Every minute that Taiwan is separate from China the likelihood increases that the nation will remain separate from China, Arthur Waldron, a professor of international relations at the University of Pennsylvania, told a forum on Capitol Hill on Wednesday.
He said he had great difficulty envisioning “in nuts and bolts terms” how unification would ever occur.
The forum entitled “Is Taiwan Defendable?” was held in a House of Representatives meeting room, and it was organized by the International Assessment and Strategy Center (IASC) and attended by congressional aides.
“Would Taiwan stop having a president? Would it stop having elections? Would it stop having a legislature?” Waldron asked.
“I just don’t see any of those things happening,” he said. “My own view is that China is probably going to change first.”
“In 30 years will there still be a standing committee of the politburo in Beijing?” he asked.
“I think it is quite unlikely, but I think that in 30 years there will still be an elected president of Taiwan,” he said.
Waldron was closing the forum in which Mark Stokes, executive director of the think tank Project 2049, discussed how submarines could change the balance of power in the Taiwan Strait; Richard Fisher, a senior fellow at IASC, argued that missile technology could deter invasion; and John Tkacik, another senior IASC fellow, discussed the legal and policy implications of expanding US weapons sales to Taiwan.
Waldron said there was currently an attempt within the “foreign policy elite” to normalize the US relationship with China and make it the same as the US relationship with democratic countries.
He said there was a suggestion that if only the US would do “the right sort of things” then all would be well with China, but he argued that if Taiwan was “stripped away,” then Japan would become isolated and the US would no longer be able to count upon Tokyo to follow either a peaceful or a pro-US policy.
He said that if Japan and South Korea were defendable, then Taiwan was just as defendable.
“Taiwan should be defended, unless we want to get a reputation for brutally abandoning our allies and being totally unreliable,” he said.
Stokes said that Taiwan had been on a 40-year quest to buy 10 to 12 diesel-electric submarines and that no other weapons system would do more to deter China from using force against the nation.
He said that submarines had the best chance of survival should China attack and they would “significantly complicate” any Chinese attempts at a blockade or invasion.
However, Stokes was not optimistic that the US or any other nation would sell submarines to Taiwan and supported the idea of Taiwan building its own.
Fisher said that following the decision by US President Barack Obama’s administration not to sell F-16C/D aircraft to Taiwan, there had been an “uptick” in pessimism.
He said that increasingly some Americans are saying Taiwan is not defendable and that at some point it would have to reach a political settlement with China.
Taiwan, he said, would lose its political freedoms “once the PRC [People’s Republic of China] gets its claws into that society and tears it apart.”
Fisher said there was an assumption that Taiwan would not be able to purchase enough military hardware to deter an attack by China, but this was not necessarily true.
He said if the US would not sell advanced F-16s to Taiwan, it should consider other weapons including a “Sensor Fuzed Munition” that is about the size of a hamburger.
It is fired as part of a missile or artillery shell, departs from the shell in mid-air, orientates itself and then, traveling at five times the speed of sound, finds its target and cuts right through it.
Fisher said the US had agreed to sell 20,000 of these to India for the price of about four F-16C/Ds.
“If Taiwan had 20,000 of these weapons it would greatly increase the island’s ability to deter a Chinese invasion force,” Fisher said.
Tkacik analyzed the laws governing US arms sales to Taiwan and concluded: “The US has a law, passed by Congress, that says it will make available to Taiwan whatever the heck it needs to defend itself. We are required to give them what they need. The world itself is a little different, but that is the law.”
SEND A MESSAGE: Sinking the amphibious assault ship, the lead warship of its class, is meant to show China the US Navy is capable of sinking their ships, an analyst said The US and allied navies plan to sink a 40,000-tonne ship at the latest Rim of the Pacific (RIMPAC) exercise to simulate defeating a Chinese amphibious assault on Taiwan. This year’s RIMPAC — the 29th iteration of the world’s largest naval exercise — involves the US, 28 partners, more than 25,000 personnel, 40 warships, three submarines and more than 150 aircraft operating in and around Hawaii from yesterday to Aug. 1, the US Navy said in a press release. The major components of the event include multidomain warfare exercises in multiship surface engagements, anti-submarine warfare and multi-axis defense of a carrier strike
Taiwanese could risk being extradited to China when traveling in countries with close ties to Beijing, Taiwan Association of University Professors deputy chairman Chen Li-fu (陳俐甫) said on Friday. Chen’s comments came after China on Friday last week announced new judicial guidelines targeting Taiwanese independence advocates. Myanmar, Cambodia, Laos and Djibouti are among the countries where Taiwanese could risk being extradited to China, he said. The Mainland Affairs Council (MAC) on Thursday elevated the travel alert for China, Hong Kong and Macau to “orange” after Beijing announced its guidelines to “severely punish Taiwanese independence diehards for splitting the country and inciting secession.” Extradition treaties
The airspace around Taiwan Taoyuan International Airport and Taipei International Airport (Songshan airport) is to be closed for an hour on July 25 and July 23 respectively, due to the Han Kuang military exercises, the Ministry of National Defense said yesterday. The annual exercise is to be held on Taiwan proper and its outlying islands from July 22 to 26. During last year’s exercise, the military conducted anti-aircraft landing drills at the Taoyuan airport for the first time, for which a one-hour no-fly ban was issued. Based on a live-fire bulletin sent out by the Maritime and Port Bureau, the nation’s
Taiwan and Thailand have signed an agreement to promote and protect bilateral investment and trade, the Executive Yuan’s Office of Trade Negotiations (OTN) said on Friday. The agreement on “Promotion and Protection of Investments” was signed by Representative to Thailand Chang Chun-fu (張俊福) and Thailand Trade and Economic Office in Taipei executive director Narong Boonsatheanwong on Thursday, the OTN said in a news release. Thailand has become the fifth trading partner to sign an investment agreement with Taiwan since 2016, following earlier agreements with the Philippines, India, Vietnam and Canada, the OTN said. The deal marks a significant milestone in the development of