There is no significant difference in the way humans and horses experience the pain of being struck by a whip, according to a landmark study that researchers say should end the argument on the continued use of the whip in horse racing.
It comes as Racing Victoria reaffirmed its commitment to reforming whip rules, after it formally tabled a proposal to phase out the whip at a board meeting of Racing Australia on Wednesday.
Racing Victoria said it would not discuss the meeting but that it maintained its belief that “the current national whip rules are no longer appropriate and that whip reform is vital for the future of our sport.”
Photo: AP
“RV will continue to advocate for whip reform which we believe is essential if racing is to retain its existing audiences and to ensure that it’s attractive for the fans and employees of tomorrow,” it said in a statement. “Considerations around the use of the whip in Victorian racing will remain a key priority for RV in the weeks and months ahead.”
The chairman of Racing Australia, Greg Nichols, told Guardian Australia that board meetings were confidential but that the proposed changes to the whip rules were subject to “quite rigorous debate.”
“It’s an issue that generates a diversity of views, they were all expressed, and we are actioning the process [to review the number of penalties issued for breaching whip rules] that we set in train six months ago,” he said.
Photo: AP
Nichols said he had requested a copy of the study on skin sensitivity and that it “could contribute to the debate as well.” “Everybody wants to be as informed as possible,” he said.
Racing NSW’s chief executive, Peter V’Landys, has previously criticized the proposed reforms, saying: “I would be the first to ban the whip if it did hurt the horse.”
“We should be calling it a riding crop,” he told Nine newspapers this month, saying Racing Victoria should instead focus on the number of deaths on the track at the Melbourne Cup. “Even the activists are starting to realize the whip doesn’t hurt the horse.”
The study, published in the journal Animals yesterday and funded by RSPCA Australia, compared the skin structure and nerve supply in skin from 10 humans and 20 thoroughbred or thoroughbred-type horses.
The skin from the thoroughbreds was taken from the rumps of horses slaughtered at export abattoirs, and the human samples were supplied by Macquarie University’s anatomy laboratory.
The study found there was “no significant difference between the epidermal nerve counts of humans and horses,” meaning that humans and horses had a similar sensitivity to pain.
The dermis of the horse — the layer of tissue below the epidermis, or outer layer of skin — is significantly thicker than that of humans. But this research, led by veterinary pathologist Lydia Tong of the Taronga Conservation Society, said that while that thicker dermis may offer some resilience against trauma, “it is not considered protective from external cutaneous pain”.
“These findings indicate that the superficial pain-sensitive epidermal layer of horse skin is as richly innervated and is of equivalent thickness as human skin, demonstrating that humans and horses have the equivalent key anatomic structures to detect cutaneous pain,” the study found.
It follows the publication of another study last month, also funded by the RSPCA, which found there was no benefit to race times or rider safety from using the whip.
The University of Sydney’s Paul McGreevy said the study should end the argument that whipping does not hurt horses.
“I don’t think you will find a veterinarian who will say that racehorses don’t feel the whip or find it aversive,” he said.
McGreevy said that while the whip was used in other equestrian disciplines, such as cross-country, which has faced its own reckoning on whip use, it is not generally used with the frequency and force seen in racing.
“There is an ethical degree of whip use that can get you out of trouble in a hazardous situation, but it is not the flogging that horses get on the racetrack,” he said. “It’s an irritant and proportionate to need.”
The whip was recognized as an aversive aid in horse riding and training — an aid that works because the animal wants to get away from it. The bit, spurs and kicking with a rider’s heels are also aversive aids.
The International Society for Equitation Science has said that where aversive aids are used, “a minimum amount and period of pressure should be applied to achieve the required response.”
Australia’s racing rules allow the whip to be used no more than five times before the final 100 metres of the race, when it can be used at the rider’s discretion. The jockey who rode second placed Tiger Moth in last week’s Melbourne Cup, Kerrin McEvoy, was fined AU$50,000 for breaching the whip rules.
McGreevy said jockeys could feel obliged to use the whip so that punters felt they had seen the horse run its best possible race.
“Whip use is established in racing because jockeys are required to show that they are riding the horse out on its merits,” he said. “That level of whip use is not expected in other disciplines and is not on the same scale.”
Racing NSW did not respond to requests for comment.
One of the biggest sore spots in Taiwan’s historical friendship with the US came in 1979 when US president Jimmy Carter broke off formal diplomatic relations with Taiwan’s Republic of China (ROC) government so that the US could establish relations with the People’s Republic of China (PRC). Taiwan’s derecognition came purely at China’s insistence, and the US took the deal. Retired American diplomat John Tkacik, who for almost decade surrounding that schism, from 1974 to 1982, worked in embassies in Taipei and Beijing and at the Taiwan Desk in Washington DC, recently argued in the Taipei Times that “President Carter’s derecognition
JUNE 30 to JULY 6 After being routed by the Japanese in the bloody battle of Baguashan (八卦山), Hsu Hsiang (徐驤) and a handful of surviving Hakka fighters sped toward Tainan. There, he would meet with Liu Yung-fu (劉永福), leader of the Black Flag Army who had assumed control of the resisting Republic of Formosa after its president and vice-president fled to China. Hsu, who had been fighting non-stop for over two months from Taoyuan to Changhua, was reportedly injured and exhausted. As the story goes, Liu advised that Hsu take shelter in China to recover and regroup, but Hsu steadfastly
You can tell a lot about a generation from the contents of their cool box: nowadays the barbecue ice bucket is likely to be filled with hard seltzers, non-alcoholic beers and fluorescent BuzzBallz — a particular favorite among Gen Z. Two decades ago, it was WKD, Bacardi Breezers and the odd Smirnoff Ice bobbing in a puddle of melted ice. And while nostalgia may have brought back some alcopops, the new wave of ready-to-drink (RTD) options look and taste noticeably different. It is not just the drinks that have changed, but drinking habits too, driven in part by more health-conscious consumers and
On Sunday, President William Lai (賴清德) delivered a strategically brilliant speech. It was the first of his “Ten Lectures on National Unity,” (團結國家十講) focusing on the topic of “nation.” Though it has been eclipsed — much to the relief of the opposing Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) and Taiwan People’s Party (TPP) — by an ill-advised statement in the second speech of the series, the days following Lai’s first speech were illuminating on many fronts, both domestic and internationally, in highlighting the multi-layered success of Lai’s strategic move. “OF COURSE TAIWAN IS A COUNTRY” Never before has a Taiwanese president devoted an entire speech to