Efforts by Taiwan and others to persuade China to jointly develop oil and gas deposits under the East and South China seas are likely to fail, a new analysis by a former US government official says.
The conventional wisdom that energy is the motivating force behind Beijing’s claims to maritime territory is wrong, Harvard University fellow Holly Morrow says.
Rather, she argues in Foreign Policy this week, the disputes are a “fundamental conflict” over sovereignty in the region.
Morrow, a former US National Security Council director for Southeast Asia, argues that if energy resources were the primary issue in China’s territorial disputes, it would be easier to find solutions.
Taiwan pushed for the joint development of potential energy resources in August 2012, when President Ma Ying-jeou (馬英九) proposed the East China Sea Peace Initiative.
As part of a much-praised initiative, Ma called for Taiwan, China and Japan to pursue joint development of natural resources to pave the way for a peaceful resolution of their disputes.
“But China’s energy exploration efforts are about demonstrating sovereignty and control, not vice versa,” Morrow writes. “Energy resources are dividable and shareable; sovereignty is not.”
“Viewing the South and East China seas through the lens of sovereignty rather than energy makes these issues zero-sum and much more intractable,” she adds. “It also makes clear why efforts at joint development are likely to fail.”
Morrow writes that there have been an increasing number of conflicts in recent years over who has the right to exploit potential energy resources in the seabed under disputed waters.
And that China’s introduction of a deepwater drilling rig into contested waters around the Paracel Islands (Xisha Islands, 西沙群島) has reinforced the idea that energy is “at the core of these disputes.”
She says that the words “vast” and “huge” are regularly applied to the hydrocarbon deposits of the South China Sea, but the truth is that nobody knows.
The contested areas around the Paracel and Spratly Islands (Nansha Islands, 南沙群島), which Taiwan also claims, are little-explored, and a US Energy and Information Agency (EIA) report contends that there is probably not much oil and gas.
Morrow says that there is likely no oil and less than 100 billion cubic feet (2.83 trillion liters) of gas — “a miniscule amount roughly equivalent to one week of China’s gas consumption.”
Morrow says that the East China Sea — where Taiwan, China and Japan spar over the Diaoyutai Islands (釣魚台), known as the Senkakus in Japan — “is even more negligible in terms of hydrocarbons.”
The EIA estimates that it contains 60 million to 100 million barrels of oil — about two weeks of oil for China — and between 1 trillion and 2 trillion cubic feet of natural gas, about six months’ worth of gas consumption in China.
“If energy were truly Beijing’s concern, its obstruction of other states’ development of their oil and gas resources — which prevents new supplies from coming online — is self-defeating,” she says.
Morrow writes that there are far easier ways to procure energy in the 21st century than occupying territory or starting conflicts with international neighbors.
Morrow’s analysis comes as Beijing’s China News Service reports that China plans to build lighthouses on five disputed islands in the South China Sea.
Two of the sites, in the Paracels, are also claimed by Taiwan and Vietnam.
US Secretary of State John Kerry is expected to call for a voluntary freeze on island development when he attends a Southeast Asian foreign ministers conference in Myanmar this weekend.
‘DENIAL DEFENSE’: The US would increase its military presence with uncrewed ships, and submarines, while boosting defense in the Indo-Pacific, a Pete Hegseth memo said The US is reorienting its military strategy to focus primarily on deterring a potential Chinese invasion of Taiwan, a memo signed by US Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth showed. The memo also called on Taiwan to increase its defense spending. The document, known as the “Interim National Defense Strategic Guidance,” was distributed this month and detailed the national defense plans of US President Donald Trump’s administration, an article in the Washington Post said on Saturday. It outlines how the US can prepare for a potential war with China and defend itself from threats in the “near abroad,” including Greenland and the Panama
The Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) is maintaining close ties with Beijing, the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) said yesterday, hours after a new round of Chinese military drills in the Taiwan Strait began. Political parties in a democracy have a responsibility to be loyal to the nation and defend its sovereignty, DPP spokesman Justin Wu (吳崢) told a news conference in Taipei. His comments came hours after Beijing announced via Chinese state media that the Chinese People’s Liberation Army’s Eastern Theater Command was holding large-scale drills simulating a multi-pronged attack on Taiwan. Contrary to the KMT’s claims that it is staunchly anti-communist, KMT Deputy
RESPONSE: The government would investigate incidents of Taiwanese entertainers in China promoting CCP propaganda online in contravention of the law, the source said Taiwanese entertainers living in China who are found to have contravened cross-strait regulations or collaborated with the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) could be subject to fines, a source said on Sunday. Several Taiwanese entertainers have posted on the social media platform Sina Weibo saying that Taiwan “must be returned” to China, and sharing news articles from Chinese state media. In response, the Mainland Affairs Council (MAC) has asked the Ministry of Culture to investigate whether the entertainers had contravened any laws, and asked for them to be questioned upon their return to Taiwan, an official familiar with the matter said. To curb repeated
Myanmar has turned down an offer of assistance from Taiwanese search-and-rescue teams after a magnitude 7.7 earthquake struck the nation on Friday last week, saying other international aid is sufficient, the National Fire Agency said yesterday. More than 1,700 have been killed and 3,400 injured in the quake that struck near the central Myanmar city of Mandalay early on Friday afternoon, followed minutes later by a magnitude 6.7 aftershock. Worldwide, 13 international search-and-rescue teams have been deployed, with another 13 teams mobilizing, the agency said. Taiwan’s search-and-rescue teams were on standby, but have since been told to stand down, as