Western aid agencies "brushed aside" the work of local community groups in a rush to spend the record-breaking donations raised after the Indian Ocean tsunami, according to a report published on Friday.
A failure to consult local people meant a quarter of the fishing boats that were donated were unseaworthy, while some aid money was wasted on the construction of sweltering corrugated-metal houses in the tropical jungle.
The tsunami was the world's biggest natural disaster in 40 years and prompted a huge public response, but humanitarian agencies felt under pressure to produce results quickly because of the unprecedented generosity, the report by the Tsunami Evaluation Coalition found.
The TEC, a group of UN bodies and aid agencies reviewing the response to the tragedy, said the donations amounted to the biggest ever international response to a disaster; at least US$13.5 billion was pledged or donated, 41 percent of it from private sources. It was also the fastest response ever recorded, partly because of increased use of the Internet.
But it was the relatives and neighbors of those affected who were first to respond, and their efforts were often ignored, the study said. John Cosgrave, one of the report's authors, said: "Because there was no consultation with local people, the fishing boats were in some cases too narrow or unstable. I think the UN Food and Agriculture Organization estimated that at least a quarter of them were unseaworthy."
Aid agencies failed to consult partly because of the scale of the crisis -- which killed 227,000 people in 14 countries around the Indian Ocean -- and partly because armed conflicts prevented proper access. Cosgrave said the worst damage was in Aceh, which was closed to international agencies because of the civil war.
"There were people in Sri Lanka who knew the country, but they were swamped by all of the emergency people who came in," he added.
Examples of inappropriate aid also included corrugated metal homes built in the Thai jungle.
The report praised the public's generosity but said it also showed up how little was given to less-advertised tragedies such as the floods in Bangladesh in 2004, which affected 36 million people. Among the factors in the west's response may have been the time of the disaster, just after Christmas, and the fact that popular holiday destinations for Western tourists were involved.
Thousands of well-intentioned people rushed to the region in the aftermath to try to help, but Cosgrave said such hands-on assistance often ended up doing more harm than good: "Like anything else, the more experience you have, the harder it is for you to make basic mistakes."
"What was positive was the relief phase, which went quite well. There were no large-scale deaths and people were able to restart their lives quite quickly," he said. "People who gave money can be happy that it helped people and is continuing to help people."
Malaysia yesterday installed a motorcycle-riding billionaire sultan as its new king in lavish ceremonies for a post seen as a ballast in times of political crises. The coronation ceremony for Malaysia’s King Sultan Ibrahim, 65, at the National Palace in Kuala Lumpur followed his oath-taking in January as the country’s 17th monarch. Malaysia is a constitutional monarchy, with a unique arrangement that sees the throne change hands every five years between the rulers of nine Malaysian states headed by centuries-old Islamic royalty. While chiefly ceremonial, the position of king has in the past few years played an increasingly important role. Royal intervention was
Hong Kong microbiologist Yuen Kwok-yung (袁國勇) has done battle with some of the world’s worst threats, including the SARS virus he helped isolate and identify, and he has a warning. Another pandemic is inevitable and could exact damage far worse than COVID-19 pandemic, said the soft-spoken scientist sometimes thought of as Hong Kong’s answer to former US National Institutes of Health director Anthony Fauci. “Both the public and [world] leaders must admit that another pandemic will come, and probably sooner than you anticipate,” he said at the city’s Queen Mary Hospital, where he works and teaches. “Why I make such a horrifying prediction
A high-ranking North Korean diplomat stationed in Cuba defected to South Korea in November last year — just months before Seoul and Havana established diplomatic ties, the South Korean National Intelligence Service said yesterday. North Korean diplomat Ri Il-kyu had been responsible for political affairs at Pyongyang’s embassy in Cuba since 2019, tasked specifically “with obstructing the establishment of diplomatic relations between South Korea and Cuba,” South Korea’s Chosun Daily reported. Ri defected to South Korea with his wife and children in early November, making him the highest-ranking North Korean diplomat known to have defected since then-North Korean deputy ambassador to the
INDICTED: US prosecutors said Sue Mi Terry accepted fancy handbags, luxury dinners and thousands of dollars in payments from South Korean intelligence A former CIA employee and senior official at the US National Security Council has been charged with allegedly serving as a secret agent for the South Korean National Intelligence Service, the US Department of Justice said. Sue Mi Terry accepted luxury goods, including fancy handbags, and expensive dinners at sushi restaurants in exchange for advocating South Korean government positions during media appearances, sharing nonpublic information with intelligence officers and facilitating access for South Korean officials to US government officials, an indictment filed in federal court in Manhattan, New York, says. She also admitted to the FBI that she served as a source