Foreign workers and tourists stranded in Cambodia during the COVID-19 pandemic have been trafficked and forced to work in sophisticated Chinese-run online scams, a Thomson Reuters Foundation investigation has found.
In interviews, nine trafficking victims said they were lured by social media adverts promising well-paid jobs in call centers.
Instead, they ended up in shuttered hotel casinos and guarded compounds where they had their passports confiscated before being put to work online.
Illustration: Yusha
The victims, mainly from Africa and Asia, said they were ordered to create fake profiles on Tinder, WhatsApp and Facebook to entice people into fraudulent investment schemes involving cryptocurrencies, foreign exchange and shares.
Those who objected or performed poorly were subjected to violence and threats, victims said.
Mary, a teacher from the Philippines, said she miscarried while locked in a room without food and water for three days.
“We were desperate,” said Mary, who was three months pregnant and four months out of work when she responded in July to a Facebook post offering call center jobs to English-speaking foreigners.
“We thought it was real work, but it became a living nightmare,” said the 26-year-old, whose name has been changed to protect her identity.
Approached for comment on the nine trafficking cases that the Thomson Reuters Foundation uncovered, a spokesperson for the Cambodian Ministry of the Interior said: “We also have heard about this before, but until now we still do not have any evidence.”
Cambodian police have previously carried out raids and deported hundreds of Chinese on suspicion of telecoms scams.
However, organized crime experts said police have struggled to stamp out online crime because of corruption and weak law enforcement.
A Facebook spokesperson said the company would investigate profiles and groups passed on by the Thomson Reuters Foundation.
A spokesperson for WhatsApp said that users should use tools in the app to report suspicious activity.
A Tinder spokesperson said it had “zero tolerance” for “romance scams” and that it would “work with law enforcement to ensure justice is served in such cases.”
‘CHINESE MAFIA’
Cambodia shut its borders when COVID-19 struck in March last year, barred almost all international flights and closed its schools to contain the virus, leaving many tourists and foreign workers unemployed and unable to return home.
For more than a decade, Chinese criminal groups have used Cambodia as a base for online scams that duped Chinese nationals out of billions of dollars. Crime experts said the pandemic has made it easier for these groups to target stranded foreigners.
Four of the nine captives interviewed by the Thomson Reuters Foundation were unemployed teachers — three from Asia and one from Uganda. Another was a construction worker from Bangladesh, three were tourists and one was a Tanzanian graphic designer.
Two days after agreeing to work at a call center near the Phnom Penh airport, Mary was in her recruiter’s car, bound for on-site training — or so she thought.
When the car passed the airport, the driver said the induction had been moved to Sihanoukville, a port city about 200km away that has received an influx of money from China, Cambodia’s largest foreign investor.
More than 80 casinos have been built in the city, largely for foreign tourists and online punters, as it is illegal for Cambodians to gamble.
Back in 2018, the province’s governor at the time, Yun Min, had warned that the influx of Chinese investment in the region was leading to a surge in crimes by “Chinese mafia,” including kidnapping.
China’s embassy in Phnom Penh declined to comment on the Thomson Reuters Foundation’s findings, but called on Cambodia to enforce its online gambling ban, which it introduced in 2019, saying the industry had become a security concern amid rising reports of crime.
“Kidnapping and human trafficking are by-products of illegal online gambling,” a spokesperson said in e-mailed comments. “Instead of addressing only the symptoms by focusing on individual cases, full implementation of online gambling prohibition can stem the problem from its root.”
LOCKED IN A ROOM
Inside a heavily guarded compound in Sihanoukville, Mary said she handed her passport to human resources and was given the tools for her new job: five iPhones and five British SIM cards.
Mary said she was told to use images of attractive women to create fake identities on Tinder, WhatsApp and Facebook, and find people interested in foreign exchange trading.
A few hours in, she told the manager she wanted out.
“She started threatening me: ‘We will beat you if you don’t follow our rules,’” Mary said. “I told her: ‘I signed no contract. I want to leave. Release me.’”
Mary said the manager replied: “If you won’t work, pack your bags — we sell you to another company.”
Mary was locked in a room, bare except for three bed frames and two other women, also bound for a new boss, she said.
For two nights and three days, they went unfed, drinking water from a toilet in a bathroom which they were allowed to access at the whim of their guards, she said.
Guards had confiscated their phones — but Mary had a second device and was relaying events to her husband who, after reporting the situation to police in Sihanoukville, took up vigil at the compound’s gates.
“I was worried if they transfer my wife, I would not find her again,” he said.
Sihanoukville is a haven for a new breed of “sinister” Chinese gangs that take advantage of Cambodia’s fast Internet speeds and relaxed visa rules, said John Coyne, head of the Northern Australia Strategic Policy Centre, a research group.
CRIMINAL HOTSPOT
“Sihanoukville is a criminal hotspot created by the confluence of Chinese money, Chinese organized crime groups and a very poor legal environment,” said Coyne, an ex-police officer and expert on organized crime in the Mekong region.
Beijing has sent police and planes to Cambodia to take home hundreds of suspected Chinese scammers in the past few years, sending a “very heavy and very public ... message to its citizens” about the risks of engaging in crime, said a foreign law enforcement official monitoring the situation.
“The operators shifted to other targets,” the official said, adding that by trafficking more people who speak languages other than Chinese, the gangs were able to target more nationalities.
“Eight new clients per day. If you don’t get eight, you keep working,” said a Tanzanian woman who took what was advertised online as a call center job in Sihanoukville in June.
“Four hundred of us in one room — cheat, cheat, cheat. That’s the job,” she said, describing how she used fake online profiles to trap people into fraudulent investment schemes.
When the woman told management she wanted to leave, she was locked in a room with Mary and given two options: pay US$2,000 or be sold to another company, she said.
The woman shared contact numbers for her trafficker, who told the Thomson Reuters Foundation that he was paid a US$1,000 commission for each person recruited to work in Sihanoukville, but denied recruiting a Tanzanian woman.
The recruiter, who said he was Chinese and gave his name as Li Qiang, said he worked for a large firm that did not have a name, and said that his actions did not involve trafficking.
“The employee can leave whenever they want,” he said.
The police chief in Preah Sihanouk Province, where Sihanoukville is located, and a spokesman for the provincial administration, declined to comment.
‘SOLD LIKE GOATS’
Cambodia has become a popular destination for workers in tourism, construction and education, which have been hard-hit by COVID-19, leaving a pool of “invisible people” for recruiters to prey on, labor abuse investigator Khun Tharo said.
“Many have lost their jobs and they’re very easy to access, very easy to scam,” Tharo of labor non-profit Central said.
Nehan, a teacher from Nepal who has lived in Cambodia for five years and was laid off during the pandemic, said he responded to a Facebook advert for a call center job after exhausting his savings — and ended up being enslaved.
“To them, we are just animals; bought and sold like goats and chickens,” he said.
Nehan said he was taken to start work in the shuttered White Sand Palace Hotel in Sihanoukville.
“[People] think that during corona time, White Sand is closed, but what happens inside, they don’t know,” said Nehan, who was released after working for a month without pay when he threatened to get his wife to report the scammers to the police.
“People go in [to the hotel] ... then they cannot go out,” he said.
A woman who answered a phone at White Sand Palace Hotel said it was not possible to speak to management, as they had gone “to China,” adding that the hotel was not aware of any online scamming operations on the premises.
Nehan said he was taken to hotel rooms where hundreds of people — mostly Chinese — worked to coax online investors into fake investment schemes and into scanning a QR code embedded in a Web site that allows them to hack into people’s smartphones.
“They are hackers, thieves,” Nehan said.
BEATEN
All of the victims were told to pay a ransom to be freed, but only one did — a South African tourist, whose mother shared a screenshot of a July payment of US$2,047 sent to a Cambodian who negotiated her son’s release.
Six others said they used threats, negotiation and social media posts to win their release. Two are still being held.
The tourist shared photographs of himself in a hospital bed with a bruised face and a bandage around his head, which he said was stitched after he was beaten by his trafficker for trying to rally a walkout from a Chinese-run scamming operation.
“We tried not to do the money thing, but in the end we had to. These people beat him up, and it’s just been hell for one month that we’ve been trying to negotiate,” his mother said shortly after his release.
In Mary’s case, her husband shared her ordeal on Facebook after three days, when she told him she thought she had miscarried their baby.
He also gave details to local news Web site Cambodia News English, he said.
“At first [the traffickers] were angry — how was this information getting out? I had videos and photos from inside,” Mary’s husband said.
After threatening violence and demanding a US$1,500 ransom, a deal was reached: Mary would be freed if he deleted the Facebook posts, he said.
The couple agreed and are now in hiding, unable to leave Cambodia together due to COVID-19 travel restrictions in their home and neighboring countries.
“Right now, we feel only anger and fear,” Mary’s husband said. “I can’t sleep. When I close my eyes, I can only imagine our child. When my wife sleeps, she shakes.”
Additional reporting by Vinh Socheata
You wish every Taiwanese spoke English like I do. I was not born an anglophone, yet I am paid to write and speak in English. It is my working language and my primary idiom in private. I am more than bilingual: I think in English; it is my language now. Can you guess how many native English speakers I had as teachers in my entire life? Zero. I only lived in an English-speaking country, Australia, in my 30s, and it was because I was already fluent that I was able to live and pursue a career. English became my main language during adulthood
Somehow, US intelligence identified “the Houthis’ top missile guy” and pinpointed his exact location. At 1348 hours (Washington time), March 15, President Trump’s national security advisor Mike Waltz texted, “positive ID of him walking into his girlfriend’s building.” The unsuspecting Romeo entered. High above, the drone monitoring the building registered a flash. When the smoke cleared, Mr. Waltz texted, “…And it’s now collapsed.” RIP. The star-crossed “top missile guy” had been target number one in the now uproarious US Navy bombing campaign on that Sunday against the Yemeni rebels who have been holding the Red Sea hostage since October 19,
Taiwan on Monday celebrated Freedom of Speech Day. The commemoration is not an international day, and was first established in Tainan by President William Lai (賴清德) in 2012, when he was mayor of that city. The day was elevated to a national holiday in 2016 by then-president Tsai Ing-wen (蔡英文). Lai chose April 7, because it marks the anniversary of the death of democracy advocate Deng Nan-jung (鄭南榕), who started Freedom Era Weekly to promote freedom of expression. Thirty-six years ago, a warrant for Deng’s arrest had been issued after he refused to appear in court to answer charges of
The Opinion page has published several articles and editorials over the past few weeks addressing Taiwan’s efforts to leverage unique or strong aspects of its culture to increase international awareness of the nation. These have included submissions by foreign journalists and overseas students, highlighting how bubble milk tea, Guinness World Record attempts, the entertainment sectors, impressive scenery, world-class cuisine and important contributions to the high-tech supply chain can enhance Taiwan’s recognition overseas and therefore its soft power. That entails competing for attention in already crowded sectors. Other nations, after all, offer popular entertainment exports, beautiful scenic spots and great food.
RSS