Declaring “it’s a matter of survival,” one of the world’s tiniest nations, speaking for imperiled islands everywhere, took on global industrial and oil powers at the UN climate conference — and lost.
“Madame President, the world is watching us. The time for procrastination is over,” Ian Fry, delegate of the mid-Pacific state of Tuvalu, declared on Wednesday as he asked the full conference for more aggressive curbing of greenhouse gas emissions than is being considered.
The rejection illustrates the rich-poor divide that overshadows the conference, a reality that has already led some islands to consider evacuation should international action on climate fall short.
Specifically, Tuvalu asked to amend the 1992 UN climate treaty to require sharp reductions in greenhouse gas emissions, deeper than major powers are considering.
The amendment would have obliged the world’s nations to keep global warming — the rise in temperatures accompanied by rising seas — to 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels. That’s just 0.75°C higher than the increase to this point. Rich countries are aiming for emissions cuts that would limit warming to 2°C.
It would also have made controls on fossil-fuel use legally binding for the US and for China, India and other developing nations that until now have not faced such obligations.
Tuvalu’s gambit, seconded by Grenada, the Solomons and other island states one by one on the floor of the cavernous Bella Center, quickly ran into stiff opposition from oil giant Saudi Arabia, which would be hurt by sharp rollbacks in fuel use, and from China and India. The US delegation remained silent.
Connie Hedegaard, Danish president of the conference, said her decision on the motion would be “very difficult and yet also very easy,” since action to advance the proposal would have required consensus approval. She refused to refer it to a “contact group,” the next step in the process.
“This is a moral issue,” Fry said. “It should not be put off any longer.”
Later on Wednesday, hundreds of young international climate activists, chanting “Tuvalu! Tuvalu!” and “Listen to the islands!” thronged the conference hall entrance as the Americans and other delegates filed in for an afternoon session.
The dramatic showdown over basic issues came in the third day of the two-week conference, widely expected to produce no better than a political agreement on emissions reductions — obligatory for industrial nations, voluntary for China and other emerging economies — to be formalized in a treaty next year.
Those reductions would replace the quotas set for 37 industrialized nations by the 1997 Kyoto Protocol, which expire in 2012. The US rejected the Kyoto pact.
The Copenhagen conference’s finale comes late next week when US President Barack Obama and more than 100 other national leaders converge on the Danish capital for the final hours of what may be tense, down-to-the-wire talks.
The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, a UN-sponsored scientific network, said seas were rising by about 3mm per year. Its worst-case scenario sees the oceans rising by at least 60cm by 2100, from heat expansion and runoff of melted land ice. British scientists note that current emissions are matching the IPCC’s worst case.
Such sea-level rises particularly threaten nations on low-lying atolls, like Tuvalu and Kiribati in the Pacific, and the Maldives in the Indian Ocean.
“Sixty centimeters can make a really, really big difference in a place like Kiribati,” Australian coastal management expert Robert Kay said on Wednesday in a presentation on the sidelines of the Copenhagen conference.
Kay displayed time-lapse projections of how the ocean will eat away at narrow — sometimes 200m wide — islands like Tarawa in Kiribati.
It has already begun in Kiribati, where islanders are struggling to save roads, houses and public buildings from increasingly threatening “king tides” every two weeks. Their wells have begun turning brackish with seawater. One village has been abandoned in waist-high water, Kiribati’s delegation chief Betarim Rimon said.
Besides seawalls and other immediate measures, he said, the island nation’s leaders have a “midterm” plan to concentrate their population of 110,000 on three islands that would be built up higher with international aid. People now live on 32 atolls spread over 5.17 million square kilometers of ocean.
“Nobody in this room would want to leave their homeland,” Kiribati’s foreign secretary, Tessie Lambourne, told the side event. “It is our spiritual connection to our ancestors. We do not want to leave our homeland.”
But “if we must go, we don’t want to go as environmental refugees,” Lambourne said, referring to a long-term plan to get Kiribati residents trained to emigrate as skilled workers.
With Australian aid, 40 i-Kiribati, as they are called, are being educated as nurses each year in Australia.
Similarly, the leaders of Tuvalu, a nation of 10,000, are looking to the future, seeking permission to resettle Tuvaluans in Australia.
Greenpeace was among the environmental organizations protesting Wednesday’s rebuff of the Tuvalu bid for a more ambitious emissions-reduction plan.
Scientists said carbon dioxide emissions already “in the pipeline” — slowly warming the atmosphere — guaranteed that low-lying islands and coasts, such as Bangladesh’s, will face inundation from tides and increasingly powerful storms.
Rising seas threaten shorelines everywhere but, islanders point out, the governments responsible for such endangered areas as Lower Manhattan island and Shanghai have the money and resources to protect them against the worst of global warming.
Turning heads as they cruise past office buildings and malls, driverless taxis are slowly spreading through Chinese cities, prompting both wariness and wonder. China’s tech companies and vehicle manufacturers have poured billions of dollars into self-driving technology over the past few years in an effort to catch industry leaders in the US. Now the central city of Wuhan boasts one of the world’s largest networks of self-driving cars, home to a fleet of more than 500 taxis that can be hailed on an app just like regular rides. At one intersection in an industrial area of Wuhan, AFP reporters saw at least five
China and Vietnam yesterday inked 14 documents spanning cross-border railways to crocodile exports after Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) met with new Vietnamese leader To Lam in Beijing. The Vietnamese president’s visit to Beijing, his first overseas trip since becoming the general secretary of the Communist Party of Vietnam earlier this month, signals a desire between the two communist neighbors to strengthen ties, amid growing trade and investment, despite occasional clashes over boundaries in the South China Sea. “China has always regarded Vietnam as a priority in its neighborhood diplomacy, and supports Vietnam in adhering to the party leadership, taking the socialist
A former Saudi Arabian official alleged in a report that the kingdom’s Crown Prince Mohammad bin Salman forged the signature of his father on the royal decree that launched the kingdom’s years-long, stalemated war against Yemen’s Houthi rebels. Saudi Arabia did not immediately respond to a request for comment over the allegations made without supporting evidence by Saad al-Jabri in an interview published yesterday by the BBC, but the kingdom has described him as “a discredited former government official.” Al-Jabri, a former Saudi Arabian intelligence official who lives in exile in Canada, has been a years-long dispute with the kingdom as
‘ENOUGH IS ENOUGH’: Hospitals said faculty staff from medical colleges were assisting with emergency cases as more than 1 million doctors were expected to strike Hospitals and clinics across India yesterday turned away patients except for emergency cases as medical professionals began a 24-hour shutdown in protest against the brutal rape and murder of a doctor in the eastern city of Kolkata. More than 1 million doctors were expected to join the strike, paralyzing medical services across the world’s most populous nation. Hospitals said faculty staff from medical colleges had been pressed into service for emergency cases. The strike, which began at 6am, cut off access to elective medical procedures and out-patient consultations, the Indian Medical Association said in a statement. The discovery of the 31-year-old doctor’s bloodied