Some of Japan’s most notable companies are feeling somewhat listless about being listed.
That might be the reason for the US$5 billion take-private offer for Taisho Pharmaceutical Co, the largest management buyout in Japanese history, announced last week.
With the founding Uehara family in control of a majority of shares, most expect the proposal to succeed even in the face of grumblings from minority shareholders, bringing to an end six decades as a public firm.
Photo: AP
Taisho might be the biggest, but is far from alone in choosing this path. Buyouts by management and controlling parties have surged this year in Japan, with the total value now set to pass ¥1 trillion (US$6.8 billion). Cram-school operator Benesse Holdings Inc and karaoke provider Shidax Corp are among firms also choosing to abandon public markets.
Expect this trend to continue: For many businesses, being public is no longer worth the hassle. For decades, a listing in Japan was easy street. Extensive cross-holdings ensured a compliant shareholder base; even if the domestic market was stagnant, the rise of China provided growth opportunities next door; and most of all, no one really expected stocks to deliver much of a return.
All that is changing. Now, everywhere management looks, there is a new annoyance. Activist investors are emboldened by recent successes and launching campaigns to bend boards to their will. The Tokyo Stock Exchange is increasingly breathing down executives’ necks, looking to nag them into compliance with the goal of boosting valuations. Who needs the hassle?
That might sum up the response of Tsuruha Holdings Inc. Despite victory against Oasis Management in the activist investor’s attempt to place directors on its board, the drugstore operator is reported to be talking to private-equity firms for a potential US$4 billion deal to take itself off the market. (Tsuruha says going private is nothing more than one option to boost shareholder value.)
The Tokyo Stock Exchange’s pressure campaign to enhance corporate returns and reduce the vast number of firms that trade below book value has been a key catalyst in the rally of Japanese stocks to new three-decade highs. A widely publicized revamp of markets last year was dismissed as a cosmetic exercise, but the bourse is now tightening the screws; next year, it plans to launch a “name and shame” list of firms that are not meeting its value goals.
Meanwhile, shareholder bases are being diversified with a gradual unwinding of cross-shareholdings. Toyota Motor Corp’s reported sale of a large chunk of its Denso Corp stake is the most high-profile example.
Combined with speculation that the Bank of Japan is nearing the end of its seven-year experiment with negative rates, and it encourages management to eye the exit.
Including other types of take-private deals, along with mergers and aquisitions and a reduction in “parent-child” listings, where the parent company and its subsidiary are both public, the number of listed companies in Tokyo is set to fall.
That is a good thing — the country has far too many listed that do not need to be.
The Prime segment of the Tokyo Stock Exchange, supposed to highlight the country’s best firms, has 1,655 constituents. That proliferation forces tracker funds to buy and sell highly illiquid stocks. About two-thirds of the country’s 4,000 or so listed firms have zero analyst coverage — heaven perhaps for value investors, but not for everyone. These little understood, albeit sometimes greatly undervalued companies drag down the broader indexes, leaving investors with the impression that Japanese stocks have little upside.
Compounding the problem is the fact that Japanese start-ups still often list too early, forcing them to focus too soon on profitability instead of growth. That is one reason the country has failed to produce a decacorn — a privately held company with a valuation that exceeds US$10 billion.
For many firms, there is little advantage to remaining public: Low rates make debt a more attractive option than dilutive share sales, while a once-lacking private equity sector has become increasingly sophisticated in the past decade, aiding businesses that need to be broken up and sold off.
When it comes to management buyouts, minority shareholders are frequently upset with the lack of a more transparent sales process — or a bidding war that could drive up valuations. Absent a well-coordinated activist campaign, these holders often have little choice but to accept what they are offered. The 55 percent premium from Taisho’s founding family might seem generous, but if a person was unfortunate enough to build their stake in 2018, they would need another 60 percent on top of that to break even.
However, that is partly explained by a particularly unique Japanese way of thinking about management’s responsibility to all stakeholders. Boards need to consider workers, suppliers and customers in their deliberations — invested parties would suffer if the firm was wound up and money returned to shareholders, as the business books would advise.
Consider the case of Culture Convenience Club Co, the operator of Japan’s equivalent of Blockbuster Video. Seeing the writing on the wall for that industry, it went private in 2011 in a ¥69.6 billion deal. It has since flourished as a unlisted firm, successfully pivoting to a line of upscale bookstores as demand for DVDs fell off. Blockbuster, of course, went under.
As pressure on boards intensifies, Tokyo is only likely to see more of them pursue this option.
The most-speculated-about of all potential deals is a long-rumored management buyout of SoftBank Group Corp by founder Masayoshi Son, who frequently complains that his company is undervalued by public markets.
Such a deal, if it ever materialized, would redefine how, and where, major firms see their future.
Gearoid Reidy is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist covering Japan and South and North Korea. He previously led the breaking news team in North Asia, and was the Tokyo deputy bureau chief.
Hon Hai Precision Industry Co (鴻海精密) yesterday said that its research institute has launched its first advanced artificial intelligence (AI) large language model (LLM) using traditional Chinese, with technology assistance from Nvidia Corp. Hon Hai, also known as Foxconn Technology Group (富士康科技集團), said the LLM, FoxBrain, is expected to improve its data analysis capabilities for smart manufacturing, and electric vehicle and smart city development. An LLM is a type of AI trained on vast amounts of text data and uses deep learning techniques, particularly neural networks, to process and generate language. They are essential for building and improving AI-powered servers. Nvidia provided assistance
STILL HOPEFUL: Delayed payment of NT$5.35 billion from an Indian server client sent its earnings plunging last year, but the firm expects a gradual pickup ahead Asustek Computer Inc (華碩), the world’s No. 5 PC vendor, yesterday reported an 87 percent slump in net profit for last year, dragged by a massive overdue payment from an Indian cloud service provider. The Indian customer has delayed payment totaling NT$5.35 billion (US$162.7 million), Asustek chief financial officer Nick Wu (吳長榮) told an online earnings conference. Asustek shipped servers to India between April and June last year. The customer told Asustek that it is launching multiple fundraising projects and expected to repay the debt in the short term, Wu said. The Indian customer accounted for less than 10 percent to Asustek’s
‘DECENT RESULTS’: The company said it is confident thanks to an improving world economy and uptakes in new wireless and AI technologies, despite US uncertainty Pegatron Corp (和碩) yesterday said it plans to build a new server manufacturing factory in the US this year to address US President Donald Trump’s new tariff policy. That would be the second server production base for Pegatron in addition to the existing facilities in Taoyuan, the iPhone assembler said. Servers are one of the new businesses Pegatron has explored in recent years to develop a more balanced product lineup. “We aim to provide our services from a location in the vicinity of our customers,” Pegatron president and chief executive officer Gary Cheng (鄭光治) told an online earnings conference yesterday. “We
LEAK SOURCE? There would be concern over the possibility of tech leaks if TSMC were to form a joint venture to operate Intel’s factories, an analyst said Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電) yesterday stayed mum after a report said that the chipmaker has pitched chip designers Nvidia Corp, Advanced Micro Devices Inc and Broadcom Inc about taking a stake in a joint venture to operate Intel Corp’s factories. Industry sources told the Central News Agency (CNA) that the possibility of TSMC proposing to operate Intel’s wafer fabs is low, as the Taiwanese chipmaker has always focused on its core business. There is also concern over possible technology leaks if TSMC were to form a joint venture to operate Intel’s factories, Concord Securities Co (康和證券) analyst Kerry Huang (黃志祺)