as “J5 Maj General.” It is the first time the military has released a photo of an active
RSS