The Taipei District Court yesterday found in favor of academic Tsuang Ben-jei (莊秉潔) over charges that he had damaged the reputation of Formosa Plastics Group (FPG).
Tsuang, a professor in National Chung Hsing University’s environmental engineering department, told an environmental impact assessment committee meeting in 2011 that the exhaust gas emitted by the group’s naphtha cracker in Mailiao Township (麥寮), Yunlin County, contained heavy metals and carcinogenic substances, resulting in elevated cancer rates among residents in the area.
Saying Tsuang’s remarks had damaged its reputation, the group filed a defamation lawsuit against him with the Taipei District Prosecutors’ Office, as well as a civil lawsuit seeking NT$40 million (US$1.34 million) in compensation and a public apology in newspapers.
Prosecutors decided in June last year not to indict Tsuang because he had been invited to the meeting as an expert and his comments concerned public health and environmental protection issues, and were not defamatory.
The district court’s ruling echoed what the prosecutors said a year ago — that his remarks were based on academic research and were made with good intentions, to care for public health.
His remarks were also comments on public affairs and did not undermine the company’s reputation, the ruling said.
The company can appeal the ruling with the Taiwan High Court, the district court said.
Tsuang has won the support of many fellow academics — including former Academia Sinica president Lee Yuan-tseh (李遠哲) — who have signed a petition of support saying the group’s legal actions would have a chilling effect by restricting academic freedom in a democratic society.
Additional reporting by staff writer
Tropical depression TD22, which was over waters south of the Ryukyu Islands, is likely to develop into a tropical storm by this morning and pose a significant threat to Taiwan next week, the Central Weather Administration (CWA) said yesterday. The depression is likely to strengthen into a tropical storm named Krathon as it moves south and then veers north toward waters off Taiwan’s eastern coast, CWA forecaster Hsu Chung-yi (徐仲毅) said. Given the favorable environmental conditions for its development, TD22’s intensity would reach at least typhoon levels, Hsu said. As of 2pm yesterday, the tropical depression was about 610km east-southeast of Taiwan proper’s
RESTRICTIONS: All food items imported from the five prefectures must be accompanied by radiation and origin certificates, and undergo batch-by-batch inspection The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) on Wednesday announced that almost all produce from five Japanese prefectures affected by the 2011 Fukushima Dai-ichi nuclear power plant disaster would now be allowed into Taiwan. The five are Fukushima, Gunma, Chiba, Ibaraki and Tochigi. The only items that would still be blocked from being imported into the nation are those that are still banned from being circulated in Japan, the FDA added. With the removal of the ban, items including mushrooms, the meat of wild birds and other wild animals, and koshiabura” (foraged vegetables) would now be permitted to enter Taiwan, along with the other
A new tropical storm is expected to form by early tomorrow morning, potentially developing into a medium-strength typhoon that is to affect Taiwan through Wednesday next week, the Central Weather Administration said today. There are currently two tropical systems circulating to the east of Taiwan, agency forecaster Hsu Chung-yi (徐仲毅) said. The one currently north of Guam developed into Tropical Storm Gebi this afternoon and is expected to veer toward Japan without affecting Taiwan, Hsu said. Another tropical depression is 600km from the east coast and is likely to develp into the named storm Krathon either late tonight or early tomorrow, he said. This
DIVA-READY: The city’s deadline for the repairs is one day before pop star Jody Chiang is to perform at the Taipei Dome for the city’s Double Ten National Day celebrations The Taipei City Government has asked Farglory Group (遠雄集團) to repair serious water leaks in the Taipei Dome before Friday next week, Taipei Mayor Chiang Wan-an (蔣萬安) said yesterday, following complaints that many areas at the stadium were leaking during two baseball games over the weekend. The dome on Saturday and Sunday hosted two games in tribute to CTBC Brothers’ star Chou Szu-chi (周思齊) ahead of his retirement from the CPBL. The games each attracted about 40,000 people, filling the stadium to capacity. However, amid heavy rain, many people reported water leaking on some seats, at the entrance and exit areas, and the