If you think the ultimate reason the Suez Canal got blocked last week is because container ships are getting too big, get ready for the future. The next few generations of cargo vessels are going to make the Ever Given look like a bath toy.
Big enough to carry 20,124 twenty-foot equivalent units, or TEUs — the standard measure for cargo, representing a single shipping container — the Ever Given was one of the world’s largest such vessels when it was launched in 2018. The first container ship to break the 20,000-TEU mark had been at sea for less than a year.
One famed 1999 study, written at a time when the largest boats carried fewer than 8,000 TEUs, argued that it would prove impossible to build craft bigger than 18,000 TEUs.
The Ever Given, finally floating on its way again, is now distinctly in the second class of mega-freighters. There are nearly 100 ships carrying more than 20,000 TEUs on the seas or under construction, and the bigger vessels being assembled in Chinese and South Korean shipyards are mostly around the 24,000-TEU mark.
One-quarter of the capacity moved by the world’s largest container line, AP Moller-Maersk A/S, is on boats above the 17,500-TEU mark.
That is unlikely to be the end of it. Chinese shipyard Hudong-Zhonghua Shipbuilding (Group) Co (滬東中華造船) has already registered designs for a 25,000 TEU vessel, and it has become relatively commonplace to predict that 30,000 TEU monsters would be plowing the oceans before the decade is out.
Such enormous hulls might cause problems that would put the Ever Given’s mishap into the shade.
At Rotterdam, the Netherlands, the largest ships already have to arrive at high tide to ensure there is enough clearance for them to get through the channel, according to a 2019 study by Nam Kyu Park of South Korea’s Tongmyong University.
Larger vessels would soon be unable to berth at Shanghai, Busan and Hong Kong even at high tide, unless channels are dredged out further, Park wrote.
There are similar problems with infrastructure on dry land. Modern ports are astonishingly efficient at unloading, and can turn around a fully laden 20,000-TEU vessel in a couple of days.
However, the time spent waiting for a berth can cut deep into the wafer-thin economics of a container line. Longer quays might have to be built to accommodate the larger ships, as well as cranes that can reach across wider decks, larger loading yards for tens of thousands of containers, and faster rail and road terminals to take cargo to its next destination.
Current vessels are already at the limits of what can fit along major shipping lanes. The Ever Given is too bulky to squeeze through the Panama Canal, where boats must be lifted over its mountainous spine with massive lock gates.
At 24m deep, the Suez Canal has more capacity — but it is roughly as deep as the Straits of Malacca and Singapore, so dredging it further to accommodate bigger ships would not help much. The binding constraint on east-west trade at this point is not engineering, but geology.
Extending 15.7m below the water line, the Ever Given should not, on paper, have trouble making it through any of those channels, which typically require 3.5m of clearance from the bottom. Next-generation ships with a 20m draught, on the other hand, would be at constant risk of grounding.
How have container ships managed to defy expectations that their size would hit fundamental limits? A large part of it is because the economies of scale are so compelling. Bigger vessels use more fuel, but relative to the number of boxes stacked on their decks they are far more efficient.
They can also turn around a larger number of containers at a time and serve a wider array of feeder ports, ensuring they can defray their massive capital costs quicker.
There is little sign that this is about to change. New International Maritime Organization (IMO) regulations against the burning of sulfur-intensive fuel oil introduced last year mean current ships are using costlier diesel, putting more pressure on naval architects to come up with yet more efficient designs.
Beyond that, the IMO has plans to reduce carbon dioxide emissions by 40 percent in 2030 compared with 2008, and by 70 percent by 2050. Even with a switch to cheaper, less-polluting liquefied natural gas as the main fuel, that will mean further drastic improvements in efficiency, not to mention propulsion technologies that do not exist yet. To date, the best way to chip away at fuel consumption and emissions is by increasing size.
It is hard to know how the industry is going to cope with this. Perhaps Suez, Malacca and Singapore can be dredged to accommodate even bigger vessels. Perhaps shipyards would find ways to squeeze a few more inches out of existing channels.
If not, alternative routes around the Cape of Good Hope and through the deeper Straits of Sunda and Lombok between Indonesia’s islands might prove the only viable way to accommodate such massive boats.
Should that happen, those economies of scale would have to be drastically larger to make up for the longer sailing time. We have seen container ships leap from 10,000 TEUs to 24,000 TEUs. Do not be shocked to see 50,000 TEU vessels plying the sea in your lifetime.
David Fickling is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist covering commodities, as well as industrial and consumer companies. He has been a reporter for Bloomberg News, Dow Jones, the Wall Street Journal, the Financial Times and the Guardian.
This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners.
WALKING AWAY: At one point the world’s No. 3 smartphone brand, LG has fallen from a position as a market leader after a series of software and hardware mishaps South Korea’s LG Electronics Inc is to wind down its loss-making mobile division after failing to find a buyer, a move that would make it the first major smartphone brand to completely withdraw from the market. Its decision to pull out will leave its 10 percent share in North America, where it is the No. 3 brand, to be gobbled up by Samsung Electronics Co and Apple Inc with its domestic rival expected to have the edge. “In the United States, LG has targeted mid-priced — if not ultra-low — models and that means Samsung, which has more mid-priced product lines than
SPECULATION: The integrated house and land transaction income tax has been amended as the real-estate market heats up because of high liquidity and low interest rates Lawmakers across party lines yesterday agreed to July 1 as the provisional date on which a draft amendment to the Income Tax Act (所得稅法) is to come into effect, with the aim of curbing real-estate speculation. The consensus was reached following interparty negotiations at the legislature’s Finance Committee to determine when revisions to the “integrated house and land transaction income tax” would take effect. The committee on Monday last week passed a number of revisions to the act, but failed to agree on when they would take effect. Under the proposed revisions, the tax would be set at 45 percent
TAICHUNG PLANT: An official said that generator No. 3 had been retrofitted and it generates 0.46g of particulate pollution per kilowatt-hour, down from 0.6g to 0.7g A spike in demand for electricity made it necessary to restart the third coal-fired generator at the Taichung Power Plant, Taiwan Power Co (Taipower, 台電) said yesterday as a feud with the Taichung City Government lingers. Taichung Mayor Lu Shiow-yen (盧秀燕) has sought to keep the generator from being used. In 2019, he revoked Taipower’s license to operate the generator. However, the state-run utility has taken the city government to court over the license revocation and won the case in February last year, Taipower manager Chang Ting-shu (張廷抒) said. “We would like to remind the Taichung City Government that operation of the third
Several hundred people have already booked their tickets and begun training for a spectacular voyage: a few minutes, or perhaps days, in the weightlessness of space. The mainly wealthy first-time space travelers are preparing to take part in one of several private missions which are preparing to launch. The era of space tourism is on the horizon 60 years after Soviet cosmonaut Yuri Gagarin became the first person in space. Two companies, Virgin Galactic and Blue Origin LLC, are building spacecraft capable of sending private clients on suborbital flights to the edge of space lasting several minutes. Glenn King is the director of