Despite supporting an anti-discrimination bill drafted by Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) Legislator Cheng Li-wun (鄭麗文), a number of civic groups yesterday raised doubts about whether the bill could be implemented once it becomes law.
Representatives from several civic groups made the remarks during a public hearing at the Legislative Yuan organized by Cheng yesterday.
The bill was drafted by Cheng’s office to combat discrimination based on race, ethnicity, nationality, religion, mental or physical disabilities, sex or sexual orientation.
The draft bill would also create a separate Cabinet-level commission for human rights protection and equality.
“I agree with most of the content in the draft bill and I think the bill’s intentions are great,” said Wu Jia-zhen (吳佳臻), TransAsia Sisters Association Taiwan’s North Taiwan Office director. “But I’m also concerned [about] how this attractive bill [will] be implemented once it becomes law?”
Wu said there were already anti-discrimination clauses in several existing laws — such as in the Immigration Act (入出國及移民法) and the Act for Gender Equality in Employment (性別平等工作法) — but they have had little effect in combating discrimination because of a lack of enthusiasm among public servants.
She questioned how the proposed bill would be more effective if such attitudes do not change.
Gender/Sexuality Rights Association Taiwan secretary-general Wang Ping (王蘋) agreed.
Wang said existing laws already assigned jobs to different government institutions to fight discrimination, asking whether the proposed commission “would conflict with existing government agencies.”
Taiwan Association for Human Rights’ Advocacy and Campaign director Yeh Ting-chun (葉亭君) said the new commission must be granted independence and the power to investigate and promote anti-discrimination through education.
“If we want a commission to better protect human rights and equality, the commission must not be a passive one,” she said.
Looking into the draft bill’s details, Labor Rights Association executive director Wang Chuan-ping (王娟萍) said she did not understand why the bill excluded certain circumstances.
“Article 47 of the bill prohibits public servants from making discriminatory comments. However, Article 26 excludes many government agencies from the bill, including the Legislative Yuan,” Wang said. “But members of the Legislative Yuan are the ones who usually make the most openly discriminatory remarks.”
Wang said it didn’t make sense for Article 44 of the draft to restrict the scope of the bill “for national security reasons.”
“Acts that would really threaten national security are mentioned in other laws. Excluding application of the bill for national security reasons would result in excuses to discriminate against people legally,” she said.
She said it would be hard to define what “discrimination” is at work because employers can always come up with an excuse to avoid being charged after firing or refusing to hire someone based on ethnicity or sex.
Five countries have in the past few months canceled preferential visa treatment for Taiwan passport holders due to pressure from China, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs said yesterday. It was responding to a report by the National Audit Office that the number of countries offering preferential visa treatment to holders of Taiwan passports had dropped from 171 at the end of last year to 166 in April. In its Central Government Budget Audit Report, the National Audit Office also said that the ministry had failed to provide timely updates on the visa changes, which could affect Taiwan passport holders’ overseas travel. In response
More Taiwanese spectators at the Paris Olympics have reported having signs and banners confiscated by security staff or snatched by Chinese fans. Sandy Hsueh (薛雅俶), president of the Taiwanese Association in France, said that three security personnel confiscated a blank piece of cardboard from her at Sunday’s men’s doubles badminton final, in which Taiwan’s Lee Yang (李洋) and Wang Chi-lin (王齊麟) defeated China’s Liang Weikeng (梁偉鏗) and Wang Chang (王昶) to win their second consecutive Olympic gold medal in the event. A staff member told her they had “received an instruction from the Olympic Games saying that anything related to Taiwan or
DISCRIMINATORY: Airlines’ uniform requirements contravene the UN Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women, a watchdog said Airline companies’ appearance requirements obliging female flight attendants to wear pencil skirts and high heels are discriminatory, and they should be able to have the option to wear pants, the National Human Rights Commission said in a report yesterday. Completing a year-long probe, commission members said the uniform requirements of Taiwan’s air carriers contravened the UN Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW). To fight gender-based discrimination, government agencies should issue guidelines and require airlines to make changes so that female flight attendants have the option to wear pants, the report said. The Taoyuan Flight Attendants’ Union in
COGNITIVE WARFARE: The People’s Liberation Army’s recent military exercises near Taiwan aim to intimidate the Taiwanese public, a legislator said Two sorties of Chinese drones were detected flying around the perimeter of Taiwan proper between 6am on Saturday and 6am yesterday, according to the Ministry of National Defense. A total of 31 Chinese military aircraft — which included several drones — and 12 Chinese warships were detected operating in and near the Taiwan Strait over the 24-hour period, the ministry said. Institute for National Defense and Security Research fellow Su Tzu-yun (蘇紫雲) said the maneuvers were likely aimed at affecting public sentiment in Taiwan, demonstrating defiance toward the US’ two-plus-two talks with India and Australia, and enacting China’s polarized strategy of pushing