A US judge on Monday dismissed a blockbuster antitrust action against Facebook Inc filed last year by federal and state regulators, helping lift the value of the social media giant above US$1 trillion for the first time.
Judge James Boasberg of the US District Court of Washington dismissed the cases filed in December last year by the US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and more than 40 states, which could have rolled back Facebook’s acquisition of Instagram and messaging platform WhatsApp.
The federal lawsuit “failed to plead enough facts to plausibly establish a necessary element ... that Facebook has monopoly power in the market for personal social networking services,” Boasberg wrote in a 53-page opinion, while allowing authorities the opportunity to refile the case.
Photo: AP
In lawsuits that were consolidated in federal court, US and state officials called for the divestment of Instagram and WhatsApp, arguing that Facebook had acted to “entrench and maintain its monopoly to deny consumers the benefits of competition.”
The judge issued a separate opinion dismissing the case by the states, saying that attorneys general had waited too long to bring the case for the acquisition of Instagram in 2012 and WhatsApp in 2014.
The commission’s complaint “says almost nothing concrete on the key question of how much power Facebook actually had ... it is almost as if the agency expects the court to simply nod to the conventional wisdom that Facebook is a monopolist,” Boasberg wrote.
The commission based its case on a “vague” assertion that Facebook controlled more than 60 percent of the social networking market, but it “does not even allege what it is measuring,” he wrote.
“The market at issue here is unusual in a number of ways, including that the products therein are not sold for a price ... the court is thus unable to understand exactly what the agency’s ‘60 percent-plus’ figure is even referring to, let alone able to infer the underlying facts that might substantiate it,” he wrote.
Still, Boasberg ruled that “this defect could conceivably be overcome by re-pleading,” allowing the commission the possibility of refiling the action.
Facebook shares surged after the decision, lifting the company’s market valuation above US$1 trillion for the first time.
“We are pleased that today’s decisions recognize the defects in the government complaints filed against Facebook,” the company said in a statement. “We compete fairly every day to earn people’s time and attention, and will continue to deliver great products for the people and businesses that use our services.”
The ruling came a week after a US congressional panel advanced legislation that would lead to a sweeping overhaul of antitrust laws and give more power to regulators to break up large tech firms, specifically aiming at Facebook, Google, Amazon.com Inc and Apple Inc.
The actions come amid growing concerns on the power of major tech firms, which have increasingly dominated key economic sectors and have seen steady growth during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Critics of Facebook said that the rulings highlight the need to revise antitrust laws for the Internet age.
“This is a setback — not the end — in the FTC’s fight against dominant Big Tech monopolies like Facebook,” said Charlotte Slaiman of the consumer group Public Knowledge.
“The FTC should continue this important work, as the judge has indicated the agency can still file a new complaint if it can address these concerns. At the same time, Congress’ ongoing work to pass new laws and rules to address the power of Big Tech, as well as broader antitrust reforms, is now especially important and urgent,” Slaiman said.
DOLLAR CHALLENGE: BRICS countries’ growing share of global GDP threatens the US dollar’s dominance, which some member states seek to displace for world trade US president-elect Donald Trump on Saturday threatened 100 percent tariffs against a bloc of nine nations if they act to undermine the US dollar. His threat was directed at countries in the so-called BRICS alliance, which consists of Brazil, Russia, India, China, South Africa, Egypt, Ethiopia, Iran and the United Arab Emirates. Turkey, Azerbaijan and Malaysia have applied to become members and several other countries have expressed interest in joining. While the US dollar is by far the most-used currency in global business and has survived past challenges to its preeminence, members of the alliance and other developing nations say they are fed
LIMITED MEASURES: The proposed restrictions on Chinese chip exports are weaker than previously considered, following lobbying by major US firms, sources said US President Joe Biden’s administration is weighing additional curbs on sales of semiconductor equipment and artificial intelligence (AI) memory chips to China that would escalate the US crackdown on Beijing’s tech ambitions, but stop short of some stricter measures previously considered, said sources familiar with the matter. The restrictions could be unveiled as soon as next week, said the sources, who emphasized that the timing and contours of the rules have changed several times, and that nothing is final until they are published. The measures follow months of deliberations by US officials, negotiations with allies in Japan and the Netherlands, and
Foxconn Technology Group (富士康科技集團) yesterday said it expects any impact of new tariffs from US president-elect Donald Trump to hit the company less than its rivals, citing its global manufacturing footprint. Young Liu (劉揚偉), chairman of the contract manufacturer and key Apple Inc supplier, told reporters after a forum in Taipei that it saw the primary impact of any fresh tariffs falling on its clients because its business model is based on contract manufacturing. “Clients may decide to shift production locations, but looking at Foxconn’s global footprint, we are ahead. As a result, the impact on us is likely smaller compared to
TECH COMPETITION: The US restricted sales of two dozen types of manufacturing equipment and three software tools, and blacklisted 140 more Chinese entities US President Joe Biden’s administration unveiled new restrictions on China’s access to vital components for chips and artificial intelligence (AI), escalating a campaign to contain Beijing’s technological ambitions. The US Department of Commerce slapped additional curbs on the sale of high-bandwidth memory (HBM) and chipmaking gear, including that produced by US firms at foreign facilities. It also blacklisted 140 more Chinese entities that it accused of acting on Beijing’s behalf, although it did not name them in an initial statement. Full details on the new sanctions and Entity List additions were to be published later yesterday, a US official said. The US “will
RSS