When former Russian minister of defense Sergei Shoigu was removed from his post and appointed head of the Russian Security Council this week, there were two big questions on everyone’s minds: What would his successor, Andrei Belousov, bring to the table, and what would happen to former security council secretary Nikolai Patrushev — reputed to be the second-most powerful man in Russia and seen by many as a potential successor to Russian President Vladimir Putin?
The second question has a straightforward answer. Patrushev, it seems, is being sidelined. Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov on Tuesday said Patrushev had been appointed to the grand position of presidential aide for shipbuilding — barring any further surprise moves, this is a considerable downgrade in role.
The question of what Shoigu’s removal would mean is a bit trickier, but it might also be a case of Putin neutralizing an ally who has become too powerful. The Kremlin reshuffle was initially interpreted as a much-needed anti-corruption cleanup within Russia’s security apparatus. There was last month’s arrest of Shoigu’s close ally, former Russian deputy minister of defense Timur Ivanov, and the reported detention on unspecified criminal charges of Yuri Kuznetsov, another senior figure in the defense ministry this week.
However, Russian political scientist Mikhail Savva said that Shoigu’s dismissal, and the nomination of Belousov as the new minister of defense, “have nothing to do with Shoigu’s corruption,” adding that “in those circles everyone steals.”
This is about two things: taking back control of military spending and removing any threat to Putin’s power.
Belousov is described as a trustworthy “bureaucrat among bureaucrats,” and “President Putin’s Albert Speer,” who would take Russia’s military industrial complex to a new level of efficiency. Russia’s myriad of pro-war bloggers have welcomed him as a technocratic manager who would undertake a full audit of military spending and manage the finances and procurement vital to the army, but leave military issues to the general staff.
By putting an economist who strongly believes that the state should be the main driver of the economy at the head of the Russian Ministry of Defense, Putin is showing the world that he is turning the whole of Russia into a war machine, and that he is digging in for the long haul. For this he needs a good technocrat who is above all loyal.
Unlike Shoigu, Belousov does not come with a power base or a clan of loyal followers. He owes his position to Putin, is an introvert who does not seek the limelight and, most importantly, does not threaten to build a parallel power base to Putin. Vladimir Osechkin, an exiled political commentator with close ties to the security apparatus, said that Putin is terrified of a repeat of the events in June last year, when Russian mercenary chief Yevgeny Prigozhin led a mutinous rebellion.
So, if it seems strange to dismiss the minister of defense while things are picking up on the front, it is precisely because of that success that Putin can now move Shoigu aside.
“Putin was afraid of changing the top brass in the defense ministry while the front was unstable,” said Ivan Preobrazhensky, a Russian political commentator and member of the Free Russia Forum.
All of this points to Putin’s fear of the power struggles inside the Kremlin and the awareness that, as he builds his absolutist power, there are cracks that could widen unless he takes pre-emptive measures. In this context, it is interesting to look at some of the other appointments of the past few days.
While Patrushev has been given the unenviable task of supervising the building of ships to replace those that have been destroyed by Ukrainian drones, his son Dmitry has been promoted from agriculture minister to deputy prime minister in charge of agriculture. Another dynastic positioning also took place at the weekend when Putin nominated Boris Kovalchuk, the son of his closest adviser and main financier Yuri Kovalchuk, to be head of Russia’s audit chamber.
By placing the children of his close advisers in prominent positions, Putin shows he is playing for the long haul, and making every effort to secure his future and that of his closest allies. He is signaling to them that they are safe for now, but by tying the next generation of leaders to his political survival he is clipping the wings of any potential threat in a carefully crafted balancing act.
Mark Galeotti, the director of Mayak Intelligence and a historian specializing in Russia, said that Shoigu is unlikely to inherit much power in his new post at the security council.
Patrushev was seen as highly influential in that role, but this is derived partly from his personality, as well as his past as an old Putin confidant in St Petersburg, and as former head of the Russian Federal Security Service, Galeotti said.
In his new position, Shoigu would also oversee the federal service for military-technical cooperation. Between this, and Patrushev as shipbuilding aide, the nominal heads of some of the most corrupt sectors of the Russian economy are controlled by Putin. Putin has effectively just put the whole military industrial complex under presidential control, thereby boosting his personal power by taking over the whole of the war economy and the opportunities for corruption that go with it.
In the short term, this makes Putin seem even more impregnable and underlines that he is not interested in any kind of peace that would put a stop to the war, which feeds his political and material power. It also shows how wary he is of political challengers, and leaves him very vulnerable should the war not go his way. In the medium and long term, this would spell disaster for the Russian economy, as the war drains resources and human power into a cycle of production, the only aim of which is to feed the war.
Those who think that Putin would be open to negotiating over a piece of eastern Ukraine and Crimea should bear this in mind when hoping for a quick negotiated end to the war. Putin needs war to survive.
Samantha de Bendern is an associate fellow in the Russia and Eurasia program at Chatham House and a political commentator on La Chaine Info in France.
Would China attack Taiwan during the American lame duck period? For months, there have been worries that Beijing would seek to take advantage of an American president slowed by age and a potentially chaotic transition to make a move on Taiwan. In the wake of an American election that ended without drama, that far-fetched scenario will likely prove purely hypothetical. But there is a crisis brewing elsewhere in Asia — one with which US president-elect Donald Trump may have to deal during his first days in office. Tensions between the Philippines and China in the South China Sea have been at
Russian President Vladimir Putin’s hypersonic missile carried a simple message to the West over Ukraine: Back off, and if you do not, Russia reserves the right to hit US and British military facilities. Russia fired a new intermediate-range hypersonic ballistic missile known as “Oreshnik,” or Hazel Tree, at Ukraine on Thursday in what Putin said was a direct response to strikes on Russia by Ukrainian forces with US and British missiles. In a special statement from the Kremlin just after 8pm in Moscow that day, the Russian president said the war was escalating toward a global conflict, although he avoided any nuclear
A nation has several pillars of national defense, among them are military strength, energy and food security, and national unity. Military strength is very much on the forefront of the debate, while several recent editorials have dealt with energy security. National unity and a sense of shared purpose — especially while a powerful, hostile state is becoming increasingly menacing — are problematic, and would continue to be until the nation’s schizophrenia is properly managed. The controversy over the past few days over former navy lieutenant commander Lu Li-shih’s (呂禮詩) usage of the term “our China” during an interview about his attendance
Bo Guagua (薄瓜瓜), the son of former Chinese Communist Party (CCP) Central Committee Politburo member and former Chongqing Municipal Communist Party secretary Bo Xilai (薄熙來), used his British passport to make a low-key entry into Taiwan on a flight originating in Canada. He is set to marry the granddaughter of former political heavyweight Hsu Wen-cheng (許文政), the founder of Luodong Poh-Ai Hospital in Yilan County’s Luodong Township (羅東). Bo Xilai is a former high-ranking CCP official who was once a challenger to Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) for the chairmanship of the CCP. That makes Bo Guagua a bona fide “third-generation red”
RSS