A judge is trying to bankrupt a former reporter with daily fines as much as US$5,000 for refusing to disclose her sources for stories about the 2001 anthrax attacks, press advocates said on Saturday.
They also said the case involving Toni Locy shows why Congress should pass a federal shield law for reporters.
US District Judge Reggie Walton denied on Friday a request from Locy to stay payment of fines for a contempt citation pending an appeal and ruled she must "personally bear the responsibility of paying the fine the court imposed."
While at USA Today, Locy wrote about a former Army scientist, Steven Hatfill, whom the Justice Department identified in 2002 as a "person of interest" in the anthrax attacks.
They killed five and sickened 17 others weeks after the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001.
Hatfill has denied any involvement in the anthrax attacks and sued the government for violating his privacy by discussing the investigation with reporters. No one was charged in the attacks.
Lucy Dalglish, executive director of the Reporters Committee for the Freedom of the Press, said Walton appears to be trying to bankrupt Locy, a former Associated Press reporter who is now a professor at West Virginia University's journalism school.
"What he's doing is essentially saying, `Toni Locy I am going to destroy your life.'" she said. "This is just plain crazy. I know you're not supposed to call a federal judge arrogant, but this is arrogant."
The judge pointed to statements Hatfill's lawyers made in court papers in explaining his rationale. Hatfill's legal team said that while Locy's reporting was conducted "within the scope of her employment for USA Today, her contempt was not. It began long after she left the employment of USA Today."
Starting at midnight tomorrow, Locy was ordered to pay fines of US$500 a day for the first week, US$1,000 a day for the second week and US$5,000 subsequently.
In his opinion, Walton frequently cited the case of a former nuclear weapons scientist, Lee Wen-ho (
In 2004, US District Judge Thomas Penfield Jackson fined five reporters US$500 a day each for refusing to identify their sources for stories about Lee.
After Jackson postponed the fines pending appeals, news organizations, including the AP, eventually agreed to pay Lee US$750,000 as part of a US$1.6 million settlement of his privacy suit against the government.
Dalglish said forcing reporters to reveal sources in the face of monetary fines is in some ways more chilling than threats of jail, which come about in contempt orders issued in criminal cases. Dalglish and others are also worried about the government using civil cases to force reporters to reveal sources.
"There's not a national security interest at peril in this case," she said. "This is all about reporters being able to do what they do every day."
Congress is considering passage of a federal shield law that would protect reporters from revealing their sources. Such laws are in place in 33 states. A bill passed the House of Representatives but has stalled in the Senate since last year.
STEPPING UP: Diminished US polar science presence mean opportunities for the UK and other countries, although China or Russia might also fill that gap, a researcher said The UK’s flagship polar research vessel is to head to Antarctica next week to help advance dozens of climate change-linked science projects, as Western nations spearhead studies there while the US withdraws. The RRS Sir David Attenborough, a state-of-the-art ship named after the renowned British naturalist, would aid research on everything from “hunting underwater tsunamis” to tracking glacier melt and whale populations. Operated by the British Antarctic Survey (BAS), the country’s polar research institute, the 15,000-tonne icebreaker — boasting a helipad, and various laboratories and gadgetry — is pivotal to the UK’s efforts to assess climate change’s impact there. “The saying goes
Floods on Sunday trapped people in vehicles and homes in Spain as torrential rain drenched the northeastern Catalonia region, a day after downpours unleashed travel chaos on the Mediterranean island of Ibiza. Local media shared videos of roaring torrents of brown water tearing through streets and submerging vehicles. National weather agency AEMET decreed the highest red alert in the province of Tarragona, warning of 180mm of rain in 12 hours in the Ebro River delta. Catalan fire service spokesman Oriol Corbella told reporters people had been caught by surprise, with people trapped “inside vehicles, in buildings, on ground floors.” Santa Barbara Mayor Josep Lluis
Police in China detained dozens of pastors of one of its largest underground churches over the weekend, a church spokesperson and relatives said, in the biggest crackdown on Christians since 2018. The detentions, which come amid renewed China-US tensions after Beijing dramatically expanded rare earth export controls last week, drew condemnation from US Secretary of State Marco Rubio, who on Sunday called for the immediate release of the pastors. Pastor Jin Mingri (金明日), founder of Zion Church, an unofficial “house church” not sanctioned by the Chinese government, was detained at his home in the southern city of Beihai on Friday evening, said
SANCTIONS: Congolese Minister of Foreign Affairs Therese Kayikwamba Wagner called on the EU to tighten sanctions against Rwanda during an event in Brussels The Democratic Republic of the Congo (DR Congo) has accused the EU of “an obvious double standard” for maintaining a minerals deal with Rwanda to supply Europe’s high-tech industries when it deployed a far-wider sanctions regime in response to the war in Ukraine. Congolese Minister of Foreign Affairs Therese Kayikwamba Wagner urged the EU to levy much stronger sanctions against Rwanda, which has fueled the conflict in the eastern DR Congo, describing the bloc’s response to breaches of the DR Congo’s territory as “very timid.” Referencing the EU’s response to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, she said: “It is an obvious double standard
RSS