Civilian control over the military is common in advanced democracies and is an inevitable trend. As Taiwan continues to reform the military and implement law-based administration of the armed forces, it is important to let more civilian leaders take charge of strategic decisionmaking, paving the way for the appointment of civilians as minister and deputy minister of national defense.
In the US, Japan and some European nations, ministers and deputy ministers of national defense are civilians. This way, the decisionmaking process would not be dominated by military officers, but would include input from professionals from different fields. That should help modernize national defense agencies, create more comprehensive national defense policies and contribute to the innovation of the military’s operations.
The heads of national defense in the UK, Japan and India are all civilians. These three countries rank among the top 10 in terms of global military power; Japan also had had two female defense heads. Other examples include Germany, France, Italy, the Netherlands, Australia, New Zealand and Canada. The incumbent defense ministers of the Netherlands and New Zealand are female. In 2021, the US appointed its first female deputy secretary of defense, Kathleen Hicks.
In 2002, Taiwan announced plans to converge its military command and administration systems. The ultimate goal is to have civilians replace military officers as heads of national defense, who would lead a group of professionals from different fields to improve Taiwan’s national defense institutions. Fundamentally, they are expected to change the culture of the armed forces, improve the military’s administrative efficiency and place all military affairs under administrative law.
Twenty-two years have passed since the enactment of the National Defense Act (國防法) and the Organization Act of the Ministry of National Defense (國防部組織法). During the tenure of former president Chen Shui-bian (陳水扁), he appointed one civilian as defense minister and two as deputy defense ministers. Former president Ma Ying-jeou (馬英九) also had one civilian defense minister and two civilian deputy ministers.
It would be significantly meaningful if the next president would also tap civilians to serve as minister and deputy minister of national defense.
Although Taiwan is a democratic country, administrative law has yet to be fully practiced in the military. Civilian leaders should be appointed to important positions in the Ministry of National Defense, such as permanent secretary or head of the department for strategic planning. However, for decades, only military officers — with a few exceptions — have been assigned to these positions, as a hierarchy based on military rank allows the ministry to be dominated by military officers. Under such a culture, it is not surprising that scandals and cases of espionage have repeatedly recurred. If the hierarchy remains in place, military reforms would never happen.
Taiwan needs to keep pushing forward on national defense reforms and law-based administration in the military. Some conservative organizations in the armed forces should be fundamentally changed or transformed. The key is to let civilian leaders supervise the transformation by making them the next minister and deputy minister of national defense.
Yao Chung-yuan is an adjunct professor and former deputy director of the Ministry of National Defense’s strategic planning department.
Translated by Emma Liu
The return of US president-elect Donald Trump to the White House has injected a new wave of anxiety across the Taiwan Strait. For Taiwan, an island whose very survival depends on the delicate and strategic support from the US, Trump’s election victory raises a cascade of questions and fears about what lies ahead. His approach to international relations — grounded in transactional and unpredictable policies — poses unique risks to Taiwan’s stability, economic prosperity and geopolitical standing. Trump’s first term left a complicated legacy in the region. On the one hand, his administration ramped up arms sales to Taiwan and sanctioned
The Taiwanese have proven to be resilient in the face of disasters and they have resisted continuing attempts to subordinate Taiwan to the People’s Republic of China (PRC). Nonetheless, the Taiwanese can and should do more to become even more resilient and to be better prepared for resistance should the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) try to annex Taiwan. President William Lai (賴清德) argues that the Taiwanese should determine their own fate. This position continues the Democratic Progressive Party’s (DPP) tradition of opposing the CCP’s annexation of Taiwan. Lai challenges the CCP’s narrative by stating that Taiwan is not subordinate to the
US president-elect Donald Trump is to return to the White House in January, but his second term would surely be different from the first. His Cabinet would not include former US secretary of state Mike Pompeo and former US national security adviser John Bolton, both outspoken supporters of Taiwan. Trump is expected to implement a transactionalist approach to Taiwan, including measures such as demanding that Taiwan pay a high “protection fee” or requiring that Taiwan’s military spending amount to at least 10 percent of its GDP. However, if the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) invades Taiwan, it is doubtful that Trump would dispatch
Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC) has been dubbed Taiwan’s “sacred mountain.” In the past few years, it has invested in the construction of fabs in the US, Japan and Europe, and has long been a world-leading super enterprise — a source of pride for Taiwanese. However, many erroneous news reports, some part of cognitive warfare campaigns, have appeared online, intentionally spreading the false idea that TSMC is not really a Taiwanese company. It is true that TSMC depositary receipts can be purchased on the US securities market, and the proportion of foreign investment in the company is high. However, this reflects the
RSS