Facing abductions, censorship and financial ruin, journalists in Pakistan say they are under unprecedented pressure from authorities ahead of nationwide polls, sparking allegations the military is overseeing a “silent coup.”
Media houses describe a sustained campaign by the security establishment ahead of the July 25 election to curb their coverage.
Those who refuse to toe the line are increasingly targeted while their employers face financial blowback, sparking widespread self-censorship.
Photo: AFP
“We have never witnessed the censorship which we are facing today,” Pakistan Federal Union of Journalists president Afzal Butt said.
Pakistan is one of the most dangerous countries in the world for journalists and activists, and there have long been red lines, but the uptick in pressure is seen as brazen and extraordinary.
The nation’s largest broadcaster, Geo TV, was partially forced off air for weeks this year until it reportedly cut a deal with the military to adjust its coverage, according to local and international media.
Moreover, Dawn, the nation’s oldest newspaper, complains its sellers are being “threatened and coerced by state institutions” after an interview with former Pakistani prime minister Nawaz Sharif last month, where he suggested Pakistani militants were behind the 2008 Mumbai attacks that killed 166 people.
Such pressure on two of Pakistan’s most powerful media houses is a clear message, News correspondent Waseem Abbasi said.
“Other outlets have no chance. So basically they’re also falling in line,” he said.
Foreign envoys have also privately aired concerns, fearing for stability in the polarized country as polls approach.
“There is clearly a concerted effort to muzzle the media in Pakistan,” a diplomatic source requesting anonymity said. “This is deeply concerning.”
Much of the tension centers around the stand-off between Sharif and the powerful military, which has ruled Pakistan for about half its 70-year history.
Sharif, who at times appeared to seek a better relationship with arch-enemy India, was ousted by the Supreme Court last year following corruption charges and banned from politics for life.
He has since repeatedly accused the military of wanton political interference.
His quotes on the Mumbai attacks during an interview with Dawn journalist Cyril Almeida approached a widely acknowledged taboo in Pakistan: criticism of the armed forces’ alleged policy toward militant proxies in India and Afghanistan.
Journalists now face pressure to cease favorable coverage of Sharif and his Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N), Abbasi said.
It is hard to quantify the extent of censorship and how it might hamper voters’ ability to make informed choices between the PML-N and other parties — namely the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf, led by former cricketer Imran Khan.
The Pakistan Institute of Legislative Development and Transparency, a think tank, said the electoral process appeared “unfair.”
Journalists believe they are “facing restraints at the hands of a silent coup in place by the military and its intelligence affiliate, the ISI,” it reported.
“Elections aren’t manipulated on the day in Pakistan,” said Omar Waraich, deputy South Asia director at Amnesty International. “The question is: Do you have a level playing field before, leading up to the elections?”
For news anchor Matiullah Jan the answer is simple.
“I think the judiciary and the armed forces are doing it... Nobody might be saying it so openly, but everybody knows it,” he said, likening it to “a fixed cricket pitch.”
The military did not respond to requests for comment and has previously said it does not interfere with media coverage.
However, it has fired unsettling rhetorical warning shots.
At a televised press conference this month, spokesman Major General Asif Ghafoor showed a slide accusing named journalists and activists of working with anti-state forces — a serious charge on par with militancy.
“Here was evidence of that pressure being put on media in Pakistan given by none other than the military spokesman himself,” said Jan, one of the named journalists.
One day later, British-Pakistani columnist Gul Bukhari, a critic of the security establishment, was briefly abducted in Lahore.
Such enforced disappearances have increased in the past year. The military, widely accused of being behind them, has denied involvement.
After his interview with Sharif, a picture of Almeida meeting an Indian diplomat was leaked to broadcasters, spawning accusations he was a traitor.
Photos of a foreign correspondent covering a rally by Pashtun activists critical of the military were posted by an ultranationalist blogger who called him a “CIA asset,” sparking calls for violent reprisals.
“You know the situation in Pakistan,” said Abbasi, who was also featured in Ghafoor’s slide.
“Some people could take this as a cue or a message to go after you,” he added.
Two former Chilean ministers are among four candidates competing this weekend for the presidential nomination of the left ahead of November elections dominated by rising levels of violent crime. More than 15 million voters are eligible to choose today between former minister of labor Jeannette Jara, former minister of the interior Carolina Toha and two members of parliament, Gonzalo Winter and Jaime Mulet, to represent the left against a resurgent right. The primary is open to members of the parties within Chilean President Gabriel Boric’s ruling left-wing coalition and other voters who are not affiliated with specific parties. A recent poll by the
TENSIONS HIGH: For more than half a year, students have organized protests around the country, while the Serbian presaident said they are part of a foreign plot About 140,000 protesters rallied in Belgrade, the largest turnout over the past few months, as student-led demonstrations mount pressure on the populist government to call early elections. The rally was one of the largest in more than half a year student-led actions, which began in November last year after the roof of a train station collapsed in the northern city of Novi Sad, killing 16 people — a tragedy widely blamed on entrenched corruption. On Saturday, a sea of protesters filled Belgrade’s largest square and poured into several surrounding streets. The independent protest monitor Archive of Public Gatherings estimated the
Irish-language rap group Kneecap on Saturday gave an impassioned performance for tens of thousands of fans at the Glastonbury Festival despite criticism by British politicians and a terror charge for one of the trio. Liam Og O hAnnaidh, who performs under the stage name Mo Chara, has been charged under the UK’s Terrorism Act with supporting a proscribed organization for allegedly waving a Hezbollah flag at a concert in London in November last year. The rapper, who was charged under the anglicized version of his name, Liam O’Hanna, is on unconditional bail before a further court hearing in August. “Glastonbury,
The Vatican Museums on Thursday unveiled the last and most important of the restored Raphael Rooms, the spectacularly frescoed reception rooms of the Apostolic Palace that in some ways rival the Sistine Chapel as the peak of high Renaissance artistry. A decade-long project to clean and restore the largest of the four Raphael Rooms uncovered a novel mural painting technique that Renaissance painter and architect Raphael began, but never completed. He used oil paint directly on the wall, and arranged a grid of nails embedded in the walls to hold in place the resin surface onto which he painted. Vatican Museums officials