The Israeli armed forces, which took the rap in the final report on the failures of the 2006 Lebanon War, need to make big changes ahead of any new conflict, analysts said on Friday.
The Winograd Commission report, published on Wednesday, delivered an unprecedented verdict on the army, saying that daring, determination and initiative were all lacking in its war against the Lebanese Hezbollah.
Since the 34-day war ended in a UN-brokered ceasefire on Aug. 14, 2006, several steps have already been taken to correct perceived military failings.
On a strategic level, the idea that air power alone can vanquish an adversary has been abandoned.
And tactically, the military has greatly boosted inter-service operations and training, which has suffered in recent years because of the focus on the Palestinian intifada.
But military experts -- and the Winograd Commission itself -- said the causes for the state of the Israeli armed forces run deep.
For military historian Martin Van Creveld, it boils down to the fact that "an army that fights against weaker forces itself becomes weaker."
Battling armed Palestinian groups, over whom the Israeli military has overwhelming superiority, requires "prudence, patience and ensuring minimum losses," he said.
But in a full-scale war, "daring is vital, timing is of the essence and losses become secondary" to winning the conflict.
Reservist Colonel Omer Bar-Lev believes the "crisis in the Israeli military's values emanates from society as a whole.
"Israel has become a society of abundance for some and one of poverty for others. When financial success and individualism are the motivating factors, people are no longer willing to sacrifice" these goals, said the former head of the top-secret Sayeret Matkal commando unit.
Bar-Lev attributed a less combative spirit to profound divisions within society following the occupation of Palestinian territory more than 40 years ago in the 1967 Middle East war.
"Nobody wants to die for Hebron or Nablus just so these [West Bank] cities can remain under the power of Israel," he said.
Analyst Ran Edelist said it would seem that Israelis are no longer willing to pay with their own lives to conquer such and such a place in south Lebanon, since they know they would merely pull out again a few days later.
In 2006, "reservists sent into Lebanon did not feel as if they were defending the very existence of Israel and were not willing to sacrifice themselves," he said.
The Winograd report itself said: "An army must aspire to victory and if it turns out from the beginning that such a victory is unattainable it is better to avoid a war."
The government-appointed commission, headed by retired judge Eliyahu Winograd, also blamed failures by the military on "altered values, as well as profound changes within Israeli society, part of which is no longer prepared to accept lengthy wars and their cost in human lives."
But the report underlined that the military should not expect society to change before it corrects its own failings and called for an end to complacency within the armed forces.
SUPPORT: Elon Musk’s backing for the far-right AfD is also an implicit rebuke of center-right Christian Democratic Union leader Friedrich Merz, who is leading polls German Chancellor Olaf Scholz took a swipe at Elon Musk over his political judgement, escalating a spat between the German government and the world’s richest person. Scholz, speaking to reporters in Berlin on Friday, was asked about a post Musk made on his X platform earlier the same day asserting that only the far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) party “can save Germany.” “We have freedom of speech, and that also applies to multi-billionaires,” Scholz said alongside Estonian Prime Minister Kristen Michal. “But freedom of speech also means that you can say things that are not right and do not contain
Two US Navy pilots were shot down yesterday over the Red Sea in an apparent “friendly fire” incident, the US military said, marking the most serious incident to threaten troops in over a year of US targeting Yemen’s Houthi rebels. Both pilots were recovered alive after ejecting from their stricken aircraft, with one sustaining minor injuries. However, the shootdown underlines just how dangerous the Red Sea corridor has become over the ongoing attacks on shipping by the Iranian-backed Houthis despite US and European military coalitions patrolling the area. The US military had conducted airstrikes targeting Yemen’s Houthi rebels at the
Pulled from the mud as an infant after the devastating Indian Ocean tsunami in 2004 and reunited with his parents following an emotional court battle, the boy once known as “Baby 81” is now a 20-year-old dreaming of higher education. Jayarasa Abilash’s story symbolized that of the families torn apart by one of the worst natural calamities in modern history, but it also offered hope. More than 35,000 people in Sri Lanka were killed, with others missing. The two-month-old was washed away by the tsunami in eastern Sri Lanka and found some distance from home by rescuers. At the hospital, he was
MILITANTS TARGETED: The US said its forces had killed an IS leader in Deir Ezzor, as it increased its activities in the region following al-Assad’s overthrow Washington is scrapping a long-standing reward for the arrest of Syria’s new leader, a senior US diplomat said on Friday following “positive messages” from a first meeting that included a promise to fight terrorism. Barbara Leaf, Washington’s top diplomat for the Middle East, made the comments after her meeting with Ahmed al-Sharaa in Damascus — the first formal mission to Syria’s capital by US diplomats since the early days of Syria’s civil war. The lightning offensive that toppled former Syrian president Bashar al-Assad on Dec. 8 was led by the Muslim Hayat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS), which is rooted in al-Qaeda’s