This is the summer of hell for the Taiwan People’s Party (TPP) and their leader Ko Wen-je (柯文哲). In just the last few weeks the party has imploded. The question now is if they will have any future as an electable party or not.
The first blow fell on July 26, when the party’s Hsinchu Mayor Ann Kao (高虹安) was convicted on corruption charges and sentenced to seven years and four months in prison and suspended as Hsinchu mayor. She left the TPP in disgrace.
Then starting on Aug. 8, in quick succession the party became embroiled in three new scandals. There is a term to describe the current status of these three scandals — Roshomon (羅生門), the name of a classic movie by the superb Japanese director Akira Kurosawa. In the movie different characters describe the murder of a samurai in a forest, but with each giving wildly different accounts. The scandals embroiled the TPP are like this, with various actors giving very different explanations for what is going on.
Photo: Wang Jung-hsiang, Taipei Times
Like Roshomon, the situation unfolding around Ko and the TPP is edge-of-the-seat, popcorn-munching material full of colorful characters, allegations and attacks, lies and contradictions, intrigue and revenge and a fight for the very life of the nation’s third-largest political party against some of the best trench-fighting political operatives and celebrity commentators out for blood. Also possibly, depending on who you believe, gross mismanagement, corruption, embezzlement and/or fraud.
REVENGE, AUG. 8
In April, Grace Woo (吳靜怡), formerly in charge of Ko’s LINE account as mayor of Taipei and in 2020 number 25 on the list of TPP party list candidates, lost her party rights for a year after repeatedly trashing the party in the media. Woo, with dramatic frizzy hair and a penchant for sharp suit jackets, did not change and finally on July 4 she was expelled from the party.
Photo: Taipei Times file photo
She was determined to get her revenge and on Aug. 6 — Ko’s birthday — she dropped the bombshell that many of the entries in the TPP’s financial filings were untrue and there were some very dodgy-looking transitions worth NT$9.16 million involving the party and marketing firm MuKo Public Relations Marketing Limited (木可行銷公關), accounting firm Jing Hua CPA (精華會計師事務所), OCT Entertainment Co (時樂) and Neo Creative Marketing Production Co (尼奧創意行銷).
The ties between these companies and the party were tight. Ko presidential campaign chief financial officer and former high school classmate Lee Wen-tsung (李文宗) is the brother of Lee Wen-chuan (李文娟), the director of MuKo, which also has their offices in the same Taiwan Glass Building that hosts the TPP. They also have the exclusive rights to sell Ko’s copyrighted “kp” campaign swag. Ko goes by the nickname “Ko P” (“Ko professor” from his teaching days) and during the campaign he used it to double for “keep promise” (yes, singular).
As we shall see, Woo was just getting started. She was soon joined by others doing their own research, most notably pan-blue internet celebrity Liu Yu (劉宇), who is more widely known as 4xCat (四叉貓), a scruffy, perpetually disheveled bear of a man fond of casual sweatshirts and ponchos.
Photo: Screen grab from Peggy Chen’s Facebook page
KO’S WIFE ADDS TO MAYHEM, AUG. 9
While the TPP was scrambling to investigate their own accounts, the next day Ko’s wife Peggy Chen (陳佩琪), an internet celebrity in her own right, publicly apologized for registering a company and opening a bank account in her son’s name. The company was for the purpose of opening a cafe on the ground floor of Taiwan Glass Building named after the nickname of the young followers of Ko during the presidential campaign, “little grass” (小草), which was symbolized by a cute little sprout suggesting new beginnings.
At the time, she was a director at a government-owned hospital and she almost certainly was trying to get around the legal limitation on people classified as civil servants registering businesses.
Photo: Screen grab from YouTube
Initially Ko tried to portray her as not having any ill intent. Then he changed his story to saying it was not strange that parents would help their son with NT$100,000 to register his own business. Chen did the same, changing her story to say it was her son who did the registering.
She also started to sound defiant and no longer apologetic and contradicted herself again by saying “what law have I broken?” — which is a good question. Depending on the media outlet or the expert reports consulted, she may — or may not — have actually broken the law.
Regardless of the legality, it was a public relations nightmare. Most headlines on the topic either rentou (人頭), a term referring to using another person’s name to open accounts with the assumption for illicit purposes implied, or simply the word for fraud.
SCAPEGOAT, AUG. 10-12
By Aug. 10, Ko was admitting there were “flaws” in the accounting and called for calm while the party held an internal investigation. Additionally, the party apologized for what it said had been mistakes made during accounting, adding that it would conduct a full check of the inventory data again and resubmit the correct data to the Control Yuan, in accordance with the regulations.
It came to light the next day that the money raised at a “KP Show” concert held by Ko on July 29 last year and was at the time billed as a creative way to fundraise was not listed in the accounts. The show was given to the aforementioned MuKo to organize, who then subcontracted the execution to also aforementioned Neo Creative.
TPP spokesperson Celina Wu (吳怡萱) admitted in a pre-recorded video that the profits had gone to the companies and claimed that had been made clear prior to the concert. No one seems to remember that having been made clear, though perhaps it was in the fine print somewhere.
Several key figures in the party on Aug. 12 held a press conference. In it, they failed to report or misdeclared 17 expenses from its latest presidential election campaign, totaling more than NT$18 million.
All of this was blamed on accountant Tuanmu Cheng (端木正), of the aforementioned Jing Hua CPA, who the party hired to declare its financial records. TPP spokesperson Vicky Chen (陳智菡) claimed that Tuanmu said that the items were left out because they were under a time crunch and that he arbitrarily claimed approximately NT$18.17 million in expenses to OCT, Neo Creative and MuKe without notifying the party’s campaign team.
Jing Hua issued a statement in Tuanmu’s name, saying that the auditing service provided by the accountant for Ko’s political donations was conducted lawfully.
“We believe the Control Yuan and the prosecutors’ office should investigate the evidence, clarify the truth and prove the accountant innocent,” the statement said.
To apologize, the presidential campaign chief financial officer Lee Wen-tsung stood up and gave a deep bow. However, the party was still putting the blame squarely on Tuanmu.
Faced with all the unwanted attention, Lee’s sister the same day announced MuKe had decided to “suspend operations immediately” and proceed with legal liquidation and said all remaining profits after liquidation will be donated to charity, fulfilling a pledge to supporters.
Ko claimed that no money had gone into anyone’s pockets. He also said he was shocked and felt betrayed, and suggested this showed the party’s inexperience at having only run their very first presidential campaign.
As we shall soon see, Ko is trying to cover for his own actions. Safeguards and oversight mechanisms were in place within the TPP, but he removed them. Why?
Where did that NT$18.17 million go? Why was the entirety of their financial records reside in one person? These are just some of the questions raised by the Aug. 11 events that were not properly addressed and were just waived away as mistakes by one allegedly incompetent accountant.
FOUR DAYS
These four days would have been a total nightmare for any political party, but things are about to get much, much worse as this fiasco unfolds.
Another scandal also broke loose on Aug. 12 when one of Ko’s vice mayors was taken into custody, questioned and barred from leaving the country over yet another alleged corruption case that took place while Ko was mayor. So, in just four days Woo blew open the financial irregularities and potential embezzlement case, Peggy Chen may or may not have admitted to separately committed fraud and a corruption investigation involving his administration is creeping closer to Ko.
Stick around for this series of columns as we watch these multiple series of catastrophes unfold. Stock up on popcorn, you are going to need it.
Donovan’s Deep Dives is a regular column by Courtney Donovan Smith (石東文) who writes in-depth analysis on everything about Taiwan’s political scene and geopolitics. Donovan is also the central Taiwan correspondent at ICRT FM100 Radio News, co-publisher of Compass Magazine, co-founder Taiwan Report (report.tw) and former chair of the Taichung American Chamber of Commerce. Follow him on X: @donovan_smith.
Last week saw the appearance of another odious screed full of lies from the People’s Republic of China (PRC) Ambassador to Australia, Xiao Qian (肖千), in the Financial Review, a major Australian paper. Xiao’s piece was presented without challenge or caveat. His “Seven truths on why Taiwan always will be China’s” presented a “greatest hits” of the litany of PRC falsehoods. This includes: Taiwan’s indigenous peoples were descended from the people of China 30,000 years ago; a “Chinese” imperial government administrated Taiwan in the 14th century; Koxinga, also known as Cheng Cheng-kung (鄭成功), “recovered” Taiwan for China; the Qing owned
When 17-year-old Lin Shih (林石) crossed the Taiwan Strait in 1746 with a group of settlers, he could hardly have known the magnitude of wealth and influence his family would later amass on the island, or that one day tourists would be walking through the home of his descendants in central Taiwan. He might also have been surprised to see the family home located in Wufeng District (霧峰) of Taichung, as Lin initially settled further north in what is now Dali District (大里). However, after the Qing executed him for his alleged participation in the Lin Shuang-Wen Rebellion (林爽文事件), his grandsons were
I am kneeling quite awkwardly on a cushion in a yoga studio in London’s Shoreditch on an unseasonably chilly Wednesday and wondering when exactly will be the optimum time to rearrange my legs. I have an ice-cold mango and passion fruit kombucha beside me and an agonising case of pins and needles. The solution to pins and needles, I learned a few years ago, is to directly confront the agony: pull your legs out from underneath you, bend your toes up as high as they can reach, and yes, it will hurt far more initially, but then the pain subsides.
A jumbo operation is moving 20 elephants across the breadth of India to the mammoth private zoo set up by the son of Asia’s richest man, adjoining a sprawling oil refinery. The elephants have been “freed from the exploitative logging industry,” according to the Vantara Animal Rescue Centre, run by Anant Ambani, son of the billionaire head of Reliance Industries Mukesh Ambani, a close ally of Prime Minister Narendra Modi. The sheer scale of the self-declared “world’s biggest wild animal rescue center” has raised eyebrows — including more than 50 bears, 160 tigers, 200 lions, 250 leopards and 900 crocodiles, according to
RSS