In a continuing effort to force a documentary group to turn over hundreds of videotapes created during the 2004 National Republican Convention in New York, city lawyers recently advanced an unexpected argument: The group, I-Witness Video, may have copies of tapes possibly lost by the district attorney’s office.
The suggestion that evidence could be missing was strongly disputed by a senior official in the district attorney’s office.
In a statement drafted to explain why they want a federal magistrate to order I-Witness to turn over the material, the lawyers referred to tapes — some created by the police — presented as evidence by the Manhattan district attorney’s office during criminal trials stemming from the convention, and then shared by defense lawyers with I-Witness.
A lawyer for the city wrote that it appears that the district attorney’s office “has misplaced or lost many of those tapes.”
A footnote elaborated, saying that “despite our best efforts” the city does not have a complete record of the videotapes used by the district attorney’s office.
Such statements would seem to cast the district attorney’s office in an unenviable light. Few prosecutors would relish the idea that they might have lost track of videotapes.
Daniel Castleman, the chief assistant district attorney, said emphatically on Friday afternoon that those things did not happen.
“I don’t know on what basis they would make those assertions,” Castleman said.
The district attorney’s office has given the city more than 200 videotapes, Castleman said.
He said that he was aware of only one file that could not be found and knew of only one videotape that was edited to remove scenes.
That incident was discovered in 2005 during the trial of a man named Alexander Dunlop, who was accused of ramming a bicycle into police officers and resisting arrest.
An I-Witness member, Eileen Clancy, proved that a police videotape had been altered to remove sections showing Dunlop’s pre-arrest behavior, which did not include the violence a police officer had described under oath.
After Clancy found an unedited videotape that showed Dunlop strolling calmly and then being arrested without a struggle, the district attorney’s office dropped the case against him.
I-Witness Video, a group of archivists and civil liberties advocates, had arranged before the convention to share videotapes of demonstrations and arrests with lawyers representing people arrested during protests.
City lawyers have issued a subpoena to I-Witness and said that they need access to tapes collected by the group because they are vital to a defense against about 600 claims filed in federal court by people who said that they were unjustly arrested and detained during the convention.
Lawyers for I-Witness, which is not part of any lawsuits against the city, have asked a judge to quash the subpoena and said that that the city already had access to hundreds of videotapes showing demonstrations, including many from the police and the district attorney’s office.
BLOODSHED: North Koreans take extreme measures to avoid being taken prisoner and sometimes execute their own forces, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy said Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy on Saturday said that Russian and North Korean forces sustained heavy losses in fighting in Russia’s southern Kursk region. Ukrainian and Western assessments say that about 11,000 North Korean troops are deployed in the Kursk region, where Ukrainian forces occupy swathes of territory after staging a mass cross-border incursion in August last year. In his nightly video address, Zelenskiy quoted a report from Ukrainian Commander-in-Chief Oleksandr Syrskyi as saying that the battles had taken place near the village of Makhnovka, not far from the Ukrainian border. “In battles yesterday and today near just one village, Makhnovka,
US Secretary of the Treasury Janet Yellen on Monday met virtually with Chinese Vice Premier He Lifeng (何立峰) and raised concerns about “malicious cyber activity” carried out by Chinese state-sponsored actors, the US Department of the Treasury said in a statement. The department last month reported that an unspecified number of its computers had been compromised by Chinese hackers in what it called a “major incident” following a breach at contractor BeyondTrust, which provides cybersecurity services. US Congressional aides said no date had been set yet for a requested briefing on the breach, the latest in a serious of cyberattacks
In the East Room of the White House on a particularly frigid Saturday afternoon, US President Joe Biden bestowed the Presidential Medal of Freedom to 19 of the most famous names in politics, sports, entertainment, civil rights, LGBTQ+ advocacy and science. Former US secretary of state Hillary Rodham Clinton aroused a standing ovation from the crowd as she received her medal. Clinton was accompanied to the event by her husband, former US president Bill Clinton, daughter, Chelsea Clinton, and grandchildren. Democratic philanthropist George Soros and actor-director Denzel Washington were also awarded the nation’s highest civilian honor in a White House
Venezuelan opposition candidate Edmundo Gonzalez Urrutia was expected to meet Argentine President Javier Milei yesterday on a regional tour to drum up support ahead of Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro’s swearing-in for a third term. Venezuelan authorities have offered a reward of US$100,000 for information leading to the capture of Gonzalez Urrutia, who insists he beat Maduro at the polls in July last year and is recognized by the US as Venezuela’s “president-elect.” The 75-year-old fled to Spain in September after being threatened with arrest by Maduro’s government, but has pledged to return to his country to be sworn in as
RSS