A Criminal Code provision requiring repeat offenders to serve up to 25 years with no chance of parole if they violate the law during their parole contravenes the Constitution, and should be amended within two years, the Constitutional Court said yesterday.
Hsieh Chao-he (謝朝和), who was sentenced to life in prison for violating the now-defunct Act Punishing Thievery and Banditry (懲治盜匪條例), was in 2009 granted parole after serving 18 years.
However, his parole was revoked after he was convicted of theft and ordered to serve 25 years in jail without parole. Hsieh said the sentence was “disproportionate” to the crime and requested a constitutional interpretation.
Photo: screen shot from a Constitutional Court livestream
Another 35 similar cases were merged into one in the Constitutional Court’s review of Hsieh’s request.
The Constitutional Court yesterday said that the revocation of the accused’s parole had not considered the severity of the repeat offense nor the effects of the rehabilitation program on the accused during the time of parole.
Ordering the accused to serve out the remainder of their previous sentence before their parole for up to 25 years violates the principle of proportionality and fails to observe the spirit of Article 8 of the Constitution, the court said.
The competent authority should amend this provision in the Criminal Code within two years, it said.
If the law is not amended within the given period, the competent authority should rescind rulings and instead implement measures more in line with the principle of proportionality, it said.
Five appeals were certified to have contravened the Constitution and have been remanded to the Supreme Court, it said, adding that chief prosecutors are within their rights or can act if petitioned by others to lodge an extraordinary appeal on the ruling.
The Supreme Court should halt legal proceedings of the cases until the amendment is passed and then review the case with the amended Criminal Code in mind, it added.
As for other convicts facing a similar situation, but who were not part of the five appeals, the Constitutional Court said that if they voice opposition regarding their cases following the constitutional interpretation or if their cases are on trial, the courts presiding over the cases should halt all legal proceedings until the amendment has been promulgated.
Two US House of Representatives committees yesterday condemned China’s attempt to orchestrate a crash involving Vice President Hsiao Bi-khim’s (蕭美琴) car when she visited the Czech Republic last year as vice president-elect. Czech local media in March last year reported that a Chinese diplomat had run a red light while following Hsiao’s car from the airport, and Czech intelligence last week told local media that Chinese diplomats and agents had also planned to stage a demonstrative car collision. Hsiao on Saturday shared a Reuters news report on the incident through her account on social media platform X and wrote: “I
‘BUILDING PARTNERSHIPS’: The US military’s aim is to continue to make any potential Chinese invasion more difficult than it already is, US General Ronald Clark said The likelihood of China invading Taiwan without contest is “very, very small” because the Taiwan Strait is under constant surveillance by multiple countries, a US general has said. General Ronald Clark, commanding officer of US Army Pacific (USARPAC), the US Army’s largest service component command, made the remarks during a dialogue hosted on Friday by Washington-based think tank the Center for Strategic and International Studies. Asked by the event host what the Chinese military has learned from its US counterpart over the years, Clark said that the first lesson is that the skill and will of US service members are “unmatched.” The second
STANDING TOGETHER: Amid China’s increasingly aggressive activities, nations must join forces in detecting and dealing with incursions, a Taiwanese official said Two senior Philippine officials and one former official yesterday attended the Taiwan International Ocean Forum in Taipei, the first high-level visit since the Philippines in April lifted a ban on such travel to Taiwan. The Ocean Affairs Council hosted the two-day event at the National Taiwan University Hospital International Convention Center. Philippine Navy spokesman Rear Admiral Roy Vincent Trinidad, Coast Guard spokesman Grand Commodore Jay Tarriela and former Philippine Presidential Communications Office assistant secretary Michel del Rosario participated in the forum. More than 100 officials, experts and entrepreneurs from 15 nations participated in the forum, which included discussions on countering China’s hybrid warfare
MORE DEMOCRACY: The only solution to Taiwan’s current democratic issues involves more democracy, including Constitutional Court rulings and citizens exercising their civil rights , Lai said The People’s Republic of China (PRC) is not the “motherland” of the Republic of China (ROC) and has never owned Taiwan, President William Lai (賴清德) said yesterday. The speech was the third in a series of 10 that Lai is scheduled to deliver across Taiwan. Taiwan is facing external threats from China, Lai said at a Lions Clubs International banquet in Hsinchu. For example, on June 21 the army detected 12 Chinese aircraft, eight of which entered Taiwanese waters, as well as six Chinese warships that remained in the waters around Taiwan, he said. Beyond military and political intimidation, Taiwan
RSS