Taiwan, once relegated to the backwaters of international news media and viewed as a subset topic of “greater China,” is now a hot topic. Words associated with Taiwan include “invasion,” “contingency” and, on the more cheerful side, “semiconductors” and “tourism.”
It is worth noting that while Taiwanese companies play important roles in the semiconductor industry, there is no such thing as a “Taiwan semiconductor” or a “Taiwan chip.” If crucial suppliers are included, the supply chain is in the thousands and spans the globe. Both of the variants of the so-called “silicon shield” are pure fantasy.
There are four primary drivers for this dramatic upswing in international coverage. Government tourism ad campaigns, increased awareness of Taiwan’s critical role in international trade and supply chains, the mass migration of foreign journalists exiled from China relocating to Taipei and the Chinese Communist Party’s (CCP) increasingly hostile and threatening behavior towards Taiwan, which is the focus of this deep dive.
Photo: Reuters
Much coverage and analysis focuses on the potential for war, much of it sexed up to drive traffic. Though cringe-worthy, much of it does help raise awareness of Taiwan’s situation and — as fellow Taipei Times columnist Michael Turton has frequently pointed out — increased awareness among key countries like the US, Japan and Australia, why Taiwan matters and is worth defending militarily.
WE ARE ALREADY AT WAR
The question of whether the CCP will go to war with Taiwan is both very easy and very difficult to answer. The simplest answer is that we are already at war as far as the CCP is concerned and we should view it in the same light and respond in kind.
Photo: Reuters
The Ministry of State Security (MSS) — Beijing’s intelligence agency — and the United Front Work Department (UFWD) are working all out to subvert, sabotage and destroy from within Taiwan and the entire Western world, with Taiwan being on the front line. Millions of hacking attacks originating in China happen daily, and active and retired military officers are regularly targeted to spy for the CCP — too often successfully.
Temples, pro-unification political parties, gangs and other institutions are recruited to act as a fifth column for the CCP to subvert society from the inside, while students, businesses and even Taiwanese indigenous groups are brought to China on paid-for trips to be inundated with propaganda. Taiwanese businesspeople operating in China are also targets.
Secret Chinese police stations dot the globe, Chinese embassies regularly work to control overseas Chinese organizations and monitor and manipulate Chinese students and, taking advantage of free press laws, seek to buy out or control as much Chinese-language media as possible. Propaganda bots and armies of nationalist “little pinks” are deployed to swamp the Internet with propaganda, while TikTok is weaponized. Chinese hackers even once took over the screens of television monitors in a bunch of 7-Elevens in southern Taiwan and giant screens at train stations to spread propaganda.
Photo: AP
Politicians, academics and officials are often bought off, seduced by attractive lovers or otherwise influenced to serve the CCP’s interests, sometimes unknowingly. There are vast networks of spies, many non-professionals but led by professionals, engaging in espionage of all kinds that includes targets that would not traditionally be targeted by traditional intelligence agencies.
Military and business technological secrets are stolen and weaponized against their creators. Crucial elements of the world’s supply chain — such as rare earths and certain drug precursor chemicals — are gobbled up and dominated by China, which has already weaponized rare earths against Japan. Even massive oversupply of key industrial products, which previously included steel and solar panels but now include new fields such as electric vehicles, is weaponized by providing massive subsidies to make other countries’ industries no longer competitive, thereby destroying those industries overseas, and creating massive economic dislocation and unemployment.
A new Kiel Institute report estimates that direct — which does not include the myriad indirect — subsidies to favored industries in China was 3.5 percent of GDP, or three to nine times higher than other major industrial nations. Because GDP figures are known to be inflated in China and with indirect subsidies and the costs of stealing foreign intellectual property added in the real percentage is significantly higher.
FBI Director Christopher Wray told the Senate Intelligence Committee in 2021 that they open new counter-espionage cases against Chinese operations on average every 10 hours.
SCARY WEAPONS BEING FIRED?
When most people think of war, they are thinking of kinetic warfare, which is when large numbers of weapons are fired at people to kill them in massive numbers. The CCP is deploying large numbers of weapons and firing them, just not yet at people, which is referred to as gray zone warfare.
In August of 2022, Beijing dramatically changed the status quo across the Taiwan Strait by conducting large-scale live-fire military exercises in zones inside Taiwan’s Air Defense Identification Zone (ADIZ) to simulate a blockade. Missiles were also fired over Taiwan, though they did not impede on Taiwan’s legal air space because they were above the Karman line, which technically meant they were in space. Five missiles ultimately landed in Japan’s Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ).
Did the missiles land in Japan’s EEZ intentionally, or is the People’s Liberation Army Rocket Force (PLARF) incompetent? They landed to the southwest of Okinawa’s Hateruma Island, which is not currently claimed by China, though nationalists in China have long agitated for it to be “reclaimed” or returned to the Ryukyu Kingdom’s tributary status to the Chinese empire.
Chinese weapons are not known for their quality, and recently the top leadership of the PLARF has been removed. Reasons for the house cleaning include corruption that could have compromised missile quality, spying for the US, disloyalty to Chinese leader Xi Jinping (習近平) or some combination of the three. That all five landed in the same area suggests that this was intentional, but incompetence can never be ruled out.
The CCP claimed the exercises were in response to then US speaker of the house Nancy Pelosi’s visit to Taiwan. In reality, the complexity of the exercises meant that they had to have been planned on a timeline of months, if not years.
In other words, these exercises were going to be held regardless. Pelosi’s visit just happened to be their best opportunity to try and claim that they had to do it because Pelosi’s “provocative” trip forced their hand. If she had not visited, the CCP would have waited for another similar “opportunity.”
Alarmingly, many journalists and analysts still parrot Beijing’s propaganda and tie these exercises to Pelosi, implying somehow she is at fault.
Since August 2022, the CCP has regularly conducted drills and there are almost daily incursions into Taiwan’s ADIZ. Beijing claims the entire Taiwan Strait as their territorial waters, giving their coast guard increased authority to engage in armed action on their own. Since earlier this year, it has increasingly been taking aggressive actions near the Kinmen and Matsu Island groups.
The Davis Line, or median line, in the Taiwan Strait that from the 1950s to 2022 was considered a “do not cross” line by both sides has been obliterated by the Chinese side. All these actions are significant changes to the status quo by the CCP.
These gray zone actions are to train their military for war in waters that would be theaters of operations in an invasion, or in key zones if they wanted to go with the blockade option. They are also intended as psychological warfare against Taiwan’s air force, exhausting their personnel and wearing out Taiwan’s planes and requiring expensive maintenance, while also testing the Taiwanese air force capabilities.
These actions are also intended as psychological warfare against Taiwan’s public and politicians by maintaining a constant sense of threat, which they hope will push voters to vote for the Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT). There are some indications that they had some success, at least in the legislature, in this year’s elections and that some voters responded to the KMT’s “deterrence plus dialogue” messaging.
ASYMMETRICAL WARFARE
The attacks by the CCP are just some ways that they are waging war, but reading over this list there is no doubt that the CCP is engaging in a “whole-of-society” asymmetrical war with Taiwan and internationally, or what two senior Chinese air force officers dubbed in the title of their book “unrestricted warfare.” This “unrestricted warfare” is most advanced within Taiwan.
Some have declared this era is a “New Cold War.” A “Sapping War” with both sides actively working to undermine the other side seems a more fitting name. In an upcoming column we will look at when or why Xi might turn this war into a kinetic war.
Donovan’s Deep Dives is a regular column by Courtney Donovan Smith (石東文) who writes in-depth analysis on everything about Taiwan’s political scene and geopolitics. Donovan is also the central Taiwan correspondent at ICRT FM100 Radio News, co-publisher of Compass Magazine, co-founder Taiwan Report (report.tw) and former chair of the Taichung American Chamber of Commerce. Follow him on X: @donovan_smith.
Last week saw the appearance of another odious screed full of lies from the People’s Republic of China (PRC) Ambassador to Australia, Xiao Qian (肖千), in the Financial Review, a major Australian paper. Xiao’s piece was presented without challenge or caveat. His “Seven truths on why Taiwan always will be China’s” presented a “greatest hits” of the litany of PRC falsehoods. This includes: Taiwan’s indigenous peoples were descended from the people of China 30,000 years ago; a “Chinese” imperial government administrated Taiwan in the 14th century; Koxinga, also known as Cheng Cheng-kung (鄭成功), “recovered” Taiwan for China; the Qing owned
In Taiwan’s politics the party chair is an extremely influential position. Typically this person is the presumed presidential candidate or serving president. In the last presidential election, two of the three candidates were also leaders of their party. Only one party chair race had been planned for this year, but with the Jan. 1 resignation by the currently indicted Ko Wen-je (柯文哲) of the Taiwan People’s Party (TPP) two parties are now in play. If a challenger to acting Chairman Huang Kuo-chang (黃國昌) appears we will examine that race in more depth. Currently their election is set for Feb. 15. EXTREMELY
Jan. 20 to Jan. 26 Taipei was in a jubilant, patriotic mood on the morning of Jan. 25, 1954. Flags hung outside shops and residences, people chanted anti-communist slogans and rousing music blared from loudspeakers. The occasion was the arrival of about 14,000 Chinese prisoners from the Korean War, who had elected to head to Taiwan instead of being repatriated to China. The majority landed in Keelung over three days and were paraded through the capital to great fanfare. Air Force planes dropped colorful flyers, one of which read, “You’re back, you’re finally back. You finally overcame the evil communist bandits and
They increasingly own everything from access to space to how we get news on Earth and now outgoing President Joe Biden warns America’s new breed of Donald Trump-allied oligarchs could gobble up US democracy itself. Biden used his farewell speech to the nation to deliver a shockingly dark message: that a nation which has always revered its entrepreneurs may now be at their mercy. “An oligarchy is taking shape in America of extreme wealth, power and influence that literally threatens our entire democracy, our basic rights and freedoms,” Biden said. He named no names, but his targets were clear: men like Elon Musk
RSS