The proposed Economic Cooperation Framework Agreement (ECFA) between Taiwan and China will only benefit certain people and corporations and will intensify the left-right economic struggle, an academic told the Central News Agency.
The trade pact “is not an independence-unification issue, but a left-right economic social issue and the core concern is whether wealth would be re-distributed,” said Lo Chih-cheng (羅致政), a political scientist at Soochow University.
“The predicted boost to GDP after the agreement takes effect may seem impressive and appealing on the surface. However, do all those numbers and indexes announced by the government reflect people’s concerns?” Lo said.
The ECFA, which Taiwan intends to sign with China to relax trade and financial regulations in the first half of this year, is expected to increase Taiwan’s GDP by 1.72 percent, Bureau of Foreign Trade Director-General Huang Chih-peng (黃志鵬) said in October.
Lo said that the ECFA, in essence a free-trade agreement, will only benefit certain sectors and large corporations while damaging the small and medium-sized business (SME) sector — the backbone of Taiwan’s economy — and the working class.
“Let’s say a large corporation secures a NT$10 billion [US$314 million] profit and the SMEs lose NT$90 million because of the cross-strait agreement. On paper, Taiwan’s economy grows, but the NT$90 million is ‘survival money’ for the SMEs and the thousands of families behind them,” he said.
The controversial agreement reflects a fact and a concern that, while large corporations are capable of lobbying and influencing government policies, SMEs and ordinary people are left out in the cold as “the rich get richer and the poor get poorer,” Lo said.
That is why Lo thinks it is a left-right issue rather than the Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) versus the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) or an independence-unification issue.
“It’s all about making choices. A government is obliged to pursue the interests of the majority,” he said.
Lo said he saw some contradictory facts and mistakes in Taiwan’s negotiation process. While the government said the agreement is more of a framework with the actual content waiting to be formulated, he said, it announced a concrete GDP growth prediction at the same time.
Also, Taiwan has said on several occasions that it is eager to complete the deal in the first half of this year, which is against the basic rule of negotiation, he said.
“When you set a timetable before the negotiations, you tie your hands behind your back and put yourself at a disadvantage,” he said.
He said the government also needed to thoroughly explain different negotiations scenarios to the public and let people know what sacrifices they might have to make to secure which benefits.
The government said Taiwan is in danger of being marginalized and hollowed out after the ASEAN-China free trade arrangement went into effect because Taiwan-made products will have higher tariffs imposed on them.
Lo denounced that argument, saying that Taiwan’s biggest competitor is South Korea, not ASEAN countries, and the government has “intentionally magnified the impact of the ASEAN-China free trade agreement.”
On the contrary, not only will Taiwan-made products not enjoy easier access to the ASEAN countries, but more local businesses will relocate to China, he said.
An ECFA can neither solve the problem of unemployment and capital outflows, nor attract Taiwanese businessmen to re-invest in Taiwan, he said, unless Taiwan is equipped with fine-tuned policies on labor, industrial parks, environmental protection and tax incentives.
It is wrong to place the agreement with China at the focus of Taiwan’s national development strategy. Taiwan needs an alternative plan including industry upgrades and the establishing pioneering sectors, Lo said.
It is the government’s responsibility to identify what those sectors are and play a major role in fostering their development, he said.
“There’s not one country I know of that formulates its national policy on outbound investment. What Taiwan needs to do is to attract foreign direct investment and create jobs,” Lo said.
“Businessmen will always go for profit and short-term goals, and there’s nothing wrong with that. But a government has to look at this from a long-term perspective,” Lo said.
There is always the possibility that China is engaged in the negotiations for more than economic benefits, Lo said, adding that China would still eye the eventual goal of political gain.
WANG RELEASED: A police investigation showed that an organized crime group allegedly taught their clients how to pretend to be sick during medical exams Actor Darren Wang (王大陸) and 11 others were released on bail yesterday, after being questioned for allegedly dodging compulsory military service or forging documents to help others avoid serving. Wang, 33, was catapulted into stardom for his role in the coming-of-age film Our Times (我的少女時代). Lately, he has been focusing on developing his entertainment career in China. The New Taipei District Prosecutors’ Office last month began investigating an organized crime group that is allegedly helping men dodge compulsory military service using falsified documents. Police in New Taipei City Yonghe Precinct at the end of last month arrested the main suspect,
Eleven people, including actor Darren Wang (王大陸), were taken into custody today for questioning regarding the evasion of compulsory military service and document forgery, the New Taipei District Prosecutors’ Office said. Eight of the people, including Wang, are suspected of evading military service, while three are suspected of forging medical documents to assist them, the report said. They are all being questioned by police and would later be transferred to the prosecutors’ office for further investigation. Three men surnamed Lee (李), Chang (張) and Lin (林) are suspected of improperly assisting conscripts in changing their military classification from “stand-by
LITTORAL REGIMENTS: The US Marine Corps is transitioning to an ‘island hopping’ strategy to counterattack Beijing’s area denial strategy The US Marine Corps (USMC) has introduced new anti-drone systems to bolster air defense in the Pacific island chain amid growing Chinese military influence in the region, The Telegraph reported on Sunday. The new Marine Air Defense Integrated System (MADIS) Mk 1 is being developed to counter “the growing menace of unmanned aerial systems,” it cited the Marine Corps as saying. China has constructed a powerful defense mechanism in the Pacific Ocean west of the first island chain by deploying weapons such as rockets, submarines and anti-ship missiles — which is part of its anti-access/area denial (A2/AD) strategy against adversaries — the
Former Taiwan People’s Party chairman Ko Wen-je (柯文哲) may apply to visit home following the death of his father this morning, the Taipei Detention Center said. Ko’s father, Ko Cheng-fa (柯承發), passed away at 8:40am today at the Hsinchu branch of National Taiwan University Hospital. He was 94 years old. The center said Ko Wen-je was welcome to apply, but declined to say whether it had already received an application. The center also provides psychological counseling to people in detention as needed, it added, also declining to comment on Ko Wen-je’s mental state. Ko Wen-je is being held in detention as he awaits trial