During a recent staff meeting at school, some teachers proposed installing surveillance cameras in every classroom on the campus to address a recent incident. Some students had written offensive words on the blackboard to insult the teachers, and no one admitted to guilt. There was no way to find out who the culprits were.
Some teachers said installing security cameras could deter students from engaging in inappropriate behavior. They believe that in cases of property loss, students obstructing classroom discipline, bullying and contravention of the Gender Equity Education Act (性別平等教育法), surveillance footage would reveal the truth.
If it is really that beneficial, it is perhaps curious that there is not even a single classroom with a security camera installed, with the exception of kindergartens.
Ministry of Education regulations on surveillance cameras in schools say that to maintain campus safety and to safeguard personal privacy, surveillance cameras are mainly installed at campus entrances and exits, corridors, stairway corners and walkway corners.
There are no surveillance cameras in restrooms even though they are black spots for school accidents. One notorious example happened in 2000, when a 15-year-old boy, Yeh Yung-chih (葉永鋕), who had been bullied for years due to his alleged effeminate behavior, died in the school toilet, where the bullies had attacked him.
However, installing surveillance cameras in school washrooms would infringe on students’ personal privacy. Therefore, security cameras could only be installed at the entrance of a restroom, but never inside.
Those who support installing security cameras in classrooms might say that teachers and students who are opposed to the idea have a guilty conscience — they are afraid that their inappropriate behavior would be exposed.
If that argument is valid, then the same reasoning could apply to installing surveillance cameras pointed at teachers’ desks. If teachers do not loaf around, why would they be afraid of being watched by a security camera?
We should all be sympathetic regarding the privacy issue. When you browse the Internet, you would not want other people to stare at your computer screen to see what you are looking at even if it is not a questionable Web site. There is, after all, a reasonable expectation of privacy.
When teachers are not teaching classes, they should be able to feel at ease in the office. Stretching their feet when the weather is hot, picking their noses or scratching an itch are no big deal, but what if you have a surveillance camera pointed at you? How would you feel? Would you still be able to relax? People should be able to have a reasonable expectation of privacy even in public venues.
There are pros and cons of installing surveillance cameras in classrooms. Taking protecting personal privacy into consideration, it should not be done hastily, especially since no consensus has been reached and parents have not given their consent.
Protecting teachers and students is just a sugarcoated excuse to install surveillance cameras and cover up the malicious intention of infringing on others’ privacy.
Lin Cheng-wu is a junior-high school teacher.
Translated by Fion Khan
Although former US secretary of state Mike Pompeo — known for being the most pro-Taiwan official to hold the post — is not in the second administration of US president-elect Donald Trump, he has maintained close ties with the former president and involved himself in think tank activities, giving him firsthand knowledge of the US’ national strategy. On Monday, Pompeo visited Taiwan for the fourth time, attending a Formosa Republican Association’s forum titled “Towards Permanent World Peace: The Shared Mission of the US and Taiwan.” At the event, he reaffirmed his belief in Taiwan’s democracy, liberty, human rights and independence, highlighting a
The US Department of Defense recently released this year’s “Report on Military and Security Developments Involving the People’s Republic of China.” This annual report provides a comprehensive overview of China’s military capabilities, strategic objectives and evolving global ambitions. Taiwan features prominently in this year’s report, as capturing the nation remains central to Chinese President Xi Jinping’s (習近平) vision of the “great rejuvenation of the Chinese nation,” a goal he has set for 2049. The report underscores Taiwan’s critical role in China’s long-term strategy, highlighting its significance as a geopolitical flashpoint and a key target in China’s quest to assert dominance
The Directorate-General of Budget, Accounting and Statistics (DGBAS) last week released the latest job vacancy data in Taiwan, which highlighted how many job openings firms had yet to be filled at the end of August last year. The data also revealed how the vacant positions were closely related to the business climate that industrial and services sectors faced at the time. The DGBAS collects data on job vacancies at the end of February, May, August and November every year. The number of job vacancies includes recruits for expanding operations and additional production lines as well as for openings related to
The Legislative Yuan passed legislation on Tuesday aimed at supporting the middle-aged generation — defined as people aged 55 or older willing and able to work — in a law initially proposed by Taiwan People’s Party (TPP) Legislator Wu Chun-cheng (吳春城) to help the nation transition from an aged society to a super-aged society. The law’s passage was celebrated by the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP), the Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) and the TPP. The brief show of unity was welcome news, especially after 10 months of political fighting and unconstitutional amendments that are damaging democracy and the constitutional order, eliciting concern
RSS