Behind the walls of a high-security lab, NATO’s top cyber-minds are trying to predict the evolution of conflict in an Internet-dependent world.
While they play down disaster-movie scenarios of total meltdown, experts say cyber-attacks will be part and parcel of future fighting.
Tallinn is home to a cutting-edge unit known in NATO-speak as the Cooperative Cyber Defense Center of Excellence. The city is the capital of Estonia, whose flourishing high-tech industry has earned it the label “E-Stonia.”
“Definitely from the cyber-space perspective, I think we’ve gone further than we imagined in science fiction,” said Ilmar Tamm, the Estonian colonel at its helm.
Its base is a 1905 building where military communications experts have toiled away since the days of carrier pigeons and the telegraph.
The center’s dozens of experts second-guess potential adversaries, gazing into what they dub the “fifth battlespace,” after land, sea, air and space.
“The whole myriad and complex area makes it a very difficult problem to solve, and at the same time it keeps a very convenient gray area for the bad guys,” Tamm said. “Many states have realized that this is really something that can be used as a weapon ... That we should not ignore. It will have a future impact.”
“I’m not so naive that I’d say conventional warfare will go away, but we should expect it to be more combined,” he said.
Bitter experience taught Estonia — one of the world’s most wired places and a NATO member since 2004 — all about cyber-conflict.
The minnow country of 1.3 million people suffered blistering attacks in 2007 that took down business and government Web-based services for days.
“It clearly heralded the beginning of a new era,” Estonian Defense Minister Jaak Aaviksoo said. “It had all the characteristics of cyber-crime growing into a national security threat. It was a qualitative change, and that clicked in very many heads.”
The assault came as Estonian authorities controversially shifted a Soviet-era war memorial from central Tallinn to a military cemetery.
The monument, erected when Moscow took over after World War II, following independence in 1991 became a flashpoint for disputes about the past with Estonia’s ethnic-Russian minority.
Tallinn was rocked by riots as the memorial was moved. Estonia blamed Russia for stoking the strife, and also said the cyber-offensive had been traced to official servers in Moscow.
Russia, whose relations with Estonia are rocky, denied involvement.
For Aaviksoo, cyber-attacks may “present a stand-alone security threat or a combined security threat.”
An example of the latter, he said, came during Russia’s 2008 war with ex-Soviet Georgia, as hackers hit Georgian Web sites while Moscow’s troops moved in.
SUPPORT: Elon Musk’s backing for the far-right AfD is also an implicit rebuke of center-right Christian Democratic Union leader Friedrich Merz, who is leading polls German Chancellor Olaf Scholz took a swipe at Elon Musk over his political judgement, escalating a spat between the German government and the world’s richest person. Scholz, speaking to reporters in Berlin on Friday, was asked about a post Musk made on his X platform earlier the same day asserting that only the far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) party “can save Germany.” “We have freedom of speech, and that also applies to multi-billionaires,” Scholz said alongside Estonian Prime Minister Kristen Michal. “But freedom of speech also means that you can say things that are not right and do not contain
FREEDOM NO MORE: Today, protests in Macau are just a memory after Beijing launched measures over the past few years that chilled free speech A decade ago, the elegant cobblestone streets of Macau’s Tap Seac Square were jam-packed with people clamouring for change and government accountability — the high-water mark for the former Portuguese colony’s political awakening. Now as Macau prepares to mark the 25th anniversary of its handover to China tomorrow, the territory’s democracy movement is all but over and the protests of 2014 no more than a memory. “Macau’s civil society is relatively docile and obedient, that’s the truth,” said Au Kam-san (歐錦新), 67, a schoolteacher who became one of Macau’s longest-serving pro-democracy legislators. “But if that were totally true, we wouldn’t
Two US Navy pilots were shot down yesterday over the Red Sea in an apparent “friendly fire” incident, the US military said, marking the most serious incident to threaten troops in over a year of US targeting Yemen’s Houthi rebels. Both pilots were recovered alive after ejecting from their stricken aircraft, with one sustaining minor injuries. However, the shootdown underlines just how dangerous the Red Sea corridor has become over the ongoing attacks on shipping by the Iranian-backed Houthis despite US and European military coalitions patrolling the area. The US military had conducted airstrikes targeting Yemen’s Houthi rebels at the
MILITANTS TARGETED: The US said its forces had killed an IS leader in Deir Ezzor, as it increased its activities in the region following al-Assad’s overthrow Washington is scrapping a long-standing reward for the arrest of Syria’s new leader, a senior US diplomat said on Friday following “positive messages” from a first meeting that included a promise to fight terrorism. Barbara Leaf, Washington’s top diplomat for the Middle East, made the comments after her meeting with Ahmed al-Sharaa in Damascus — the first formal mission to Syria’s capital by US diplomats since the early days of Syria’s civil war. The lightning offensive that toppled former Syrian president Bashar al-Assad on Dec. 8 was led by the Muslim Hayat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS), which is rooted in al-Qaeda’s
RSS