In his novel The Hunchback of Notre Dame, French writer Victor Hugo tells the story of Quasimodo, the ugly but kindhearted bell-ringer of the Notre Dame de Paris cathedral. British physicist Wade Allison compared electric-power facilities to Quasimodo, saying that ugly as they might be, they are helpful to society.
Many people think that state-run Taiwan Power Co’s (Taipower) transformer boxes look awful and steer clear of them or even blame them for various problems, yet those transformers are essential for everyone who uses electricity.
There is a case concerning a transformer box on the campus of the New Taipei Special School in New Taipei City’s Linkou District (林口). When it emerged that five of the school’s teachers have been stricken with cancer in past five years, some people said electromagnetic waves are the “culprit.”
The school principal and councilors have become enraged over this issue, with everyone blaming Taipower.
Over the years, the state has incurred great losses over such matters. An electricity substation that was shuttered at National Taiwan Ocean University 30 years ago had cost NT$200 million (US$6.36 million) to build, and it would cost NT$13.6 million to relocate the transformer at the New Taipei Special School.
Electromagnetic fields are commonly known as electromagnetic waves. Invisible as they are, some people see them as a hidden danger and think they are harmful.
However, the human body is a “power station” in itself. The nervous and muscular activities of the human body are naturally stimulated by electric currents. The effect of external electromagnetic fields on the human body is about 1,000 times less than that generated by the body itself.
The WHO Fact Sheet No. 322 “Electromagnetic Fields and Public Health” says there is no evidence that electricity is harmful to people, and a report by the US National Academy of Sciences draws a similar conclusion. That the US, Canada and other countries set no technical standards regarding electromagnetic waves shows that they are harmless and do not need to be controlled.
The high-voltage equipment on the campus of the New Taipei Special School emits electromagnetic radiation in the range of 20 milligauss (mG), which is about the same as that emitted by a refrigerator, and much less than the Earth’s magnetic field, whose intensity is about 500mG.
The WHO’s safety standard, which used to be 833mG, has since been relaxed to 2,000mG, but Taiwan has yet to make a similar change. Moreover, the Ministry of the Interior’s list of items that must and must not be listed in real-estate manuals includes nearby installations such as electricity substations, on the grounds that such facilities are socially undesirable.
The Ministry of Health and Welfare should seize this opportunity to investigate the reasons why the five teachers got cancer. Such an investigation would probably exonerate Taipower and relieve it from being blamed.
We all need to use electricity, and the same is true of the nation as a whole. That is why Taipower has built four new electric substations to ensure sufficient power supply for Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co, which is a major pillar of the nation’s economy.
Protests about electromagnetic radiation are based on a misunderstanding. The associated anxiety can hurt people’s health and harm national security. Scientific education needs to be strengthened, and the government should be prepared to intervene when necessary.
Lin Ji-shing is a university professor.
Translated by Julian Clegg
Deterrence is fading; war is looming on the Taiwan Strait and for other targets of the China-enabled dictatorship alliance, and after three years the cure is just dawning on the Biden Administration. Now mind you, for a May 28, 2024 interview with Time magazine, President Joe Biden made his 5th public commitment that the United States would defend Taiwan. Less than three weeks later the United States Navy, along with ships from navies of Japan, Canada, the Netherlands, and France, were conducting the Valiant Shield joint force exercise in the Philippine Sea south of Taiwan and in the South China Sea to
While the Chinese People’s Liberation Army (PLA) consistently sends drones to harass military bases in Taiwan’s outlying islands and along the coastline, new US Indo-Pacific Commander Admiral Samuel Paparo told the Washington Post that the US military would implement a “Hellscape” strategy involving thousands of uncrewed systems to deter a Chinese invasion. Josh Rogin, who authored the article which was published on Monday last week, spoke to Paparo on the sidelines of the recent Shangri-La Dialogue defense forum in Singapore. Paparo told him that as soon as China’s invasion force began to move across the 180km Taiwan Strait, the US military
The Chinese Communist Party (CCP) has once again resorted to its age-old tactic of blaming the US for China’s woes. The Financial Times on Sunday reported that Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) told European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen that China would not invade Taiwan because it was a trap set by the US. This is not just an attempt to deflect blame, but also a textbook example of the CCP’s “divide and conquer” strategy to sow discord between Europe and the US. However, the blame game reveals deeper problems. Xi’s power rests on the support of the Chinese People’s Liberation
The official media of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) reacted to the May 20 inauguration speech of President William Lai (賴清德) by asserting: “Lai’s words reveal his true intention of sacrificing peace and stability across the Taiwan Strait for his own desire for power.” This baseless accusation by Beijing that Lai is manipulating Taiwanese to resist unification with China for his personal gain, is part of a broader CCP information warfare campaign that has intensified since Lai’s election. This campaign, orchestrated by the United Front Work Department, the CCP’s agency for coordinating influence operations and propaganda, aims to demoralize Taiwanese,