Canada denied refugee status Thursday to a US paratrooper who walked out on the 82nd Airborne Division to dodge combat in Iraq, in a decision that will dismay scores of other US deserters.
Jeremy Hinzman, 26, had filed for refugee protection arguing he would face persecution over his political beliefs or cruel or unusual punishment if returned to the US.
But Canada's Immigration and Refugee Board (IRB) found that Hinzman, his Laotian-born wife and young son would benefit from fair and independent justice in the US.
Hinzman, a veteran of the Afghan war, denied conscientious objector status in the US, will now take his battle to stay in Canada to federal court.
"I am not going to kill people just so the US can build a big gas station in the Middle East," Hinzman said, hours after the verdict was handed down. "When you are faced with committing evil acts, you have no other choice but to act and that is what I did by coming here."
Should Hinzman's court appeal founder, his last resort would be a plea to Canada's immigration minister for leave to stay on compassionate grounds.
The South Dakota-born soldier argued in a three-day tribunal here in December that he was within his rights to leave his unit because he viewed the war in Iraq as illegal and could be asked to commit atrocities.
But the IRB had already ruled that it would not consider the legality of the Iraq War in coming to its determination in the case.
"We don't believe that people should be imprisoned if what they're asked to do is illegal," Hinzman's lawyer, Jeffry House argued Thursday, adding that the legality of the war would be questioned in the appeal.
The case was seen as a barometer for seven other US soldiers who have also applied for refugee status in Canada, who also absconded over the Iraq War.
Up to 100 other US deserters, yet to file refugee claims, are believed to be sheltering in Canada, reviving memories of an "underground railroad," which spirited Vietnam war draft dodgers over the border in the 1960s.
IRB member Brian Goodman found in his judgment that Hinzman would be offered protection by a fair and independent military and civilian justice system should he be returned to the US.
It also ruled "Mr. Hinzman was not a conscientious objector," and that the punishment he would likely receive in the US was not "excessive or disproportionately severe."
Hinzman faces court-martial for desertion and a five-year prison term if his bid to stay in Canada is ultimately unsuccessful and he is returned home.
He fled to Canada with his wife and two-year-old son last year after learning he was to be sent to Iraq.
SUPPORT: Elon Musk’s backing for the far-right AfD is also an implicit rebuke of center-right Christian Democratic Union leader Friedrich Merz, who is leading polls German Chancellor Olaf Scholz took a swipe at Elon Musk over his political judgement, escalating a spat between the German government and the world’s richest person. Scholz, speaking to reporters in Berlin on Friday, was asked about a post Musk made on his X platform earlier the same day asserting that only the far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) party “can save Germany.” “We have freedom of speech, and that also applies to multi-billionaires,” Scholz said alongside Estonian Prime Minister Kristen Michal. “But freedom of speech also means that you can say things that are not right and do not contain
Ukraine’s military intelligence agency and the Pentagon on Monday said that some North Korean troops have been killed during combat against Ukrainian forces in Russia’s Kursk border region. Those are the first reported casualties since the US and Ukraine announced that North Korea had sent 10,000 to 12,000 troops to Russia to help it in the almost three-year war. Ukraine’s military intelligence agency said that about 30 North Korean troops were killed or wounded during a battle with the Ukrainian army at the weekend. The casualties occurred around three villages in Kursk, where Russia has for four months been trying to quash a
FREEDOM NO MORE: Today, protests in Macau are just a memory after Beijing launched measures over the past few years that chilled free speech A decade ago, the elegant cobblestone streets of Macau’s Tap Seac Square were jam-packed with people clamouring for change and government accountability — the high-water mark for the former Portuguese colony’s political awakening. Now as Macau prepares to mark the 25th anniversary of its handover to China tomorrow, the territory’s democracy movement is all but over and the protests of 2014 no more than a memory. “Macau’s civil society is relatively docile and obedient, that’s the truth,” said Au Kam-san (歐錦新), 67, a schoolteacher who became one of Macau’s longest-serving pro-democracy legislators. “But if that were totally true, we wouldn’t
TRUDEAU IN TROUBLE: US president-elect Donald Trump reacted to Chrystia Freeland’s departure, saying: ‘Her behavior was totally toxic, and not at all conducive to making deals Canadian Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland on Monday quit in a surprise move after disagreeing with Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau over US president-elect Donald Trump’s tariff threats. The resignation of Freeland, 56, who also stepped down as finance minister, marked the first open dissent against Trudeau from within his Cabinet, and could threaten his hold on power. Liberal leader Trudeau lags 20 points in polls behind his main rival, Conservative Pierre Poilievre, who has tried three times since September to topple the government and force a snap election. “It’s not been an easy day,” Trudeau said at a fundraiser Monday evening, but
RSS