Sun, Jun 21, 2009 page5

• Mistakes ‘likely’ in Afghan deaths

  LACK OF GUIDANCE: A military probe recommended that tactics and combat rules in the Afghan war be revised to avoid civilian casualties, but did not call for prosecution

  • AFP
  • • 
    • 
    • 

  A failure by US forces to follow procedures in air strikes last month in Afghanistan “likely” caused the death of at least 26 civilians, the US military said.

  An internal investigation of a May 4 battle with Taliban insurgents in western Afghanistan found US air crews and ground troops acted in line with the laws of armed conflict, but three air strikes by a B-1 bomber failed to adhere to US combat rules and orders.

  “Not applying all of that guidance likely resulted in civilian casualties,” said a summary of the military probe released on Friday.

  The report recommended tactics and combat rules in the Afghan war be revised to avoid civilian casualties, but did not call for prosecution of any US military personnel.

  The investigation found that 78 Taliban fighters were killed and 26 civilians died in the incident, but said it was possible that a higher number of civilians were killed.

  The Kabul government has put the civilian toll at 140.

  The incident has fueled public anger at the NATO-led coalition and prompted Afghan President Hamid Karzai to demand a halt in air strikes.

  US and NATO officials have grown increasingly concerned about the effect of civilian casualties on the war effort, as insurgents have sought to exploit the incidents to sow distrust of foreign troops. The report, issued by US Central Command, described an intense battle over several hours with Afghan security forces calling for assistance from a team of US Marines near the village of Gerani in Farah Province.

  The Marines had tried to persuade Afghan authorities to hold off on moving against about 300 Taliban that had threatened local villagers, suggesting more time was needed to fully plan an operation, it said.

  But the Afghan security forces went ahead and soon had to call the Marines for assistance.

  Scrambling to rescue Afghan forces pinned down by insurgent gunfire and secure the evacuation of wounded soldiers, the Marines called in air power. A first wave of strikes by F/A-18 fighter jets hit intended targets apparently without causing civilian casualties, the report said. After nightfall, a B-1 Lancer bomber was called in to relieve the F/A-18s and carried out three strikes using 500lb (226kg) and 2,000lb bombs.

  In two of the three raids, the bombing likely caused civilian deaths, the report said.

  In both cases, air crews and the ground commander believed they were targeting insurgent forces in buildings based on intelligence reports, even though the groups of adults they targeted in the darkness had not fired on them.

  Neither the ground force commander or the bomber crew “could confirm the presence or absence of civilians already in the building,” the report said.

  In the third strike, the crew of the bomber and ground commander spotted a group of adults that they suspected were Taliban forces “moving rapidly in the dark across difficult terrain in an evenly-spaced formation.”

  The ground commander ordered the B-1 bomber to hit a building where he believed the insurgents had moved. The aircraft then dropped a 2,000lb bomb on the target.

  “The inability to discern the presence of civilians and assess the potential collateral damage of those strikes is inconsistent with the US government’s objective of providing security and safety for the Afghan people,” the report said.
• Most Popular

  • 1

    LA Dodgers beat Braves to secure 7th straight win

  • 2

    Memes, social media disinformation fuel support for Burkina junta leader

  • 3

    CIA releases two Mandarin-language videos inviting officials to spill secrets

  • 4

    Notes from Central Taiwan: Taiwan’s health system is going to erode, not collapse

  • 5

    MAC flags CCP-linked essay contest