On April 22, 2021, music teacher Chan Hui-ling (詹慧玲) was stopped and questioned in Taoyuan’s Jhongli District (中壢) by a police officer, surnamed Yeh (葉). When she refused to cooperate, she was thrown to the ground and arrested for obstructing an officer in carrying out their duties.
Chan filed a complaint against the officer, but the Taoyuan District Prosecutors’ Office declined to press charges. After Chan applied for a reconsideration, the Taiwan High Prosecutors’ Office ordered local authorities to conduct a second review. Yeh was found guilty in the first trial of coercion by a public official and was sentenced to four months in jail, in addition to offenses against personal freedom by a public official, for which he received a further six months.
The case highlights the major problem with spot checks by police.
Police conduct spot checks to maintain social order — not for criminal investigations. As such, spot checks do not involve arrest or search warrants, and are not subject to stringent oversight. Many years ago, the only legal basis for spot checks by police was Article 11 of the Police Duty Act (警察勤務條例), which demonstrates the dearth of attention given to spot checks. It was not until the passage of the 2003 Police Power Exercise Act (警察職權行使法), following the grand justices’ issuance of Interpretation No. 535 in 2001, that clearer legal norms were laid for spot checks.
According to Interpretation No. 535, police cannot conduct arbitrary or random inspections regardless of time, location or individuals. There must be reasonable doubt that shows the person poses a risk to endangering public safety or order.
Furthermore, before carrying out a spot check, there must be reasonable grounds to believe the person constitutes a hazard or will cause a hazard. This principle is also laid out in the first item of Article 6 of the Police Power Exercise Act.
Based on Paragraph 1, Article 4 of the same act, when initiating a stop-and-check, police shall present their credentials showing their identity and state their intent. Furthermore, Paragraph 1, Article 3 of the same act states that the principle of proportionality must be observed.
If an officer were to conduct a spot check without following legal procedures — for example, basing their action on subjective feelings, such as they think the target is a stranger or acting strangely — did not inform the other person why they were targeted, or breached the principle of proportionality, etc., they have no legal basis on which to conduct the check. In such cases, based on Paragraph 2, Article 4 of the Police Power Exercise Act, people have the right to refuse to cooperate.
Since the crime of obstructing an officer in discharge of their duties as stated in Paragraph 1, Article 135 of the Criminal Code assumes that civil servants perform their duties in accordance with the law, resisting illegal checks is a legitimate self-defense, and it is not considered obstructing an officer in carrying out their duties. It is the police who might be breaking the law if they were to take a person into custody without proper authority, through coercion or after an illegal search.
Most people would feel intimidated or unsure of what the legal consequences would be if they refused to cooperate. They could take legal action after the incident, but by that time it would be difficult to collect evidence. It is rare for somebody to stand up for their rights in the manner like Chan did, leading to the prosecution of a police officer.
As the Police Power Exercise Act has been in force for nearly 20 years, aside from reviewing and amending legislation, police must strive to comply with due process and protect people’s rights when conducting random inspections.
Wu Ching-chin is a law professor at Aletheia University and director of the university’s Research Center for Criminal Law.
Translated by Lin Lee-kai
The EU’s biggest banks have spent years quietly creating a new way to pay that could finally allow customers to ditch their Visa Inc and Mastercard Inc cards — the latest sign that the region is looking to dislodge two of the most valuable financial firms on the planet. Wero, as the project is known, is now rolling out across much of western Europe. Backed by 16 major banks and payment processors including BNP Paribas SA, Deutsche Bank AG and Worldline SA, the platform would eventually allow a German customer to instantly settle up with, say, a hotel in France
On August 6, Ukraine crossed its northeastern border and invaded the Russian region of Kursk. After spending more than two years seeking to oust Russian forces from its own territory, Kiev turned the tables on Moscow. Vladimir Putin seemed thrown off guard. In a televised meeting about the incursion, Putin came across as patently not in control of events. The reasons for the Ukrainian offensive remain unclear. It could be an attempt to wear away at the morale of both Russia’s military and its populace, and to boost morale in Ukraine; to undermine popular and elite confidence in Putin’s rule; to
A traffic accident in Taichung — a city bus on Sept. 22 hit two Tunghai University students on a pedestrian crossing, killing one and injuring the other — has once again brought up the issue of Taiwan being a “living hell for pedestrians” and large vehicle safety to public attention. A deadly traffic accident in Taichung on Dec. 27, 2022, when a city bus hit a foreign national, his Taiwanese wife and their one-year-old son in a stroller on a pedestrian crossing, killing the wife and son, had shocked the public, leading to discussions and traffic law amendments. However, just after the
The international community was shocked when Israel was accused of launching an attack on Lebanon by rigging pagers to explode. Most media reports in Taiwan focused on whether the pagers were produced locally, arousing public concern. However, Taiwanese should also look at the matter from a security and national defense perspective. Lebanon has eschewed technology, partly because of concerns that countries would penetrate its telecommunications networks to steal confidential information or launch cyberattacks. It has largely abandoned smartphones and modern telecommunications systems, replacing them with older and relatively basic communications equipment. However, the incident shows that using older technology alone cannot