Sun, May 12, 2024 page12

• They made one-of-a-kind quilts, then Target came along

  Target’s mass-produced reproductions missed out on capturing the unique social familial context of Gee’s Bend quilts, while paying the creators a flat fee rather than a rate proportionate to sales

  • By Anna Furman / AP
  • • 
    • 
    • 

  Over the past two decades, Gee’s Bend quilts have captured the public’s imagination with their kaleidoscopic colors and their daring geometric patterns. The groundbreaking art practice was cultivated by direct descendants of slaves in rural Alabama who have faced oppression, geographic isolation and intense material constraints.

  As of this year, their improvisational art has also come to embody a modern question: What happens when distinctive cultural tradition collides with corporate America?

  Enter Target Corp.

  

  A Gee’s Bend x Target display advertises products based on creations by Gee’s Bend quilters at a Target Corp store in Trumbull, Connecticut, on Feb. 10.

  Photo: Tangular Irby via AP

  The multinational retailer launched a limited-edition collection based on the quilters’ designs for the US’ Black History Month this year. Consumer appetites proved to be high as many stores around the US sold out of the checkered sweaters, water bottles and faux-quilted blankets.

  “We’re actually in a quilt revival right now, like in real time,” artist and academic Sharbreon Plummer said. “They’re so popularized, and Target knew that. It created the biggest buzz when it came out.”

  Indeed, there has been a resurgence of interest among Gen Z and millennials in conscious consumption and the homemade — with “cottagecore” style, baking bread, DIY bracelets — but both are at odds with the realities of fast fashion.

  

  From left, Gee’s Bend quilters Lucy Marie Mingo, Nancy Pettway and Arlonzia Pettway work on a quilt in the Boykin Nutrition Center in Boykin, Alabama, on April 6, 2006.

  Photo: AP

  The Target designs were “inspired by” five Gee’s Bend quilters who reaped limited financial benefits from the collection’s success. They received a flat rate for their contributions rather than pay proportionate to Target’s sales.

  A spokesperson for Target would not share sales numbers from the collection, but confirmed that it sold out in many stores.

  Unlike the pay structure of the Freedom Quilting Bee of the 1960s — an artist-run collective that disbursed payment equitably to Gee’s Bend quilters, who were salaried and could set up US Social Security benefits — one-off partnerships with companies like Target benefit only a small number of people, in this case five women from two families.

  The maxim “representation matters” is not new, but it is gaining wider traction. Still, when visibility for some does not translate into meaningful change for a marginalized community as a whole, how is that reconciled?

  ”Every stage of the finances has been problematic,” said Patricia Turner, a retired professor in World Arts and Culture and African American Studies at the University of California, Los Angeles who traced the commodification of Gee’s Bend quilts back to white collector Bill Arnett in the 1990s.

  “I’m really bothered by Target’s in-house designer manipulating the look of things to make it more palatable for their audience,” she said of the altered color palettes and patterns.

  “Each quilter had the opportunity to provide input on the items featured in our collection on multiple occasions throughout the process,” Target spokesperson Brian Harper-Tibaldo wrote in an e-mailed statement.

  While thumbnail-size photographs of the makers appeared on some marketing materials and the text “Gee’s Bend” was printed on clothing tags, the company’s engagement with the quilters was limited. As soon as Black History Month ended, the quilters’ names and images were scrubbed from the retailer’s site.

  While Target has pledged to spend more than US$2 billion on black-owned businesses by next year, it has no plans to work again with the Gee’s Bend community.

  The situation mirrors that of the 1990s, when some quilters enjoyed newfound visibility, others were disinterested and still others felt taken advantage of. (In 2007, several quilters brought a series of lawsuits against the Arnett family, but all cases were settled out of court and little is known about the suits because of nondisclosure agreements.)

  The profit-oriented approach that emerged, which disrupted the Quilting Bee’s price-sharing structure, created “real rifts and disharmony within the community” over engaging with collectors, art institutions and commercial enterprises, Turner said. “To have those bonds disrupted over the commercialization of their art form, I think, is sad.”

  By reproducing an aesthetic, but stripping it of its social fabric and familial context, Target missed capturing the essence of what makes this particular craft tradition so rich and distinct.

  Quilts are made to mark major milestones and are gifted to celebrate a new baby or a marriage, or to honor someone’s loss. Repurposing fabric — from tattered blankets, frayed rags, stained clothes — is a central ethos of the community’s quilting practice, which resists commodification.

  However, the Target collection was mass-produced from new fabrics in factories in China and elsewhere overseas.

  The older generations of Gee’s Bend quilters are known for one-of-a-kind designs with clashing colors and irregular, wavy lines — visual effects borne of their material constraints. Most worked at night in houses without electricity and did not have basic tools such as scissors, let alone access to fabric stores.

  Stella Mae Pettway, who has sold her quilts on Etsy for US$100 to US$8,000, has characterized having scissors and access to more fabrics now as a paradox of “advantage and a disadvantage.”

  Many third and fourth-generation artists returned to quilting as adults for a creative and therapeutic outlet, as well as a tether to their roots.

  After her mom died in 2010, quilter JoeAnn Pettway-West revisited the practice and found peace in completing her mother’s unfinished quilts.

  “As I’m making this stitch, I can just see her hand, stitching. It’s like, we’re there together,” she said. “It’s a little bit of her, a little bit of me.”

  Delia Pettway Thibodeaux is a third-generation Gee’s Bend quilter whose grandmother was a sharecropper and whose bold, rhythmic quilts are in the Philadelphia Museum of Art’s permanent collection.

  For the Target collection, she received a flat fee rather than a rate proportional to sales.

  “I was kind of concerned in the beginning” about how quilts would be altered to fit with the collection, Pettway Thibodeaux said. “But then again when I saw the collection, I felt different.”

  Because job opportunities are so limited in Gee’s Bend, many fourth-generation quilters have left the area to take jobs as teachers, day care workers or home health aides, or to serve in the military.

  “We, as the next generation, we was more dreamers,” Pettway-West said.

  National recognition has certainly brought some positive change, but more visibility — from museum exhibitions, academic research and a US Postal Service stamp collection — has not necessarily translated into economic gains.

  After all, the average annual income in Boykin, Alabama, is still far below the poverty rate at about US$12,000, according to the nonprofit Nest.

  “This is a community that still, to this day, really needs recognition, still needs economic revitalization,” said Lauren Cross, Gail-Oxford Associate Curator of American Decorative Arts at The Huntington Museum of Art. “And so any economic opportunities that, you know, funnel back to them, I support.”

  Target’s line in particular is disconnected from the group’s origins and handmade practice, she said.

  It is a problem that distills the challenge at hand when something handcrafted and linked to deep tradition goes national and corporate.

  “On one hand you want to preserve the stories and that sense of authenticity,” Cross said. “And on the other hand, how do you reach a broader audience?”
• Most Popular

  • 1

    Undersea cable to Penghu severed, Chinese-funded ship suspected

  • 2

    US exempts security funds for Taiwan

  • 3

    French aircraft carrier stages drills with Philippines

  • 4

    Taiwan keep WBC hopes alive with win

  • 5

    Photo shows Koo next to US general