A giant British tobacco company is to take the unprecedented step this week of denying there is a proven causal link between smoking and lung cancer in the first case against a cigarette firm to go to a UK court.
The unique defense, to be heard in Scotland's Court of Session, denies decades of scientific proof of such a link, which was accepted by the British Government in 1957.
Imperial Tobacco is being sued for £500,000 (US$835,000) by Margaret McTear, whose husband, Alf, a 60-a-day smoker from Beith near Glasgow, died of lung cancer in 1993. The case, which starts tomorrow, will be scrutinized across Europe by lawyers who want to bring similar actions against tobacco firms.
Margaret McTear's lawyers will call scientist Sir Richard Doll, 91, as an expert witness. It was Doll whose work in the 1950s is credited with establishing the link.
Yet Imperial says in documents filed into court: "Cigarette smoking has not been scientifically established as a cause of lung cancer. The cause or causes of lung cancer are unknown."
The company will argue that studies, such as those carried out by Doll, "report a statistical association between cigarette smoking," not complete proof. The studies "also report cancer to be statistically associated with other actors. These include race, ethnicity, religion, sex, personality, low socio-economic status, occupation, diet and education ... It is not known which, if any, of these plays a role in the causation of lung cancer."
Cameron Fyfe, McTear's solicitor, said: "I'm amazed. Many of the tobacco companies have accepted the causal link but Imperial continues to refute it."
Fyfe said Doll's decision to give evidence "strengthens our case enormously."
The case hinges on the fact that Alf McTear started smoking Imperial's John Players brand in 1964, seven years before packets had to carry a government health warning. His lawyers argue this meant he was unaware of the risks he was running. Despite denying the link, Imperial will produce press articles and broadcast transcripts to show there were significant concerns about the effects of tobacco throughout the 1960s which should have made McTear aware of the dangers. It has produced such newspaper headlines as, "Cigarette tar causes cancer," and "Million deaths from lung cancer by end of century."
It will even invoke a treatise written in 1604 by King James I who said smoking was "loathsome to the eye, hatefull to the nose, harmful to the braine [and] dangerous to the lungs."
Many experts predicted the McTear case would never reach court. The smoker launched it just before he died, and gave evidence on his deathbed without which it would have been lost.
"Alf was in a bad way. He could hardly breathe, but he insisted he wanted to get his evidence out to give us a feel for how difficult his life had become," Fyfe said.
The case has faced attempts by Imperial to stop it, and around 17 adjournments which held it up. At one stage the company demanded that Margaret McTear pay £2 million to the court to cover potential costs, a move rejected by a judge.
Alex Parsons, an Imperial spokesman, insisted it has always been keen to get to court.
"We believe this case is speculative and that our legal defense is robust," he said.
Margaret McTear said whatever the outcome, the hearing would highlight the links between ill health and smoking.
"I'm fighting for the young people, to try and get through to them the dangers of smoking," she said.
McTear, 58, a deputy manager with Help the Aged, faces financial ruin if she loses. Imperial could try to recover the costs of the hearing, and it recently served her with an order preventing her from selling her home.
Getting to court will keep a promise she made to Alf before he died.
"I gave him an understanding I would continue it, and my family will continue if anything happens to me," she said.
TIT-FOR-TAT: The arrest of Filipinos that Manila said were in China as part of a scholarship program follows the Philippines’ detention of at least a dozen Chinese The Philippines yesterday expressed alarm over the arrest of three Filipinos in China on suspicion of espionage, saying they were ordinary citizens and the arrests could be retaliation for Manila’s crackdown against alleged Chinese spies. Chinese authorities arrested the Filipinos and accused them of working for the Philippine National Security Council to gather classified information on its military, the state-run China Daily reported earlier this week, citing state security officials. It said the three had confessed to the crime. The National Security Council disputed Beijing’s accusations, saying the three were former recipients of a government scholarship program created under an agreement between the
ACCESS DISPUTE: The blast struck a house, and set cars and tractors alight, with the fires wrecking several other structures and cutting electricity An explosion killed at least five people, including a pregnant woman and a one-year-old, during a standoff between rival groups of gold miners early on Thursday in northwestern Bolivia, police said, a rare instance of a territorial dispute between the nation’s mining cooperatives turning fatal. The blast thundered through the Yani mining camp as two rival mining groups disputed access to the gold mine near the mountain town of Sorata, about 150km northwest of the country’s administrative capital of La Paz, said Colonel Gunther Agudo, a local police officer. Several gold deposits straddle the remote area. Agudo had initially reported six people killed,
Sitting around a wrestling ring, churchgoers roared as local hero Billy O’Keeffe body-slammed a fighter named Disciple. Beneath stained-glass windows, they whooped and cheered as burly, tattooed wresters tumbled into the aisle during a six-man tag-team battle. This is Wrestling Church, which brings blood, sweat and tears — mostly sweat — to St Peter’s Anglican church in the northern England town of Shipley. It is the creation of Gareth Thompson, a charismatic 37-year-old who said he was saved by pro wrestling and Jesus — and wants others to have the same experience. The outsized characters and scripted morality battles of pro wrestling fit
SUSPICION: Junta leader Min Aung Hlaing returned to protests after attending a summit at which he promised to hold ‘free and fair’ elections, which critics derided as a sham The death toll from a major earthquake in Myanmar has risen to more than 3,300, state media said yesterday, as the UN aid chief made a renewed call for the world to help the disaster-struck nation. The quake on Friday last week flattened buildings and destroyed infrastructure across the country, resulting in 3,354 deaths and 4,508 people injured, with 220 others missing, new figures published by state media showed. More than one week after the disaster, many people in the country are still without shelter, either forced to sleep outdoors because their homes were destroyed or wary of further collapses. A UN estimate