“Formosa in the 19th century was responsible for some of the most lurid pages in the history of the Far East,” wrote George Carrington in his 19th century PhD thesis, Foreigners in Formosa, 1841-1871. Chief among them was the sordid tale of the ships Ann and Nerbudda, wrecked off the coast of Taiwan (then known as Formosa, or “beautiful island”) during the First Opium War (1839-1942) between the Qing Dynasty and British Empire.
At the time Formosa was seen as a possible alternative market for the British opium trade. In 1837, William Jardine, co-founder of Jardine, Matheson and Co wrote: “The drug market is getting worse every day owing to the extreme vigilance of the authorities. The only thing to do is to send more armed European ships along the coast and try out new markets such as Formosa.”
Jardine advocated annexing Formosa and said that the English merchant community in China all supported such a move.
Photo courtesy of Wikimedia Commons
Echoing Jardine in 1840, as the Opium War entered its opening stages, the cartographer and linguist William Huttmann, one of those fascinating omni-talented people the British Empire minted like penny coins, wrote to foreign secretary Lord Palmerston arguing that the British should occupy the east coast of Formosa. He said that a base there would enable the British to “constantly harass the Chinese by land, and destroy their foreign and coasting trade by sea.”
To be seen as a font of disorder on the margins of great imperial states is a terrible calamity for a place. Just as Taiwan is today.
THE NERBUDDA
Photo courtesy of Wikimedia Commons
The Nerbudda left Hong Kong bound for Zhoushan in September of 1841. Aboard were 274 souls, including 243 Indians, sailors and their followers. The ship was dismasted in a storm, and drifting, hit a reef off Keelung. The Europeans, including the crew, quickly abandoned the ship, leaving “the Indians… to their fate,” Carrington records with obvious disgust.
The stricken ship then drifted into Keelung Harbor where it remained for several days. The Indians made rafts and attempted to float to shore. Some drowned, some were killed for their belongings when they reached shore, but roughly two-thirds made it and were captured by the local government. They were marched overland to Tainan.
In Tainan the Indians were imprisoned. Meanwhile, the Europeans in the rowboat drifted over to the east coast where a passing ship picked them up and took them to Hong Kong.
Photo courtesy of Wikimedia Commons
In October, a British sloop, the Nimrod, arrived in Keelung looking for survivors, offer $100 for each one. After learning that the survivors had been packed off to Tainan, the captain had the ship bombard the harbor. Not much of a diplomat was he.
THE ANN
In March of 1842, the Ann set off for Macao from Zhoushan, with 57 aboard, again mostly Indian sailors. She was buffeted by strong winds and forced into Daan Harbor in Taichung. The crew seized a couple of local junks and attempted to leave, but were surrounded and captured by locals after an armed standoff.
One of the men aboard the Ann, Robert Gully, left a diary of his experiences. From time to time they were taken out of their cramped, waterless cells (“our jailer was the most wicked brute ever created,” he averred) and moved about.
On one such journey, he observed: “The houses, together with every building we passed, were formed of the before-mentioned boulders and mud, with, in many instances, a large wide-spreading tree or trees with seats close to them,” a tradition that continues in Taiwan to this day.
“The country had a most wild and heavy aspect,” he continued “more so than any I ever saw, and I began to think ‘Formosa’ a sad misnomer.”
In both cases, the local Manchu Brigade General Dahonga (達洪阿) and Han official Yao Ying (姚瑩) reported to the Emperor claiming to have sunk the ships and captured the foreigners in the act of attacking Taiwan. The diary of Captain Denham of the Ann states that their interrogators tried to force them to say the Ann was a warship, and that two of the captured men from his ship were repeatedly whipped when they refused.
The two local leaders then asked the emperor for permission to execute the men as invaders. That came down in May of 1842, in revenge for a British victory in the war. The emperor ordered the leaders imprisoned, but the others to be executed.
A SAD FATE
The Chinese Repository, a periodical published between 1832 and 1851 for Protestant missionaries, tells the sad tale of their fate.
“On or about Aug. 13, 1842, one hundred and ninety-seven men, late of the British vessels the Ann and Nerbudda, were placed on their knees near to each other, their feet in irons and their hands manacled behind their backs.”
This was done in a large field just outside Tainan, with thousands of local onlookers. Executioners then proceeded to behead all 197. The heads were tossed into baskets to be displayed on the shore, while the bodies were thrown into a mass grave.
Later, according to reports of the time, in discussions with a British representative, Yao Ying denied that any British people had been killed, arguing that only 130 “black ones” had been killed.
In October of 1842, the British ship Serpent arrived in Taiwan, knowing that the executions had taken place, but still searching for survivors. They were able to rescue survivors from another shipwreck, who had been well treated.
The Nerbudda Incident could have served as a useful excuse for a British attempt to occupy Formosa, an interest that would again be stimulated by the discovery of coal in the north, and would wax and wane as the century wore on.
The British desire for coal was confounded, however, by two factors. First, it was still cheaper to ship coal from Hong Kong; second, the local gentry in Keelung blocked coal excavations in the hills above the city, on the grounds that mining works wrecked the fengshui (風水).
After Tamshui was opened as a Treaty Port in the wake of the Arrow War, a bizarre private Prussian-British initiative to erect a colony near Yilan County’s Suao took place in 1868. By early 1869, its leader, James Horn, had built a fortress and was levying taxes on the local indigenous communities, infuriating China’s Manchu leadership (recall that James Brooke, the first white Rajah of Sarawak, had just died after 27 years of rule, and the reader can imagine what Horn might have been dreaming).
James Milisch, the German merchant funding the colony, arrived and encouraged Horn to grow tea. In the interest of good relations with the Qing Dynasty, the British suppressed the colony later that year, and Horn’s dreams were lost with him at sea off the southern tip of Taiwan.
British interest in Taiwan in the mid 19th century remains just another of the numerous might-have-beens that populate Taiwan history.
Notes from Central Taiwan is a column written by long-term resident Michael Turton, who provides incisive commentary informed by three decades of living in and writing about his adoptive country. The views expressed here are his own.
Feb. 17 to Feb. 23 “Japanese city is bombed,” screamed the banner in bold capital letters spanning the front page of the US daily New Castle News on Feb. 24, 1938. This was big news across the globe, as Japan had not been bombarded since Western forces attacked Shimonoseki in 1864. “Numerous Japanese citizens were killed and injured today when eight Chinese planes bombed Taihoku, capital of Formosa, and other nearby cities in the first Chinese air raid anywhere in the Japanese empire,” the subhead clarified. The target was the Matsuyama Airfield (today’s Songshan Airport in Taipei), which
On Jan. 17, Beijing announced that it would allow residents of Shanghai and Fujian Province to visit Taiwan. The two sides are still working out the details. President William Lai (賴清德) has been promoting cross-strait tourism, perhaps to soften the People’s Republic of China’s (PRC) attitudes, perhaps as a sop to international and local opinion leaders. Likely the latter, since many observers understand that the twin drivers of cross-strait tourism — the belief that Chinese tourists will bring money into Taiwan, and the belief that tourism will create better relations — are both false. CHINESE TOURISM PIPE DREAM Back in July
Could Taiwan’s democracy be at risk? There is a lot of apocalyptic commentary right now suggesting that this is the case, but it is always a conspiracy by the other guys — our side is firmly on the side of protecting democracy and always has been, unlike them! The situation is nowhere near that bleak — yet. The concern is that the power struggle between the opposition Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) and their now effectively pan-blue allies the Taiwan People’s Party (TPP) and the ruling Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) intensifies to the point where democratic functions start to break down. Both
This was not supposed to be an election year. The local media is billing it as the “2025 great recall era” (2025大罷免時代) or the “2025 great recall wave” (2025大罷免潮), with many now just shortening it to “great recall.” As of this writing the number of campaigns that have submitted the requisite one percent of eligible voters signatures in legislative districts is 51 — 35 targeting Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) caucus lawmakers and 16 targeting Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) lawmakers. The pan-green side has more as they started earlier. Many recall campaigns are billing themselves as “Winter Bluebirds” after the “Bluebird Action”
RSS