Two exiled pro-democracy Hong Kong activists have been blocked from accessing their pensions, depriving them of tens of thousands of US dollars of their savings and raising questions about the complicity of western financial institutions in the persecution of Chinese government critics.
Assets, including pension savings, belonging to Ted Hui (許智?), a former pro-democracy legislator who is now based in Australia, were frozen shortly after he fled from Hong Kong in December 2020. The assets are held by HSBC, a British bank.
HSBC briefly unfroze Hui’s accounts in December 2020, during which time he was able to transfer “the majority of funds” out of Hong Kong, Hui said. But he recently said that his pension, worth several hundred thousand Hong Kong dollars, remains locked in his HSBC-administered pension scheme.
Photo: Reuters
The Guardian has learned that another high-profile pro-democracy figure, who has Australian permanent residence, has also been blocked from withdrawing his pension savings, worth more than HK$600,000 (US$76,900). The savings are managed by Manulife, a Canadian financial services firm.
Hui and the other activist, who does not wish to be named, have been issued with arrest warrants by the Hong Kong police for allegedly violating the city’s national security law while in exile. HK$1 million has been offered for information leading to their arrest.
In 2022, Hui was convicted in absentia for his role in the 2019 protests and sentenced to three-and-a-half years in jail.
In November, the second activist attempted to withdraw his pension from the fund administered by Manulife, one of the financial institutions approved to manage Hong Kong’s compulsory pensions scheme. He was notified in March that the claim could not be processed because his account was under investigation.
The exiled activist said Manulife’s decision was “hypocritical.”
“These companies like Manulife sign up to human rights pledges, but they don’t honor those pledges,” he said.
Manulife’s anti-slavery statement states that it is committed to “the protection of internationally proclaimed human rights.”
“The only reason to deny me is because of the national security law,” said the activist, who has no other legal charges against him.
A Manulife spokesperson said: “We do not comment on individual cases. Manulife complies with all laws and regulations in the jurisdictions we operate in.”
Hong Kong’s national security law, imposed in 2020 after months of pro-democracy protests, has been widely condemned by international governments and human rights organizations for suppressing free expression in Hong Kong. Tens of thousands of Hongkongers have left the city since it was imposed amid a wider crackdown on civil society. The Chinese and Hong Kong governments said the law was necessary to restore stability.
Hongkongers are entitled to withdraw their pensions early if they have permanently resettled outside Hong Kong. They must provide proof that they are permitted to reside overseas, such as permanent residence documents or a foreign passport.
In January 2021, in response to the national security law, the UK government launched a special visa scheme to Hongkongers in possession of a British national (overseas) (BNO) passport, allowing them to resettle in the UK. As of March, nearly 150,000 people have arrived in the UK via that route, according to Home Office statistics.
But Hong Kong and the pensions regulator, the Mandatory Provident Fund Authority (MPFA), have said that they do not recognize BNO passports as a valid travel document or as proof of permanent resettlement. That means many Hongkongers in the UK have been blocked from accessing savings, typically worth tens of thousands of US dollars per person.
Last year, there were 29,900 claims to withdraw pensions savings early on the grounds of permanent departure from Hong Kong, according to the MPFA, down from 31,700 in 2022.
The national security law allows the authorities to freeze the assets of anyone charged with violating national security. But critics say that the law, and the way in which it is used, is politically motivated.
Megan Khoo, a research and policy adviser at Hong Kong Watch, a pressure group, said: “Every week I receive rejection letters from Hongkongers on the British national (overseas) visa scheme … who continue to be blocked from accessing their hard-earned retirement savings. These two cases are particularly important, as they demonstrate that the freezing of Hongkongers’ assets is not just a BNO issue … but one of transnational repression.”
Hui said that the impact of being denied access to his savings was emotional as well as practical.
“It is a warning sign, targeting many of the high profile people advocating for freedom and democracy in Hong Kong,” he said.
A HSBC spokesperson said: “We are unable to comment on individual matters. We have to abide by the laws and regulations of the
The tropic of cancer bisects the city of Chiayi (嘉義). The morning heat is, predictably, intense. But the sky is blue and hued with promise. Travelers brave the heat to pose for photos outside the carriages lined up at the end of platform one. The pervasive excitement is understandable. HISTORIC RAILWAY The Alishan Forest Railway (阿里山森林鐵路) was engineered by the Japanese to carry timber from the interior to the coast. Construction began in 1906. In 1912, it opened to traffic, although the line has been lengthened several times since. As early as the 1930s, the line had developed a secondary function as
The Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) National Congress tomorrow will potentially be one of the most consequential in the party’s history. Since the founding of the DPP until the late 2000s or early 2010s, the party was riven with factional infighting, at times getting very ugly and very public. For readers curious to know more about the context of the factions and who they are, two previous columns explore them in depth: “The powerful political force that vanished from the English press,” April 23, 2024 and “Introducing the powerful DPP factions,” April 27, 2024. In 2008, a relatively unknown mid-level former
In Taiwan there are two economies: the shiny high tech export economy epitomized by Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電) and its outsized effect on global supply chains, and the domestic economy, driven by construction and powered by flows of gravel, sand and government contracts. The latter supports the former: we can have an economy without TSMC, but we can’t have one without construction. The labor shortage has heavily impacted public construction in Taiwan. For example, the first phase of the MRT Wanda Line in Taipei, originally slated for next year, has been pushed back to 2027. The government
July 22 to July 28 The Love River’s (愛河) four-decade run as the host of Kaohsiung’s annual dragon boat races came to an abrupt end in 1971 — the once pristine waterway had become too polluted. The 1970 event was infamous for the putrid stench permeating the air, exacerbated by contestants splashing water and sludge onto the shore and even the onlookers. The relocation of the festivities officially marked the “death” of the river, whose condition had rapidly deteriorated during the previous decade. The myriad factories upstream were only partly to blame; as Kaohsiung’s population boomed in the 1960s, all household