A Criminal Code provision requiring repeat offenders to serve up to 25 years with no chance of parole if they violate the law during their parole contravenes the Constitution, and should be amended within two years, the Constitutional Court said yesterday.
Hsieh Chao-he (謝朝和), who was sentenced to life in prison for violating the now-defunct Act Punishing Thievery and Banditry (懲治盜匪條例), was in 2009 granted parole after serving 18 years.
However, his parole was revoked after he was convicted of theft and ordered to serve 25 years in jail without parole. Hsieh said the sentence was “disproportionate” to the crime and requested a constitutional interpretation.
Photo: screen shot from a Constitutional Court livestream
Another 35 similar cases were merged into one in the Constitutional Court’s review of Hsieh’s request.
The Constitutional Court yesterday said that the revocation of the accused’s parole had not considered the severity of the repeat offense nor the effects of the rehabilitation program on the accused during the time of parole.
Ordering the accused to serve out the remainder of their previous sentence before their parole for up to 25 years violates the principle of proportionality and fails to observe the spirit of Article 8 of the Constitution, the court said.
The competent authority should amend this provision in the Criminal Code within two years, it said.
If the law is not amended within the given period, the competent authority should rescind rulings and instead implement measures more in line with the principle of proportionality, it said.
Five appeals were certified to have contravened the Constitution and have been remanded to the Supreme Court, it said, adding that chief prosecutors are within their rights or can act if petitioned by others to lodge an extraordinary appeal on the ruling.
The Supreme Court should halt legal proceedings of the cases until the amendment is passed and then review the case with the amended Criminal Code in mind, it added.
As for other convicts facing a similar situation, but who were not part of the five appeals, the Constitutional Court said that if they voice opposition regarding their cases following the constitutional interpretation or if their cases are on trial, the courts presiding over the cases should halt all legal proceedings until the amendment has been promulgated.
Taiwan aims to open 18 representative offices and seven Taiwan Tourism Information Centers worldwide by next year to attract international visitors, the Tourism Administration said on Saturday. The agency has so far opened three representative offices abroad this year and would open two more before the end of the year, it said. It has also already opened information centers in Jakarta, Mumbai and Paris, and is to open one in Vancouver next month and in Manila in December, it said. Next year, it would also open offices in Amsterdam, Dubai and Sydney, it added. While the Cabinet did not mention international tourists in its
EYES AT SEA: Many marine enthusiasts have expressed interest in volunteering for coastal patrols, which would help identify stowaways and illegal fishing, the CGA said Six thousand coastal patrol volunteers are to be recruited for 159 inspection offices to enhance the nation’s response to “gray zone” conflicts, Coast Guard Administration (CGA) sources said yesterday. Volunteer teams would be established to increase the resilience of coastal defense systems in the wake of two unlawful entries attempted by Chinese over the past three months, Ocean Affairs Council Minister Kuan Bi-ling (管碧玲) said. A former Chinese navy captain drove a motorboat into the Tamsui River (淡水河) in Taipei on the eve of the Dragon Boat Festival in June, while another Chinese man sailed in a rubber boat into the Houkeng
NEXT LEVEL: The defense ministry confirmed that a video released last month featured personnel piloting new FPV drone systems being developed by the Armaments Bureau Taipei and Washington are pushing for their drone companies to work together to establish a China-free supply chain, the Financial Times reported on Friday. A delegation of high-level executives and US government officials were yesterday to arrive in Taipei to discuss with their Taiwanese counterparts collaboration on drone technology procurement and development, the report said. The executives represent 26 US manufacturers of drone and counter-drone systems, while the officials are from the US Department of Commerce and the US Department of Defense’s Defense Innovation Unit, along with Dev Shenoy, principal director for microelectronics in the Office of the Under Secretary of Defense
‘ANONYMOUS 64’: A national security official said that it is an attempt by China to increase domestic anti-Taiwanese sentiment and inflame cross-strait tensions The Ministry of National Defense’s (MND) Information, Communications and Electronic Force Command (ICEFCOM) yesterday denied accusations by China that it had undermined regional security by carrying out cyberattacks against targets in China, adding instead that Beijing was responsible for raising tensions and undermining regional peace. The Chinese Ministry of State Security on WeChat accused a hacker group called “Anonymous 64” of targeting China, Hong Kong and Macau starting earlier this year through frequent cyberattacks. The group carried out cyberattacks to seize control of Web sites, outdoor electronic billboards and video-on-demand platforms in China, Hong Kong and Macau, it said, adding the hackers’