Quanta Storage Inc (廣明光電), a subsidiary of contract laptop maker Quanta Computer Inc (廣達電腦), yesterday said it could not accept a US federal appeals court’s ruling in a price-fixing case, and would continue to appeal.
The company was shocked by the US Court of Appeals’ ruling on Friday to turn over essentially all of its assets to HP Inc to satisfy a US$439 million antitrust judgement handed down in January, Quanta Storage president Ho Shih-chih (何世池) told a news conference at the Taipei Exchange.
The ruling was ridiculous and the company would file a petition for the case to be reheard en banc (before the entire bench), Ho said.
Photo: Cho Yi-chun, Taipei Times
It would also discuss with its lawyers how to file an appeal with the US Supreme Court, he said, adding that the impact of the ruling on the company’s operations had yet to be evaluated.
A three-judge panel of the New Orleans-based Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit ruled that the Taoyuan-based firm must give all its cash, factories and patents to HP Inc — basically surrender almost all its assets — before its appellate challenge has played out because it failed to post an US$85 million bond to prevent early collection of the crippling award.
“Quanta risked bet-the-company litigation and lost, so the district court ordered it to hand over the company,” the appellate court panel said in its 21-page ruling, although it did agree to give Quanta Storage more time to comply.
2013 CASE
In 2013, HP sued Quanta Storage and several other companies for allegedly engaging in a price fixing scheme from 2004 to 2010 by rigging bids for HP’s request for optical disc drives used to store and read media and data on DVDs, CDs and Blu-ray discs.
Quanta Storage was the only defendant not to settle out of court with HP. It said it served only as a storage contractor for Sony Electronics and Royal Philips NV, which sold the products directly to HP, and therefore it was not part of the alleged conspiracy.
A Houston jury in October last year awarded HP US$176 million in damages after a price-fixing trial, tagging Quanta Storage with all of HP’s losses from the scheme.
On Jan. 3, the trial judge, US District Judge David Hittner, compounded Quanta Storage’s woes by tripling the damages to US$439 million, after subtracting settlement credits HP had already received.
Quanta Storage had argued that tripling damages would violate US constitutional prohibitions on excessive punitive damages, but Hittner ruled that antitrust law allowed for the tripling of awards as compensatory rather than punitive damages.
In April, Quanta Storage tried repeatedly to delay HP’s push to collect on the judgement.
It said that COVID-19-related travel and business restrictions in Taiwan and China, where most of its executives and factories are, prevented it from posting the bond, while complying with Taiwanese regulations on asset transfers by publicly traded companies.
It also argued that the damages had been incorrectly calculated at trial, because jurors included purchases by HP’s foreign subsidiaries, which it claimed are not covered by US antitrust protections.
HP said its economic expert excluded purchases by the foreign units, and the appeals court agreed, upholding the money judgement.
HP also said Quanta Storage was using the pandemic as a ploy to dissipate its assets that could be used to satisfy the judgement.
“It is not apparent from the record that the district court considered the amount of time it would take for Quanta to complete the asset transfer process required by Taiwanese law,” the Court of Appeals panel said.
HP said that it was pleased that the appeals panel had agreed with Hittner and the jury.
“Quanta violated US antitrust laws by conspiring to fix prices,” Alex Roberts, one of HP’s lawyers, said in an e-mail to Bloomberg. “That conduct cannot go unpunished. HP took them to task for those violations, and now we look forward to ensuring they comply promptly” with the turnover orders.
Quanta Storage, which has surrendered some assets to a court custodian, had sought more time to comply with Taiwanese regulations before turning over the keys to its Asian factories.
It also said it needs to make sure the HP judgement is enforceable under Taiwanese law before complying with an overseas court order that essentially liquidates it.
It urged the courts to respect international comity and require HP to confirm the judgement in Taiwanese courts — or risk retaliation by foreign judges who might strip US companies of the protection of US courts in overseas disputes.
The appeals panel rejected those arguments.
PATENTS: MediaTek Inc said it would not comment on ongoing legal cases, but does not expect the legal action by Huawei to affect its business operations Smartphone integrated chips designer MediaTek Inc (聯發科) on Friday said that a lawsuit filed by Chinese smartphone brand Huawei Technologies Co (華為) over alleged patent infringements would have little impact on its operations. In an announcement posted on the Taiwan Stock Exchange, MediaTek said that it would not comment on an ongoing legal case. However, the company said that Huawei’s legal action would have little impact on its operations. MediaTek’s statement came after China-based PRIP Research said on Thursday that Huawei filed a lawsuit with a Chinese district court claiming that MediaTek infringed on its patents. The infringement mentioned in the lawsuit likely involved
Taipei is today suspending work, classes and its US$2.4 trillion stock market as Typhoon Gaemi approaches Taiwan with strong winds and heavy rain. The nation is not conducting securities, currency or fixed income trading, statements from its stock and currency exchanges said. Authorities had yesterday issued a warning that the storm could affect people on land and canceled some ship crossings and domestic flights. Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電) expects its local chipmaking fabs to maintain normal production, the company said in an e-mailed statement. The main chipmaker for Apple Inc and Nvidia Corp said it has activated routine typhoon alert
GROWTH: TSMC increased its projected revenue growth for this year to more than 25 percent, citing stronger-than-expected demand for AI devices and smartphones The Taiwan Institute of Economic Research (TIER, 台灣經濟研究院) yesterday raised its forecast for Taiwan’s GDP growth this year from 3.29 percent to 3.85 percent, as exports and private investment recovered faster than it predicted three months ago. The Taipei-based think tank also expects that Taiwan would see a 8.19 percent increase in exports this year, better than the 7.55 percent it projected in April, as US technology giants spent more money on artificial intelligence (AI) infrastructure and development. “There will be more AI servers going forward, but it remains to be seen if the momentum would extend to personal computers, smartphones and
CHANGE OF FORTUNES: Concern over a pricey valuation and the risk of tighter US curbs on chip sales to China have poured cold water on TSMC’s bullish momentum Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電) shares fell the most in three months yesterday upon trading resumption, joining a global technology rout as investors dramatically soured on the promises of artificial intelligence (AI). The shares declined 5.62 percent to close at NT$924 in Taipei, dragging down the benchmark TAIEX, which fell 3.29 percent to 22,119.21 points amid a technical correction, Taiwan Stock Exchange data showed. Other chip stocks also fell, with ASE Technology Holding Co (日月光投控) plunging 9.86 percent, MediaTek Inc (聯發科) dropping 2.35 percent, Realtek Semiconductor Corp (瑞昱) falling 1.33 percent and United Microelectronics Corp (聯電) retreating 1.17 percent, while Apple