Last month, heavy rains brought by Typhoon Gaemi flooded dozens of neighborhoods in southwestern Taiwan — but things could have been much worse.
Several locations saw total precipitation exceeding that recorded 15 years ago during Typhoon Morakot, yet the resulting floods weren’t nearly so extensive. According to a July 29 report in the United Daily News (UDN), the affected area in Kaohsiung was less than a tenth of that in the 2009 calamity. And instead of being inundated for days, in most places the mud-colored water receded after just a few hours.
Keen to put a positive spin on their response to the deluge, the Kaohsiung City Government was quick to highlight how flood storage and other municipal infrastructure had mitigated the disaster.
Photo: Steven Crook
At the time of Morakot, the city had just one flood detention pond, a 110,000-cubic-meter basin in Sanmin District (三民). Kaohsiung now has 25 such ponds, 10 of which were completed in the last six years. In some cases, the authorities had to overcome opposition from residents who feared that having a detention basin nearby might increase the risk of their homes being flooded.
The Tainan section of Southern Taiwan Science Park (南部科學園區) came through Gaemi unscathed, but that was no consolation for some of those living nearby. While the park administration hailed the success of the industrial zone’s flood detention system, the borough warden of Shyjhongrong (許中營) told the China Times (July 26) that the high foundations of the park’s semiconductor fabs and optoelectronics factories had turned his own low-lying community into another detention pond.
MAJOR INVESTMENTS
Photo: Steven Crook
Kaohsiung’s flood detention ponds vary greatly in land area and capacity, with three of the largest being close to Dianbao Creek (典寶溪) in Ciaotou (橋頭) and Gangshan (岡山) districts. Together, they can hold up to 4.98 million cubic meters of water, greatly reducing the pressure on the city’s drains and waterways.
Such facilities also serve as parks and ameliorate urban heat, but they don’t come cheap. To complete one of the Dianbao Creek projects, the authorities spent NT$1.7 billion on acquiring land and a further NT$134.56 million on construction.
The UDN article quoted Yu Pao-shan (游保杉), an emeritus professor in National Cheng Kung University’s Department of Hydraulic and Ocean Engineering, as saying that Kaohsiung’s water-control infrastructure appears to have functioned as planned.
Photo: Chen Wen-chan, Liberty Times
Yu warned, however, that climate change may well cause even heavier rainfall in the future, and that this is an issue that Taiwan must face. Because precipitation is likely to exceed the current infrastructure’s design standards, he called on central and local governments, along with vulnerable communities, to jointly devise disaster-prevention strategies.
Like Yu, Liao Kuei-hsien (廖桂賢), director of the Taiwan Rivers Network, an NGO that works to promote the protection and restoration of river health, understands that Kaohsiung’s flood detention basins worked as intended. She responds to those who complain that the billions spent on them was wasted by saying that, even when precipitation is as extreme as during Gaemi, and even if future urban development increases overall flood risk, properly-maintained basins should still be able to hold back the amount of floodwater they were designed to detain.
“People need to understand that without human development, flooding is a natural phenomena,” says Liao, who’s also a professor in National Taipei University’s Graduate Institute of Urban Planning. When humans choose to develop an area that’s naturally flood-prone, rather than think flooding is abnormal, they should understand that artificial control, be it by flood detention basins or other hard infrastructure, is inevitably limited by its design standards, she says.
Photo: Lee Hui-chou, Taipei Times
Floating cars and submerged orchards make for compelling television, so it’s hardly surprising the media paid little attention to a village in Yunlin County that was spared the worst.
‘LOCALIZED FLOOD DETENTION’
Youcai (有才) in Baojhong Township (褒忠鄉) — a low-lying agricultural community susceptible to flooding — avoided serious problems during Gaemi as a result of what the Ministry of Economic Affairs’ Water Resources Agency calls “localized flood detention” (在地滯洪).
Photo: Taipei Times file
When sensors alerted the authorities to dangerously-high water levels, sluice gates were opened, releasing water onto farmland owned by Taiwan Sugar Corp (Taisugar). This second line of defense protected local homes from inundation. However, it’s an approach that requires more space than might be available in densely populated parts of Kaohsiung or Tainan.
Liao is among those who were impressed by the effectiveness of this solution, which creates detention capacity without extensively changing the landscape.
She says flood-prone cities and counties should create more space for water: “This includes, but shouldn’t be limited to, building more flood detention areas which aren’t conventional flood detention basins.”
Low-lying land should have more than one purpose, she argues. It can be farmland or parkland for most of the year, but ready to detain floodwater when needed.
“I think it’s especially important to incentivize farmers to allow their fallow fields to serve as flood detention areas during the typhoon season. Sufficient incentives could overcome the misconception that rainwater detention could ruin their farmland,” Liao says.
At the same time, Liao says Taiwan should embrace a different approach, one she has long championed. Rather than build even more flood-control infrastructure, she believes, the authorities should invest in making communities more floodable and flood-resilient, so that even if flooding occurs, there’s no significant damage or disruption.
Liao admits that this will be difficult, as Taiwan relies too much on hard infrastructure and people expect the government to invest in it.
“The entire system is designed around maintaining and adding flood control infrastructure,” she says, pointing out that such policies help politicians garner votes.
Liao doesn’t expect Typhoon Gaemi to lead to a change in thinking.
“It wasn’t ‘serious enough,’ in that it was mostly rural people who really suffered,” she says. “I think it’d take Taipei City being under deep water before mindsets change.”
Steven Crook, the author or co-author of four books about Taiwan, has been following environmental issues since he arrived in the country in 1991. He drives a hybrid and carries his own chopsticks. The views expressed here are his own.
Nov. 11 to Nov. 17 People may call Taipei a “living hell for pedestrians,” but back in the 1960s and 1970s, citizens were even discouraged from crossing major roads on foot. And there weren’t crosswalks or pedestrian signals at busy intersections. A 1978 editorial in the China Times (中國時報) reflected the government’s car-centric attitude: “Pedestrians too often risk their lives to compete with vehicles over road use instead of using an overpass. If they get hit by a car, who can they blame?” Taipei’s car traffic was growing exponentially during the 1960s, and along with it the frequency of accidents. The policy
While Americans face the upcoming second Donald Trump presidency with bright optimism/existential dread in Taiwan there are also varying opinions on what the impact will be here. Regardless of what one thinks of Trump personally and his first administration, US-Taiwan relations blossomed. Relative to the previous Obama administration, arms sales rocketed from US$14 billion during Obama’s eight years to US$18 billion in four years under Trump. High-profile visits by administration officials, bipartisan Congressional delegations, more and higher-level government-to-government direct contacts were all increased under Trump, setting the stage and example for the Biden administration to follow. However, Trump administration secretary
The room glows vibrant pink, the floor flooded with hundreds of tiny pink marbles. As I approach the two chairs and a plush baroque sofa of matching fuchsia, what at first appears to be a scene of domestic bliss reveals itself to be anything but as gnarled metal nails and sharp spikes protrude from the cushions. An eerie cutout of a woman recoils into the armrest. This mixed-media installation captures generations of female anguish in Yun Suknam’s native South Korea, reflecting her observations and lived experience of the subjugated and serviceable housewife. The marbles are the mother’s sweat and tears,
In mid-1949 George Kennan, the famed geopolitical thinker and analyst, wrote a memorandum on US policy towards Taiwan and Penghu, then known as, respectively, Formosa and the Pescadores. In it he argued that Formosa and Pescadores would be lost to the Chine communists in a few years, or even months, because of the deteriorating situation on the islands, defeating the US goal of keeping them out of Communist Chinese hands. Kennan contended that “the only reasonably sure chance of denying Formosa and the Pescadores to the Communists” would be to remove the current Chinese administration, establish a neutral administration and
RSS